5 ms·
Peter Thiel’s CS183: Startup - Class 4 Notes Essay
- nchuhoai 15y agoFavorite part: This is not to say that clerkships, scholarships, and awards don’t often reflect incredible accomplishment. Where that’s the case, we shouldn’t diminish it. But too often in the race to compete, we learn to confuse what is hard with what is valuable. Intense competition makes things hard because you just beat heads with other people. The intensity of competition becomes a proxy for value.
- xmmx 15y agoPart 1: http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20400301508/cs183class1 http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20400301508/cs183class1 Part 2: http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20582845717/peter-thiels-cs183-startup-class-2-notes-essay http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20582845717/peter-thiels... Part 3: http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20955341708/peter-thiels-cs183-startup-class-3-notes-essay http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/20955341708/peter-thiels... Part 4: http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/21169325300/peter-thiels-cs183-startup-class-4-notes-essay http://blakemasters.tumblr.com/post/21169325300/peter-thiels...
- pbreit 15y agoSo are there any homework assignments, quizzes, exams, papers, etc?
- rcchen 15y agoWe got our first assignment last week, there's a pitch deck that is like a project coming up, and there will be a final on the last week.
- leot 15y agoI've enjoyed everything up to where he starts bad-mouthing the benefits of competition, where he claims that if there's perfect competition "nobody makes any money". That's about as sensible as Yogi Berra's "Nobody goes there any more -- it's too crowded". With more competition, things are significantly better for nearly everyone, and only slightly less awesome for the erstwhile monopolists.
- rscale 15y agoPerfect competition is a term of art referring to a specific competitive scenario with no product differentiation, no economies of scale, no barriers to entry, and a huge number of well-informed buyers and sellers. The net result is that the sellers become "price takers", accepting whatever the market will give them. An example of this effect near an extreme is in the securities markets, where you sell stock for whatever price the market will give you. You can't reasonably argue that if my shares are selling for $600 that somebody should purchase yours for $601. When you think of competition, it's quite likely you're envisioning monopolistic competition in which products are differentiated, and aimed to appeal to slightly different buyers. This is a form of competition where profits are possible, but they're hard to sustain without continued innovation, and the establishment of new differentiating factors. A monopoly is the other end of that scale, where they have substantial pricing power and that power is quite durable over time, even without substantive innovation. But I absolutely agree with Thiel that perfect competition is terrible if your goal is to turn a profit.
- huherto 15y agoIs this what happens to airlines? I was wandering that air travel is a very valuable service yet companies seem to struggle to survive. Thanks for the explanation, I wasn't familiar with the term.
- rscale 15y agoIt's a good question, but I believe airlines would be classified either as monopolistic competition, or a non-collusive oligopoly. There's an identifiable difference between a flight on Virgin America and one on American Airlines, so at least some of the competition occurs on a dimension other than price. There's a model called 'Porter's five forces' that is often used to evaluate the strength of business models, and Thiel's choice of language seems to indicate that he's familiar with and supports at least some aspects of this model. It looks at five major factors: 1) threat of new competition (new airlines) 2) threat of substitutes (WebEx, high-speed rail) 3) bargaining power of buyers (you and me) 4) bargaining power of suppliers (Airbus, Sysco Foods, Airports, Labor, Fuel) 5) Intensity of competition Thinking quickly about airlines, my thought is that items 2 and 5 are the largest problem areas. Item 2 because if prices rise too much, businesses can shift some travel to email/webex/conference call, and pleasure travelers can pick alternate destinations either on lower-priced (likely less profitable) routes, or can simply not fly to their destination. Item 5 because if A creates a profitable flight, there's a fairly strong incentive for B to start offering a very similar flight and competing (in part) on price. This is likely to eventually drive the profit generated from that flight down to zero. After all, even if A and B managed to reach a profitable equilibrium, C is likely to notice and compete on that flight, and this is likely to continue until everyone's revenues are just meeting their expenses.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- srconstantin 15y agoA lot of this is stuff I've been thinking implicitly for a while. Success can exist on a continuum between competitive and niche. The far end of "competitive" is being something like a concert violinist. Everyone knows that it's prestigious to be a concert violinist, millions of people want to, everyone plays the same audition pieces; you win if you're a hair's-breadth better than a million people doing the same thing. It's an unpleasant process, and the odds of success are long, but you know for certain what you'll have to do to win, and you know that if you get that coveted orchestra spot, you'll have reached the top of your profession. The far end of "niche" is probably starting a company in a completely open industry. Nobody else is doing what you're doing; you're not competing directly with anyone; but you don't know what you'd have to do to succeed, you don't know if the niche you've chosen is any good, and you don't know how to judge how valuable it is to succeed in your niche. On the other hand, you don't have the demoralizing stress of trying to do the same thing as everybody else, infinitesimally better. I've been trying to decide what to do with my life in this context. I'm a grad student in mathematics, with research interests related to machine learning. On the one end of the scale there's academia (which is at the extreme "competitive" side of the axis) and on the other side there's entrepreneurship (at the extreme "niche" side of the axis) and in between there's working as a data scientist at companies ranging from "three-month-old start-up" to "IBM." There's a tradeoff between the freedom of staking out your own territory, and the risk that if you're free to make things up, you'll get everything wrong. (I've noticed that this is also true within science. In my computational vision research, there's a lot of "whitespace" for developing your own mathematical models; but most people, sooner or later, get proven wrong. In my harmonic analysis research there's a lot of classical theory already existing and the problems are better-defined; but it's correspondingly harder to make an original contribution.)