4 ms·
Declining As A Manufacturer, Japan Weighs Reinvention
- rollypolly 15y ago"We can follow the United States into a more postindustrial economy, or we can follow Germany into high-end manufacturing, but we shouldn’t be trying to compete with China in mass production." ouch In other words, "Do we want to compete with America or Germany?" Maybe they need to find another option.
- sliverstorm 15y agoMock the two proposed alternatives, provide no alternatives yourself? That's helpful.
- rollypolly 15y agoYou're right that providing a solution would be more helpful, but I have none to propose. I didn't mean to be flippant. I was just noting the difficult position they're in.
- hrktb 15y agoI thought Japan was already in the same direction as Germany regarding high-end manufacturing. It was just more diverse and also did middle and low end at the same time. I think it has the potential to find original ways, but going head to head with Germany wouldn't put it in a bad place either. Still i'd hope the shift to a more software oriented business culture occurs.
- saraid216 15y agoThis, basically. I thought it was patently obvious from the article that high-end manufacturing was something Japan would find to be a good fit.
- dmix 15y agoSoftware and robotics. Software engineers and designers are already in high demand. Robotics are getting close to having wider industrial/consumer applications. Once Korea and China's factory wages go up high enough and the price of automation lowers, they'll start to invest heavily in robotics (ala Foxconn).
- sliverstorm 15y agoSoftware and robotics. Software's an uphill battle with the culture they have- although perhaps embracing advanced robotics, and the accompanying sophisticated software demands, might help change that.
- rawfalafel 15y agoWhy do you say software's an uphill battle? With so much attention on web technologies like YouTube and Facebook in Japan right now and with the economy so sluggish for so long, I would hope that Japan (and Korea) could find it in them to focus more on developing software in their own country.
- sliverstorm 15y agoWhen it comes to your profession, Japanese culture places significantly more value on making tangible things as compared to the intangible. It is mentioned in passing in the article; the idea is called "monozukuri". Imagine an old-fashioned craftsman who takes immense pride in working with his hands on something like blades, clockwork or fine jewelry. That sort of mentality is built into their culture.
- chris_wot 15y agoI'm curious why you think that they don't have innovators who are willing to take risks or do things in a non-traditional way. Saying that something is "baked in" to a culture has never stopped people from challenging the status quo. As their economy falters, I feel that they will have more people who will be willing to innovate. In short, I'd not write them off because of perceived cultural mores. It's more than likely that your view is either wrong, or misjudged.
- skylan_q 15y agoFor those who read the 2nd page, you'll see that there is no decline, just changes. The headline is agitprop. The Yen has increased in value against the US dollar greatly in the past decade, yet Japan still manages to manufacture and export. It's defending the myth that currency devaluation is required to have a positive balance of trade.
- arupchak 15y agoI was hoping for more insight into why the Japanese factories are unable to keep up with the lower costs from other Asian factories. Japanese manufacturing has always had a strong reputation with continuous improvement in their factories. This supposedly leads to lowered costs through efficiency. I am assuming that even with the decades of improvements, the lower wages of the other countries are still able to bring down the overall cost.
- minikomi 15y agoComparing the costs of living might be a good place to start looking
- stonemetal 15y agoIt depends on how much lower income countries copy their innovations in manufacturing process.
- kqr2 15y agoThere was a recent BBC podcast by Peter Day which examines this very issue: http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/radio/worldbiz/worldbiz_20120414-0030a.mp3 http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/radio/worldbiz/worldbiz_... The last twenty years in Japan look to have been abject grey economic failure. It seems that successive attempts to restart he economy have not worked. But if you look around Tokyo it's a country that still appears very rich. So what is going on here?
- kalleboo 15y agoHere's a debunking of Eamonn Fingleton who is interviewed on that show http://spikejapan.wordpress.com/2012/01/15/spiked-eamonn-fingleton/ http://spikejapan.wordpress.com/2012/01/15/spiked-eamonn-fin...
- kijin 15y ago> One of the biggest questions, economists say, is whether Japan, and by extension Asia's newer export-oriented economies, will learn how to foster innovation, nurturing the Apples, Googles, Facebooks I'm pessimistic that this will happen any time soon in Japan, or any other country in the Far East, or pretty much every country except a select few. That kind of innovation is almost universally looked down upon in those cultures. You're supposed to be employed in a large corporation that makes tangible goods, not sit in front of a screen and churn out intellectual property. Yes, they would love to make a billion dollars, too. But no, the sight of a bunch of college-dropout geeks doing what American startups typically do would be abhorrent enough to drive all investors a thousand kilometers away. You would be a shame to everyone around you. Your parents will not know how to explain themselves to their neighbors. Your high school teachers will deny that they ever taught you. I seriously hope that somebody somewhere will say "F U" to all of that and just build something. Don't even target people in the same country, just sell it directly to everyone around the world. But even then, the sight of you straddling your MacBook in T-shirts and underpants like a hikikomori would be considered a shame to everyone around you. At least until you buy a sports car with your hard-earned foreign currency.
- diminish 15y agoThe same factor seems to prevail everywhere from Europe, Russia to Japan. Everyone thinks it would be easy to ignite a Silicon Valley by government will. The truth is that a lot of forces are in place which makes a startup culture a difficult thing to create.
- replax 15y agoWhile I kind of agree with you, I have to add a few things. Especially concerning the startup culture in Japan. Yes, it is looked down upon by most, however, it exists. Compared to SV or London or Berlin it is fairly small, but it is there. However, the exposure they get is very limited. It seems to be somewhat shut-off, mainly caused by a language barrier. Nearly everything is in Japanese, with little incentive to go international. Also, many people do not understand english well enough to participate in international communities or do not feel the urge to. For example, look at mixi (it's a social network with roughly 15m members in japan, exists for i think 7 years+, mixi.jp), they had a huge userbase before facebook was popular in japan, even before facebook was really popular anywhere. however, their website is still only in japanese and to sign-up, you have to have a japanese cell phone email-address (for account confirmation). They are artificially locking people out and considering that japanese people increasingly go abroad/have friends outside of Japan, they migrate to facebook. Still, mixi does not move. What I think is missing, is obviously the acceptance, as you mentioned, but also the incentive to go international(, unless the service involves billing). It's the internet and not a local sweets shop. By the way, there are also Japanese investors looking for startup and there are websites where they exchange ideas and whatnot, but it is all in Japanese.