3 ms·
Ressentiment as a trope is just as old as celebration of the powerful and successful. (In fact, the two often go hand in hand; both amount to defenses of the s
by zozbot234 3y ago
Ressentiment as a trope is just as old as celebration of the powerful and successful. (In fact, the two often go hand in hand; both amount to defenses of the status quo. The whole point of being a victim is that you're not among the oppressors, and conversely.) I don't think either of them is anything near an "all time high".
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoRessentiment is essentially a false morality founded on the envy of the weak toward the strong. It's one thing for strength to be abused, but another thing entirely to hate strength because you are weak. This false morality is what Nietzsche calls "slave morality", which is essentially a coping mechanism for the prideful. Whereas master morality prizes strength over weakness and expresses a straightforward and natural attitude of good and evil, slave morality begins with self-deception. It recasts that which it envies as evil in a game of sour grapes, so that the envious come out on top as the good. This has always existed, sure, but it is also true that victimhood has been elevated and celebrated as virtuous quite notably today. It has become a manipulative instrument to dishonestly extract from and exploit others through false guilt. Nobody of sound mind celebrates victimhood. A victim can take comfort in his innocence when he is victimized, he may have a moral superiority because it is not what is done to us, but what we do that defiles us. He may be pleased that his suffering has advanced some good. But a victim of sound mind doesn't love his victimhood per se, though he may pity the perpetrator for his depravity and moral weakness.
- sltkr 3y agoOf course ressentiment is constant, but the question is which kind of thinking dominates society? Historically, the pendulum has swung back and forth between what Nietsche labeled master and slave morality. The Roman empire is a typical example of master culture: it's good to be rich and powerful, and it is right for the strong to dominate the weak. There might have been ressentiment among the Barbarians the Romans conquered, but the dominant culture certainly didn't sympathize with them. Then in Europe we get the rise of Christianity, a typical example of slave morality which regards strength and power as evil (the New Testament is full of messages like the meek will inherit the earth, it's easier for a camel to pass through a needle's eye than for a rich man to enter heaven, etc.) Then Western civilization swings back to Master morality: the crusades as an early example, later manifest destiny, the white man's burden, the rise of fascism in Europe, etc. Then after WW2 fascism loses its luster and the pendulum swings back. Western colonies which were previously considered mutually beneficial developments are now condemned as exploitative of the less advanced native cultures. People like Columbus who were once lionized for their discoveries and conquests are now condemned as villains. You can view the American civil war as a midpoint of the pendulum's swing: while Negroes, who are poor and uneducated, are not (yet) considered morally superior to Whites, it is no longer morally acceptable to enslave them just because you can. Today, the pendulum has swung fully towards slave morality. You should check your privilege, and shut up, so the oppressed may speak. Representation is important. The rich and powerful are almost by definition evil. Bill Gates and Elon Musk won't be remembered in the same way as Rockefeller or Ford. Racism is no longer racism, as it was in Martin Luther King's time, but now it's prejudice PLUS power (also everyone has racial bias, so by the very definition, the powerful are evil, while the powerless are innocent). So while you can argue that the pendulum has swung back and forth on this topic through history, and it's hard to say if slave morality is currently at an “all-time high”, I think it's undeniably true that we are currently heavily biased towards celebrating the powerless over the rich and powerful.
- jemmyw 3y agoI think this is too much of a simplification to be a useful guide. First the older stuff can be discounted because there just isn't enough written evidence to know what the general Roman population was thinking. Columbus wasn't generally lionised and celebrated during his lifetime, a lot of the mythology about him comes later > As a colonial governor, Columbus was accused by some of his contemporaries of significant brutality and removed from the post. But I think the weakness of this argument is apparent when you consider the modern examples. Gates and Elon have been lauded and praised and reviled and criticised at various levels at different times. There has always been a plurality of opinion about successful celebrities, modern and historic. So I don't see that there is a master/slave swing. Rather perhaps the issue is that recently we've come into a situation where everyone's voice can be broadcast and opinion written. In the not so distant past the writing of the majority either didn't exist or wasn't available for consumption by society in general, and only the writing of influential people survived for us to read later. The grumbling of the masses was only apparent when it boiled over into action.
- sltkr 3y ago> Columbus wasn't generally lionised and celebrated during his lifetime, a lot of the mythology about him comes later Right, but the point is he was lionized during a period where people found his conquests more important than the atrocities he committed, as is consistent with master morality of the time, even if it was not during Columbus' own time. Similarly, Christianity only became really popular long after the death of Jesus Christ. That doesn't mean his viewpoints aren't an example of slave morality. > There has always been a plurality of opinion about successful celebrities, modern and historic. That's a fair point; obviously this obfuscates the situation a bit, but I don't think it disproves the general trend. > In the not so distant past the writing of the majority either didn't exist or wasn't available for consumption by society in general, and only the writing of influential people survived for us to read later. Also a fair point, but the observation doesn't rely on learning what the masses think (which I suspect is mostly what they're told to think). We see the same shift in attitude among the powerful elites. For example, President Joe Biden picked a non-white woman as his vice president, and later vowed to nominate a Black woman to the Supreme Court, to increase representation of underrepresented minorities. If any past president made such a declaration it would have been on record too. The same is true about a lot of other topics. Homosexuals have existed forever, but large corporations didn't find it necessary in the past to dedicate a month per year to celebrating them, and there are plenty of historical records to prove that. And so on, and so forth. I think it's hard to deny overall that it's a sign of the times we live in that we must praise and promote the marginalized and oppressed, and criticize and penalize the powerful.