4 ms·
If true, doesn't this mean that you might possibly pass on memories to your children?
by HeyLaughingBoy 18y ago
If true, doesn't this mean that you might possibly pass on memories to your children?
- gruseom 18y agoI have a hunch that Lamarck will eventually be rehabilitated.
- freewheel 18y agoDoes any one know of work that suggests that advantageous experience during life can be encoded in DNA and passed on? That would be Lamarckian. What would not be Lamarckian: (1) the example of this story; (2) environmental factors increasing mutation rate; (3) viral infection inserting new DNA. Others that would not count?
- gruseom 18y agoRight, if Retric's comment is correct, then the example of this story certainly isn't a vindication of Lamarck. But it might be a step in that direction. I'm just an ignorant outsider, but the absolute dismissal of Lamarck always felt like a dogmatism to me. I'm suspicious whenever I hear words like "can't" or "never" repeated in a slightly too loud and rigid way. Remember when everyone "knew" that brain cells could "never" regenerate?
- glymor 18y agoLamarck ideas are nearly always advanced as a form of genetics denialism. Lysenkoism being the prime example. Also how would any research done now rehabilitate Lamarck? He had no evidence for his hypothesis and his theory was incredibly vague. It's as if he had suggested a hypothesis of a carriage without horses and you were now willing to credit him with the invention of the automobile.
- gruseom 18y agoLamarck is now remembered for the single idea that acquired traits can be inherited. When I say his name that's all I'm referring to. Similarly, Democritus is remembered for the idea of "atoms" despite having nothing to do with modern physics. This is just historical convention.
- Retric 18y agoNo, your not storing your memories in the cells that you use to have children. They are suggesting nerons are using their DNA like a message board to store information, but it's specific to each cell. I suspect like most processes in our cells DNA is involved, but what's changing is the wrapper around the DNA not the DNA's code. Edit: think of DNA as program code, and what's wrapped around it as RAM.
- trapper 18y agoOf course, last year we thought introns we junk dna, a few years ago there was no such thing as epigenetic information and rna was only an intermediary. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/bv.fcgi?tool=bookshelf&call=bv.View..ShowSection&searchterm=methylation&rid=cell.figgrp.2114 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/bv.fcgi?tool=bookshelf&...