2 ms·
The article goes into detail about how the framers did not do this thing you claim they did; for instance, in Hamilton's defense of the Senate as trier of impea
by tptacek 3y ago
The article goes into detail about how the framers did not do this thing you claim they did; for instance, in Hamilton's defense of the Senate as trier of impeachments, rather than the judiciary, in Federalist 66.
- rayiner 3y agoFederalist 66 indicates the opposite. That the principle of separation of powers is so entrenched in the Constitution, that objections were raised to giving the Senate the quasi-judicial power to try impeachments, even though that was (1) explicitly incorporated into the Constitution by design, and (2) was designed that way to address the separation-of-power problem that could arise if the executive could prosecute legislators in the courts. The framers thought very hard about, explicitly codified, and had to justify even that explicit and special-purpose deviation from the separation of powers.
- tptacek 3y agoSo just in this one very specific case of the Senate literally taking over the Judiciary's entire role was it the legitimate design of our system that there be shared responsibility.
- rayiner 3y agoIn this one case which doesn’t even seem necessarily to be a judicial function to begin with (since it relates to the internal working of the government, not the public), the framers not only wrote the deviation from separation of powers into the constitutional text, but felt the need to justify that departure by explaining that in this unique context, mixing the powers is necessary to preserve the separation of powers overall.
- tptacek 3y agoAnd the courts-martial system?