4 ms·
You can exercise judgment in choosing a topic: fair enough. Within that topic, you can present all the facts that you know, or just the ones that support a cer
by kazinator 3y ago
You can exercise judgment in choosing a topic: fair enough.
Within that topic, you can present all the facts that you know, or just the ones that support a certain narrative.
- tptacek 3y agoThe facts you know are also selected subjectively, both by yourself and by the people who make you available to those facts.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 3y agoYes, and then bias is also a statistical phenomenon too, yadda yadda. But we all understand we're talking about the subset of bias that any specific actor can introduce due to ignorance or ulterior motives, and could in principle choose otherwise. Objectively unbiased reporting may be impossible, but intellectual honesty is possible, and should be required of people more.
- zogrodea 3y agoAgreed. Even if one cannot achieve an ideal, there is no reason why one should not try their hardest to live up to it, instead of abandoning it as "all or nothing".
- paulddraper 3y ago> Within that topic, you can present all the facts that you know, or just the ones that support a certain narrative. Let's say you are reporting on the elevated rate of gun violence in Chicago compared to other US cities. Which of the following facts do you include in your story? (For sake of argument, assume these are factually accurate statements.) 1. Chicago votes predominately Democrat. 2. Chicago has a higher poverty rate than other cities. 3. Chicago has a large black and Hispanic population. 4. Chicago has more gangs than other cities.
- mcpackieh 3y agoWhy not all of those facts? It's only four short sentences, it won't take up much space on a printed newspaper let alone an online article. Throw in some more facts about American gun crime rates vs other countries for good measure, some facts comparing Chicago to other American cities, etc.
- kazinator 3y agoIf it's your intent to report facts about gun violence in Chicago, and only that, then dropping those other facts detracts from what you're doing. It makes it look like you're insinuating possible causes. Like that voting Democrat leads to gun violence, or that poverty causes gun violence, or that hispanics and blacks perpetrate gun violence. By mentioning certain remotely related facts, it looks as if you're hinting at giving an interpretation of the central facts. If you want to convey facts about a topic like gun violence in Chicago, then stick to facts closely relevant to it. Like different ways of slicing up the data. You might show a density map of where in Chicago most of it has happened over a certain period, or demographics about gun violence. Now if you want to explore a link between gun violence and something else like poverty, then you have to get your ducks in a row about that. Such a subject deserves to be treated by a sophisticated researcher with an expert background in statistics. If that researcher postulates some kind of link, they have to look at all the reasons why that might be false, not only true.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe idea is to report all the facts that at least a substantial minority of the public believe to be relevant, regardless of which way they swing politically. All of those facts qualify under this standard, and also the ones I suggested as well. If you leave out the part about Chicago being a Democratic stronghold city, half the American public are going to be yelling that fact at the article and concluding that the writer is biased. And if you leave out the comparison of American gun violence to other countries, you'll have the same accusations of bias coming from other readers. If you want to preempt those accusations of bias, then you need to cover your bases and present all the facts that the public may believe to be relevant. Even those facts which you personally believe to be irrelevant distractions from the narrative you prefer.