4 ms·
The question to me is: are they actually good? I've bought into the Z-Wave ecosystem, and by and large all the Z-Wave door/window sensors available on Amazon h
by kelnos 3y ago
The question to me is: are they actually good? I've bought into the Z-Wave ecosystem, and by and large all the Z-Wave door/window sensors available on Amazon have bad reviews. They have issues maintaining a connection to the network, they drop events, have terrible battery life, etc. The Zigbee sensors on Amazon seem a bit better, but still.
I'd seriously consider getting a Zigbee USB stick if I knew these function well and have good battery life. I just bought several $40 Z-Wave door/window sensors that got decent reviews, but at 4x the $10 IKEA price, I'm not going to be buying many of them.
- Toutouxc 3y agoMy home automation is 100% Zigbee and 1/2 of it is IKEA stuff (switches, buttons, motion sensors, outlets, lightbulbs, LED drivers, air quality sensor, air purifier). No problems whatsoever. I believe I haven’t touched any of it for a year.
- _fqqr 3y agoI've got a single motion sensor, and all light bulbs in the house done with IKEA's TRADFRI bulbs, all bought nearly a year ago. The stack is a zigbee USB stick, Zigbee2MQTT, mosquitto and HA. The lights are decent, I've had 2 fail so far, but both were on the same spot so I suspect something's wrong there. The motion sensor has been pretty reliable, still working with no signs of failure. Delays or "dropped" events (the light not turning on) have been very rare and most likely a result of the ancient server I have than the motion sensor itself.
- cyberax 3y ago> Delays or "dropped" events (the light not turning on) have been very rare and most likely a result of the ancient server I have than the motion sensor itself. Heads up: you can bind two ZigBee devices directly. So a sensor can trigger a light without requiring a hub to even be on. It can even work across the mesh network.
- Jeeves 3y agoI have large zwave AND zigbee networks. They're very equivalent. I find that the hub is the important factor for ZWave where as each device is important for Zigbee. Since ZWave is licensed and controlled, I've only had issues where (actual example) a siren supported playing multiple tones but the hub didn't support that particular feature directly. My experience with Zigbee is slightly different. Being an open standard there are lots of cheap choices however it also means that because there is no licensing to use it, not all of the devices branded "zigbee" are fully compatible with each other. My personal experience leans more towards "Pair the device and cross my fingers that it is compatible". If it's not, nothing works. Otherwise; They all use the same basic tech (PIR, Resistance for water sensing, magnets and reed switches for door/window open closed) so it really comes down to implementation.
- matthew-wegner 3y agoYou'll have a good experience with zigbee if you have a solid base layer of lights or smart outlets. Mains-powered devices act as repeaters in zigbee networks. Without enough repeaters, it might be tricky to place a distant contact sensor and have it behave reliably. Like other commentators, I have both z-wave and zigbee networks running. Z-wave has better standalone penetration (lower frequency), but if I were to build from the ground up again I would go all-in on zigbee. One of the few reasons I have a z-wave network at all is a smart lock, but these days there are more zigbee offerings there. All lights in my house are hue bulbs, using a deconz setup controlled by home assistant. My aqara motion/contact sensors get ~2 years of battery life.
- cyberax 3y agoZ-Wave is less power-efficient in real life. And you can say that because up until recently there had been exactly ONE chip that implemented the Z-Wave stack. You could open any Z-Wave device and find exactly the same chip, usually on a daughterboard. It worked well enough on mains power, but battery life sucked. This started to change several years ago, but battery-powered devices are still hit-and-miss. ZigBee has always had a robust infrastructure of manufacturers, who actually compete on quality and price.
- andylynch 3y agoI expect these will be; the current IKEA Zigbee products are a both inexpensive & well implemented; they are very popular and well-supported by open source ecosystems like Zigbee2mqtt, home assistant, etc.