3 ms·
ChatGPT, Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love AI
- ukuina 3y agoLawyer finds ChatGPT waffles and is easy to persuade because it holds no strict views on anything, thinks this is a confirmation that (his) persuasion skills are magical.
- zem 3y agoyeah, if he had found a different set of arguments from the other side, chatgpt would have agreed just as readily. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7RmcdHrYuk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7RmcdHrYuk
- sigilis 3y agoI think he understands that, he just is refreshed by being able to interact with an apparently reasonable intelligent agent rather than a lawyer.
- cjbprime 3y agoThere's no skepticism in the post, for example making the opposite argument in his "But <my opinion, X> is true, right?" conversational style, and seeing whether ChatGPT tells him just as readily that he "is correct" and it "appreciates the clarification" and he is "raising an astute point". Lessig is famous, but lawyers -- especially famous ones -- are not known for their resistance to intellectual flattery. I think it is fair to describe this lack of skepticism as a fatal flaw in the blog post (and a potentially significant flaw in its author). The blog post was supposed to be about how AIs can be convinced by reason, but the author did not actually assess, or show curiosity about, whether reason is a requirement for convincing them in any way. That's not a small blind spot; the mention in the final paragraph of "But I'll confess that this persuadable intelligence has seduced me." seems to be confessing more than it intended to.
- tmaly 3y agoI would love to see him react to it handling the trolley problem.
- williamcotton 3y agoI mean, he’s not your average lawyer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Lessig https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Lessig
- aetherson 3y agoChatGPT is agreeable, not principled.
- habitue 3y agoIt's very hard to separate the model's tendency to flatter and appease from a sincere attempt to reason. It very much picks up on what you want it to say if it's at all reasonable and will praise you for suggesting it. (There are lots of things it won't agree with, but usually very outside the Overton window) I've had some success asking it to poke holes / find weaknesses in an argument it just agreed with. Basically, you kind of need it to play both prosecution and defense in order to feel confident in the resulting conclusion
- sdwr 3y agoYes, it's very pleasant to talk to. The only great conversation I had with it involved playing both sides, teasing apart dimensions, and asking for concrete numbers (1-10 scale). That was the closest I ever felt to being a Asimov robot-psychiatrist x Minority Report pod-dweller.
- SamPatt 3y agoI'm a huge fan of GPT-4 and I think it has potential as an objective source in an extremely biased world. However... this article isn't even remotely compelling. It gives you what you're looking for most of the time. No surprises there.
- xrd 3y agoThis article is about a human changing his mind multiple times over the course of his life. And then, seeing a machine do it too. Sadly, I doubt that important idea will be considered on the Internet very well.
- up2isomorphism 3y agoChatGPT does not have an opinion. So it does not change its opinion.
- chmod775 3y agoYou can "convince" ChatGPT of anything using such language. It's not reasoning or even fact-checking at all. Here I make it agree with me about some history I just made up: https://chat.openai.com/share/e373193d-001b-4413-9273-cbde3edb45f4 https://chat.openai.com/share/e373193d-001b-4413-9273-cbde3e... The Weimar Republic (and Hitler's rise to power) has to be one of the most well-documented time periods in German history, yet ChatGPT refuses to spot obvious nonsense and happily hallucinates. ChatGPT is a useful tool, but you have to be careful about the language you use with it. If you use strong language it will almost always agree, regardless of whether you're making sense. However if you phrase your argument more weakly and with less conviction, it will be much more likely to point out mistakes.
- timrichard 3y ago> However if you phrase your argument more weakly and with less conviction, it will be much more likely to point out mistakes. I've found this too. I often use ChatGPT to explore unfamiliar topics, and I think the custom instructions help a bit. Something like : "I try not to bias your responses by loading my questions or putting strong opinions in them, but please do contradict or correct me if I'm on the wrong tracks, following bad practice, or making faulty assumptions. Please do have your own opinions."
- RagnarD 3y agoWhen AI is working well enough to have a virtually unlimited context window, and doesn't hallucinate, or much, wouldn't it be interesting to feed it the entire corpus of law for a given territory and have it identify contradictions between laws?
- ShamelessC 3y agoI think people would do far more interesting things than that.
- huytersd 3y agoLike what? I would love to hear what one could do with an infinite context window.
- reportgunner 3y agoEhh, anything you can imagine and more I guess ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bomewish 3y agoThis feels extremely cringe. “Law professor looks deeply into the mirror, loves what he sees.”
- RecycledEle 3y ago> what a good lawyer does, that makes this system work. It is not the bluffing, or the outrage, or the strategies and tactics. It is something much simpler than that. What a good lawyer does is tell a story that persuades. Not by hiding the truth or exciting the emotion, but using reason, through a story, to persuade. When it works, it does something to the people who experience this persuasion. LOL. Nope. I have never seen a court (cult?) use reason. Never.