3 ms·

I don't doubt your expertise, but don't financial people bring predictability to the world by assigning a value to everything? I agree, rich get richer, but 99/

I don't doubt your expertise, but don't financial people bring predictability to the world by assigning a value to everything? I agree, rich get richer, but 99/100 of cases, rich always get richer. See the pandemic for example - Govt tried to help the poor, but the rich made a killing. In anycase, I am interested to know why you think so, and would appreciate pointers to any reading.

lotsofpulp 3y ago
> Govt tried to help the poor, but the rich made a killing. That might be because the government gave the rich much more money than the poor.
- underwatersea 3y ago
  They did not. Well a little bit with PPA loans, but that was more business targeted. The main issue was causing inflation, which increased the values of assets, which rich people have the most (real estate, stock, cryptocurrency, luxury cars, etc...). I think the governments wrong doing was shutting down work for low income earners (restaurants, gyms, etc...). And then trying to help with stimulus checks, but sending it income based rather then if you still had a good paying job. I got a stimulus check but absolutely did not need it. I used mine to book a flight to Texas in 2020 with my family and enjoy a nice week of water parks (we all had covid prior).
  - lotsofpulp 3y ago
    Targeting businesses…which are more often owned by richer people than poorer people. I know lots of business owners that made out very well from PPP (myself included). The whole thing was an exercise in ensuring the social ordering remained in place. Otherwise, the government easily could have given people more cash, rather than go via their bosses. https://www.investopedia.com/where-ppp-money-went-5216725 https://www.investopedia.com/where-ppp-money-went-5216725 > Almost all PPP loans are expected to be forgiven with 94% of eligible small businesses in the U.S. receiving one or more loans under the program. Roughly 25% of PPP loan funds went directly to workers who would have lost their jobs. The rest (75%) went to business owners, shareholders, creditors, and suppliers of companies receiving loans. > Most of the negative outcome is blamed on the untargeted nature of the program due to the lack of administrative capacity in the U.S. to administer a program of this type. >Ultimately some percentage of PPP loan funds that went to businesses reinforced the company's bottom line in the form of windfall profit.

lotsofpulp 3y ago

> Govt tried to help the poor, but the rich made a killing. That might be because the government gave the rich much more money than the poor.

underwatersea 3y ago
They did not. Well a little bit with PPA loans, but that was more business targeted. The main issue was causing inflation, which increased the values of assets, which rich people have the most (real estate, stock, cryptocurrency, luxury cars, etc...). I think the governments wrong doing was shutting down work for low income earners (restaurants, gyms, etc...). And then trying to help with stimulus checks, but sending it income based rather then if you still had a good paying job. I got a stimulus check but absolutely did not need it. I used mine to book a flight to Texas in 2020 with my family and enjoy a nice week of water parks (we all had covid prior).
- lotsofpulp 3y ago
  Targeting businesses…which are more often owned by richer people than poorer people. I know lots of business owners that made out very well from PPP (myself included). The whole thing was an exercise in ensuring the social ordering remained in place. Otherwise, the government easily could have given people more cash, rather than go via their bosses. https://www.investopedia.com/where-ppp-money-went-5216725 https://www.investopedia.com/where-ppp-money-went-5216725 > Almost all PPP loans are expected to be forgiven with 94% of eligible small businesses in the U.S. receiving one or more loans under the program. Roughly 25% of PPP loan funds went directly to workers who would have lost their jobs. The rest (75%) went to business owners, shareholders, creditors, and suppliers of companies receiving loans. > Most of the negative outcome is blamed on the untargeted nature of the program due to the lack of administrative capacity in the U.S. to administer a program of this type. >Ultimately some percentage of PPP loan funds that went to businesses reinforced the company's bottom line in the form of windfall profit.