36 ms·
The choice of which dead children we must see is political and commercial. AP has many dozens of journalists staffed in Israel, and allegedly only a couple stri
by tptacek 3y ago
The choice of which dead children we must see is political and commercial. AP has many dozens of journalists staffed in Israel, and allegedly only a couple stringers in Syria, where over 300,000 civilians have died in the last 10 years. The children killed in Tigray (tens of thousands) are through the lens of this article less important for us to see than those of Uvalde.
- sockaddr 3y agoI suspect it isn't political but rather that being a journalist in Israel is safer than being a journalist in Syria. So naturally one will be represented more than the other. No politics there.
- hubb 3y agotry telling the family of shireen abu akleh about how safe it was to be a journalist in israel
- criddell 3y agoThey didn’t say Israel is safe, just safer than Syria. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_during_the_Syrian_civil_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_journalists_killed_dur...
- tptacek 3y agoSyria is much less safe than Israel is, but millions of people live there, and newswires can buy information from them; that's what a stringer is. The allegations I've read are that, on a good day in 2018, AP might have had one stringer to get information from. That's a decision AP made, not a reality it had to conform to.
- bhouston 3y agoIt is safe to be a Western journalist in Israel, but if you are Arab reporting on Israel from an Arab perspective, it is quite dangerous. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/20/world/middleeast/palestian-journalist-killing-shireen.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/20/world/middleeast/palestia... https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/10/30/reuters-al-jazeera-journalists-targeted-in-lebanon-strike-press-group https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/10/30/reuters-al-jazeera... https://reliefweb.int/report/occupied-palestinian-territory/widespread-targeting-journalists-gaza-amid-israeli-attacks-enar https://reliefweb.int/report/occupied-palestinian-territory/...
- mminer237 3y agoThat was in an area administered by Palestine. It can't really be considered "in Israel" at all. I think it strengthens his point that it's hard to get comprehensive journalism in an area either controlled or actively contested by terrorists.
- Gabriel54 3y agoThe Palestinian Authority administers the West Bank. No country in the world considers them a terrorist organization.
- tptacek 3y agoOur thinking here is, we're going to settle Israel/Palestine once and for all, on this message board thread; a pity, we think, nobody ever thought of just tossing the question to us in the first place. The lives that could have been saved.
- mminer237 3y ago> or actively contested by terrorists. The Palestinian Authority isn't a terrorist organization, but Hamas does maintain an active presence in the West Bank. The government also explicitly encourages terrorist attacks in the region through the Palestinian Authority Martyrs Fund.
- gyudin 3y agoKinda strange. First article says Palestinian leaders rejected request about investigation under international supervision and refused to show the bullet, claiming it was an armor piercing round. While IDF soldiers use standard ammunition.
- bhouston 3y agoThe general international consensus is that Israeli soldiers killed her, but you can personally claim anything you want, that is your right: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Shireen_Abu_Akleh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killing_of_Shireen_Abu_Akleh
- polytely 3y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 3y agoThe piece you cite here at no point supports (or even makes) the outlandish claim you've made here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- oa335 3y agoIt doesn’t make the point outright, but the reports that 80%ish of the journalists were killed in their homes, many with their kids and families, could at least support the claim that Israel is “targeting” journalists.
- tptacek 3y agoIt does no such thing.
- oa335 3y agoAnd why is that?
- nearbuy 3y agoWhat do you mean? The article you linked never claims 80% of journalists were killed in their homes, or anything near that number. Where did you get that number from?
- oa335 3y agoI did not link the article. I was responding to the comment that stridently declared that the article provides no support for the claim that Israel is targeting journalists. I got the number by actually fully reading the article, counting up the number of Palestinians who were listed as killed in their home or with their families (around 30) and then of the remaining, reading the provided linked reports that gave more detail as to how the journalists died (around 8). 38 died in their homes, 49 Palestinian journalists killed totally, hence around 80 percent. I may be off by a couple since here or there, but to say that the article “doesn’t mention anything near that number” is a stretch.
- paulddraper 3y agoThat is probably true. Doesn't change the consequence, but probably true.
- rngname22 3y agoYep. And I wonder why we don't see more childhood cancer death images linked to the multinational chemical conglomerates and industrial corps that pollute our waterways and air continuously, it couldn't possibly have to do with corporate donors (sorry, advertising customers) to media or the incentive for media to only cover deaths that generate reader engagement and subscribers. Kill 10,000 people 5-15 years earlier than their otherwise natural trajectory for death by dumping PCBs in the river (ignoring that additional cohorts will have an increased disease burden going forward for....decades? Centuries? Who knows if you can un-shit this bed), no one gives a shit apart from a symbolic fine of 1% of annual revenue 20 years later. Certainly no actual punishment for those involved. Kill a couple thousand with a plane into a building and the world's most powerful country starts a war.
- rightbyte 3y agoI know nothing about the case, but you got the lurking benefit of doubt for those more abstract killings. Like the poor guy that thought it was a good idea to put Freon in refrigerators. Oh, and also put led in gasoline. Some people can more or only feel sorry for small children or animals, because they are obviously innocent, while a grown up could have done something to deserve it. I think that is a failure to the extreme of having a hard time dealing with more abstract (maybe indirect is a better word?) crimes.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gerdesj 3y ago"Oh, and also put led in gasoline." Freon and lead were engineering decisions. Both had properties that fixed a burning issue at the time. Unfortunately they also had ... side effects that became apparent later. Neither involved "a guy", they involved entire countries, blocs and multi national enterprises.
- c54 3y agoThe guy in question knew very well about the negative effects of lead[0]. The way in which you're right is that under capitalism, the profit motive distorts and chews up any moral precepts of any individual. The machine demands efficiency no matter how many lives it consumes. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Midgley_Jr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Midgley_Jr.
- sctb 3y agoYes, surely. I'm curious if you have more to say about this. Semi-relatedly, one could read this article as a journalist attempting to convince the public to normalize a more emotionally potent form of journalism.
- tptacek 3y agoI feel generally defensive of journalism, especially on HN, and I'm a little reluctant to dissect it too much. I worry about the utility and unintended effects of emotionally potent journalism on a consumer public so locked into narratives, and with such superficial, social-media-mediated connection to actual journalism. I'll just add that when I say "commercial", I mean exactly that. This is AP's former Bureau Chief in Jerusalem: Matti [a former AP journo and critic] states that the AP’s Jerusalem bureau – like all other major news operations based in Israel and the Palestinian territories – employs too many reporters because of this hostile obsession with the Jews. The truth is the story of Israel is that of a nation rising from the ashes of the worst genocide in human history, being attacked from all sides upon its inception. Depending on your point of view, it’s also a story about the persecuted becoming the persecutors. All of this, of course, is happening to the people of the Bible, the descendants of the Hebrew slaves who were led out of Egypt by Moses and from whose ranks emerged Jesus Christ. It’s as if a new chapter of the Bible is being written in our times. Whether you think the Bible is mythology or the word of God is beside the point. The point is we are all human beings who love a good story, and this one is particularly good. I read that a couple days ago and it's been pinging back and forth in my head ever since.
- rightbyte 3y ago> "It’s as if a new chapter of the Bible is being written in our times." It's debatable who fits in as the slaves in Egypt in the allegory ...
- civilitty 3y agoThat's why it makes such a good story (née clusterfuck). No matter where you sit, you can pretend to be the hero of the story or the persecuted victim.
- bhouston 3y agoThe main difference with Syria is that those who are doing the killing are not funded by the US. Israel on the other hand is funded by the US government, especially its military. On the other hand, it is estimated that 90% of the deaths are by the Syrian government, which is not funded at all by the US Government: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Syrian_civil_war https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casualties_of_the_Syrian_civil...
- tptacek 3y agoSee, this is exactly what I mean.
- yodsanklai 3y ago> Israel on the other hand is funded by the US government, especially its military Generally speaking, Israel is part of the West and we expect them to have a higher standard than some dictatorship. That being said, how many deaths can be attributed to the US in Iraq or Afghanistan? I assume order of magnitude higher than what we're witnessing in Gaza. It seems Israel doesn't get the same free pass for some reason.
- differingopinio 3y agoThe Israelis have killed more children in two months in Gaza than the US killed in 20 years of war in Afghanistan.
- tptacek 3y agoThere's a reason it's Afghanistan people cite here, and not Iraq. Even counts of dead children aren't neutral. There's no way around taking time to learn about things; you can't sum things up with a grisly picture or a grim scorecard. Or you can, I don't know, maybe it works great. It's what we've been trying to do up 'til now. How's it going?
- differingopinio 3y ago
- kej 3y agoReminds me of one of my favorite quotes from the afterword of Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States: >But there is no such thing as a pure fact, innocent of interpretation. Behind every fact presented to the world—by a teacher, a writer, anyone—is a judgment. The judgment that has been made is that this fact is important, and that other facts, omitted, are not important.
- lovecg 3y agoThat quote tells more about Zinn’s views than anything true about the world. Explains a lot about that propaganda piece of a book that has little to do with actual history.
- sctb 3y agoThis is also a feature (the defining feature, IMO) of causal narratives.
- tptacek 3y agoRight. It's a thing to be aware of, not a disqualifier; if you simply filter out any content delivered with an agenda, you can't learn anything.
- sctb 3y agoI'm going to agree harder: it's a thing to be aware of as a fundamental mechanism which may or may not be related to agenda or judgement in any given instance.
- hackeraccount 3y agoTrue enough but the poison is in the dose. Too much and you're left with Nihilism. The trouble revolves around how much judgement is required on any given subject. On the right subject people can come perilously close to laying out facts devoid of interpretation; on the wrong subject either no one can or no one believes anyone can - which is pretty much the same thing.
- phpisthebest 3y agoAP and other mainstream "news" sites only care when Jewish people from Israel kill someone, they are of the "wrong" or unprotected religion. Other peoples in the region can kill with impunity and no one will report on it at all. Syria, Yemen,Lebanon, Afghanistan, Iraq, etc... silence is the game If a Jewish persons defends themselves though, that is front page news.
- tptacek 3y agoI don't know if that's true. Problematically, I don't know if anybody else does either. The implications are significant either way. Under those circumstances, amping up the emotional impact of the stories being told seems worrisome. But not amping it up has had poor outcomes too, so who knows?
- handy2000 3y agoThere are many reasons for this, one of the key reasons being less insidious than you imply. Americans see Israelis as people with the same "western" values, same cultural and ethical norms. Most Americans are not shocked by tribal violence in Yemen (as despicable as it is by general humanistic standards), but can relate and identify with Israelis both experiencing violence and inflicting it. I agree with you that we need to always provide clear context for what is happening in this specific situation, not rush to judgment and not to be as reactive in general. Israelis are defending themselves, Hamas is clearly using their own people as human shields. Saying that, Israel does have other options in this war, options that would reduce the civilian death count (e.g. allowing women and children leave Gaza for Israel, even at the cost of an increased terrorist activity).
- dclowd9901 3y agoNothing in this article denies any of this. Not sure what your point is. Everything is political.
- tptacek 3y agoRereading this comment, I'm seeing that I wrote that tens of thousands of children died in the Tigray conflicts, but that's not the case (or what I meant to write); that's an estimate of the total civilian death toll.
- C6JEsQeQa5fCjE 3y agoThe choice is not difficult to understand. What prompts more of a concern about these particular dead children (civillians, really, but since the topic focuses on children, let us stick with that) than others, is largely about the level of support from the USA government and military for the party doing the killing (talking about USA here because the magazine that published the article is The New Yorker). It is difficult to care about everything bad happening in the world, but when one's government (that one votes for and funds through their taxes) is directly standing behind it, it tends to get people (more) involved. That a lot (most? I don't know the exact proportions) of the ammunition and advanced weapons and machines that are killing those children are made and given to Israel by USA tends to get people to feel more strongly about it, too. Similarly with the funding (mentioned by a sibling comment) and the political protection.