7 ms·
This is probably a death knell for Goldman's entire consumer banking division. Ever single one of their products (including the Marcus savings account, which is
by paxys 3y ago
This is probably a death knell for Goldman's entire consumer banking division. Ever single one of their products (including the Marcus savings account, which is now the sole remaining one) has been a costly failure.
- odiroot 3y agoThey went very aggressively with Marcus offering here in UK. Had the most attractive rates for savings and ISAs for a time. And then... they just gave up? Their Android app was actually quite nice.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoAre there any alternatives to Marcus? It has felt like too good of a deal to last.
- smugma 3y agoBetterment and Wealthfront both offer higher rates than Marcus. 4.75-5%. They also have higher FDIC limits due to how they spread your money.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Covzire 3y agoI'm currently seeing 5.05% APY from a CITbank savings account.
- hellcow 3y agoCareful with them. They keep you at a high APY for a period of time, then they silently drop your interest rate and create a new "type" of savings account for new customers which offers the proper high rate -- you have to notice they did this, since they deliberately don't alert you. They do this over and over again. When I saw what they were doing, I withdrew all my money, and they even built a little popup into their mobile app... "Stay and we'll give you the rate we promised you all this time!" I don't have the time or patience for Comcast-style tactics with my savings account. I moved it into Robinhood Gold and am getting 5%, fully insured, with no stress about them trying to screw me over with an account shell game.
- Covzire 3y agoI'll keep an eye on it, thanks.
- etrautmann 3y agoCash just sitting untouched in my Vanguard account's default money market is earning more than my Marcus account. I had to transfer everything out of Marcus because there was no point in using it.
- etrautmann 3y agoAs of right now, Marcus is yielding 4.4% APY while Vanguard Federal Money Market Fund (VMFXX) is paying 5.3%
- symlinkk 3y agoThat isn’t FDIC insured like Marcus (or other HYSA) are.
- paxys 3y agoTrue, but Vanguard has "too big to fail" insurance.
- hagy 3y agoThe default settlement account, Vanguard Federal Money Market Fund, has incredibly low credit risk because its assets are short-term US Federal gov debt and Federal Reserve repurchase agreements. [1] Neither of those entities have substantial default risk. Further, the global financial chaos of significant defaults from either of those entities would likely render FDIC insurance ineffective because too many banks would fail simultaneously due to their assets in those classes. [1] https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/mutual-funds/profile/vmfxx#portfolio-composition https://investor.vanguard.com/investment-products/mutual-fun...
- dgrin91 3y agoUFB Direct has the highest FDIC insured savings account I've seen, 5.25% (and its been there for a while) https://www.ufbdirect.com/ https://www.ufbdirect.com/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- initplus 3y agoWhat is the underlying reason these consumer offerings have been such a failure? Something like a savings account should be the closest thing to free money there is - stick the cash into t bills, collect a margin on top and pass the rest back to the customer. Do the marketing/cs costs really outweigh the margin? Or is it some issue with how the assets backing the account are invested?
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoI do recall that the way at least the Apple Card deal was structured ended up extremely unfavorable to GS. It seems that part of the reason the Apple Card deal went so poorly for GS is because the initial negotiation and terms of the agreement heavily favored Apple. So perhaps it was just lack of knowledge of the industry in a big way that tanked this deal.
- mvc 3y agoGoldman is known for servicing ultra-wealthy and business clients. Consumer finance seems like a completely different beast to me. Tighter margins. Lots of low-paid call center staff and low-paid managers to crack the whip. Folks at Goldman would rather be on the golf course doing shady deals with Trump and Musk.
- initplus 3y agoI guess I still don't understand... how much customer service do you need to run a savings account? How do you even screw that up? Operating a savings account like this one should be close to just picking money off the free money tree. It's wild to think that it costs them more to operate this than the margin they take off it.
- dylan604 3y agoYou seem to think savings account do not get withdrawn against. If you take the customers cash to put into a T-bill but the customer withdrawals money before the T-bill matures, where do you get their cash from to honor the request? Not everyone uses offerings in the manner the offerer expects. As software types, this is familiar territory. If you design a thing with only the happy path in mind while never allowing for that path not being followed, you’re in for a very rough time.
- brentm 3y agoThey've been signaling they were pulling out of consumer for the last few quarters.