3 ms·
I'm sympathetic to the viewpoint that it's important to watch cities as central to our future. This article, however, relies a bit much on psychological gobbled
by scarmig 15y ago
I'm sympathetic to the viewpoint that it's important to watch cities as central to our future. This article, however, relies a bit much on psychological gobbledygook. Helicopter parents, Friends, the Google bus...
Even the one graph they provide is more or less incomprehensible. What would be useful to see is land prices in inner urban areas, average lived population density, and comparative migration patterns for young adult populations (ideally taking into account long term lifestyle pattern trends).
My general take:
Places like NYC, SF, and Chicago are definitely growing, but not at some particularly spectacular rate; IIRC it's at pace with US population growth as a whole. Instead the areas with the highest population growth have been the sun belt for the past decade, which is hardly the "smart" urban growth that people go nuts over.
The demographics, however, are changing in a much more meaningful way. Gentrification will continue and accelerate. Not everyone will live in the city: instead it will be a professional ruling class working in government, finance, law, technology, and business (and their associated servants), with everyone else relegated to the decaying suburbs.
So if you want to see the future, look at Paris.
- wtn 15y agoChicago shrank by 6.9% from 2000-2010.
- emperorcezar 15y agoChicago mostly lost population in black neighborhoods. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/16/us/16illinois.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/16/us/16illinois.html
- scarmig 15y agoThat's... very weird and surprising. NYC grew by low single digits, while SF did a bit more. I incorrectly assumed this was shared across most major cities. I'm not sure how that affects my prediction, one way or another. Edited to add: a table with actual data. The 2000s have not been kind to most cities. By comparison, the USA as a whole grew 9.7% from 2000 to 2010. http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/census/2011-04-07-1Acities07_ST_N.htm#table http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/census/2011-04-07-1Aciti...
- MrFoof 15y agoNot all cities are created equally. I'm guessing Chicago is feeling much of what the same Pittsburgh is, each being on different edges of the rust belt. For example, Boston is growing at a decent rate. Boston however has a tremendous education, health care, biotech/pharma, finance and high-tech industries. Boston crime is also at all-time lows. However, small cities in Massachusetts such as New Bedford, Fall River, Worcester, and Lowell are continuing to see people move out -- usually towards Boston, but also towards smaller suburbs that are continuing to grow. Actually, Boston bedroom communities aren't exactly hurting, as they're pretty decent at attracting lots of good jobs on their own (particularly the 128 corridor). A great contrast is Philadelphia versus Pittsburgh. Although within the same state, they're still 300 miles apart and the differences in their industries and crime do much to determine how their populations are growing and falling respectively.
- meddlepal 15y agoWorcester is actually growing. I grew up in that city, lived there for most of my life, though I do not live there anymore. It's not shrinking by any means, just examining the census numbers shows it outpacing Boston in growth 4.9% to 4.8% between 2000 and 2010. Worcester is at a cross-roads now. It has excellent proximity to Boston and Providence. It has a strong bio-medical industry as well as three highly regarded universities (Holy Cross, WPI, and Clark) as well as several smaller, less known ones. Several major hospitals too. If Massachusetts can sort out the commuter rail situation and cut travel time down to <45min between Worcester and Boston then it could really take off as an alternative to Boston for people with families and on budgets. It does have its issues. Certain neighborhoods are giant crime-pits (Main South, Vernon Hill etc.) On the other hand it has an extremely safe, pleasant west-side with some pockets of high-affluence. East and North Worcester range from OK to good. It's a very spread out city despite having 180K people living in it which unfortunately means cars are a must. It's all going to be about transportation. Commuter rail to Boston will improve, part of the deal to allow CSX to expand its freight yard in Worcester was to add 10 - 20 more trains to Worcester between now and 2020. The Pike bypasses Worcester but since the completion of the 146 connector that has stopped being a real issue. If those things occur, and it is a big-if, expect the urban-downtown area of Worcester to boom as it's a small downtown area and it will be important to tightly pack around the train station because of the lack of transportation around the rest of the city.
- rilindo 15y agoMuch of decrease is due to the sharp decline in Southside Chicago as well as the growth of the suburbs outside of Cook county. http://igpa.uillinois.edu/content/census-reveals-population-change-illinois http://igpa.uillinois.edu/content/census-reveals-population-... Thanks to the economy, however, the trend is somewhat reversed: http://www.chicagobusiness.com/article/20120406/BLOGS02/120409835/chicago-area-population-growth-slows-to-a-crawl http://www.chicagobusiness.com/article/20120406/BLOGS02/1204...
- dhughes 15y agoAnd I think Detroit disappeared, didn't it?
- learc83 15y agoI thought the section on TV shows was nonsense as well. He cherry picked a few examples that fit his model. Off the top of my head some modern comedies that don't fit are Modern Family, Parks and Recreation, and Desperate Housewives. There were plenty of classic shows set in the city as well. Mary Tyler Moore, The Jeffersons, The Bob Newhart Show, Three's Company, Taxi, Welcome Back Kotter.
- chrischen 15y agoNot to mention at the end of the series Chandler and Monica move out to the 'burbs to raise a family.
- cfinke 15y agoSpoiler alert!
- JoelSutherland 15y agoIf anything the shows you list are exceptions that prove the rule. Parks and Rec, Desperate Housewives and the Office are not exactly aspirational portrayals of non-city living. Modern family is about people older than Gen Y members and is set in Hollywood. While they're not downtown, they spend "fun" time there.
- lnwilliams 15y agoYou make a good point in your reference to gentrification. It is the reason Gen Y-ers from cookie cutter backgrounds feel more comfortable in urban areas. Many cities are simply turning into condensed suburbs. However, I think this "migration" is only temporary as Gen Y-ers will likely move to outlying suburbs as they mature and start families. Metro area suburbs are ultimately where they will end up as they provide the best of both worlds, convenience and comfort.