4 ms·
The self-driving car will still need energy to run. Suburbs are built on the principle that energy is cheap. That is no longer the case.
by toyg 15y ago
The self-driving car will still need energy to run. Suburbs are built on the principle that energy is cheap. That is no longer the case.
- TheFuture 15y agoThe self driving car will be much more energy efficient, especially if they can communicate with each other to optimize traffic flow
- sliverstorm 15y agoImproving traffic flow is a win, but only a small win. Lugging around the mass of the car and yourself is still by far and away the biggest energy cost of operating a car, not sitting at a stoplight or getting stuck in stop-and-go. Clearing up 1 mile of stop-and-go is not going to make up for the 9 miles from your house to the city streets on your 10-mile commute.
- jerf 15y agoThe self-driving car will (eventually) be only one part of a larger ecosystem. A scheduled trip on your rent-a-car share may well take you to a dynamically-scheduled bus that will aggregate many people's trips. Also, the car you call will be only as powerful as it needs to be, so you won't be routinely driving around in an SUV when all you need is an efficient sedan for a given trip. Electric cars work much better in this environment, because they can easily either go charge up or do battery exchange on a commercial-fleet scale instead of at a neighborhood gas station. Personally, I'm also pretty sure the net effect of self-driving cars will also be to spread out the suburbs even more too. Most people imagine self-driving cars that are still owned by you and have single-owner use patterns, but the economics of that don't work; in nothing flat owners start renting their car out during their off times, AirBnB style, and it's a short hop from there to simply providing cars as a service. Somebody is going to get very rich being the somebody who wins on the network effects and creates "the" transportation-as-a-service company. It's going to be an enormous change, and I find it unlikely it's going to play to the city's advantages in terms of people actually moving there.
- nitrogen 15y agoBut most of a car's energy is spent accelerating, with the rest spent fighting wind resistance. Improved traffic flow helps with both -- no stop and go means no energy wasted to braking, and automated car trains will allow cars to take turns drafting off one another for a significant reduction in drag. Notice that cars have markedly different highway vs. city mileage ratings. The old BMW I used to drive would get better than 26 (not great by today's standards) on an open freeway, but 17-18 in city traffic due to repeated acceleration and idling. Algorithmically optimized traffic flow would allow cars to spend more time in the highway range.
- sliverstorm 15y agoOn a freeway drive, I assure you, energy spent maintaining speed is the primary investment by great lengths. This is an over-generalization. Yes, city mileage is generally lower than highway, and yes, it is because of stop-and-go. But markedly different? My old car got 32 freeway, 29 city. My current car gets 27 freeway, 25 city. Cars with a large difference, like your BMW, suffer either from poor aerodynamics or engine configuration. (That is to say, the particular engine setup operates very inefficiently when accelerating from a stop) Now, the most damning evidence of all- the Prius gets 40 freeway, 44 city. Automating drafting is an interesting suggestion, but anecdotal evidence from hypermilers suggests that even when drafting close behind a big-rig, you typically only net a few percent. In addition, to get any kind of measurable improvements from drafting behind a regular car, you'd basically have to ride their bumper. It seems unlikely we will permit computers to try this any time soon. In the end, my point is not that improved traffic flow is worthless- it is a win in nearly every aspect- but that it is a small, incremental win. It is not going to reduce our energy consumption enough as to obviate our dependence on cheap energy, which ties back in to the earlier point this discussion spawned from: Suburbs are built on the principle that energy is cheap. That is no longer the case.
- reitzensteinm 15y agoPoor aerodynamics would make the difference smaller, not larger. We can drastically increase fuel efficiency by making our cars out of carbon fibre, and it doesn't have to be more expensive or less safe. Check out Amory Lovin's concept car for one example. We believe lighter = less safe, despite evidence to the contrary (in reality it's smaller = less safe, lighter = safer). Perhaps computer controlled cars will allow us to stop feeling the need to fortify our cars more and more, making the road less safe for everyone.
- philwelch 15y agoYou're using 2500 pounds of steel to carry a 200 pound human. Even if you assume 100% efficiency and power it with pixie dust that's too energy intensive. You're also using a 6 foot by 12 foot cage to convey that human being, which isn't scalable regardless of how much you optimize traffic flow. And that's if you're driving a Mini Cooper.
- philwelch 15y agoNot sure what I said wrong here. If someone could explain so I can improve I'd appreciate it.
- learc83 15y agoGas prices have gone up, but adjusted for inflation not outrageously so. http://inflationdata.com/inflation/images/charts/Oil/Gasoline_inflation_chart.htm http://inflationdata.com/inflation/images/charts/Oil/Gasolin... Additionally gasoline isn't the only energy source. Once solar power reaches grid parity and electric cars are popular gas prices won't mean much. You're right that energy is finite and if we stay on the current energy consumption growth curve, energy will continue to get more expensive. However by that logic--extrapolating the decrease in time it takes me to run a mile each week--I'll be able to teleport in a few months. Population growth slows when a country becomes developed and at some point we will reach an equilibrium.
- icebraining 15y agoGas prices have gone up, but adjusted for inflation not outrageously so. But gas prices are themselves a big (maybe even the largest?) drivers of inflation, since they are not only counted themselves as they result in price raises for a lot of other products, like food.
- learc83 15y agoYou can look at gas prices as a percent of personal expenditures to see gasolines direct cost to the consumer. You'll see a similar curve. http://jerrykhachoyan.com/gas-expenditures-as-a-percent-of-pce/ http://jerrykhachoyan.com/gas-expenditures-as-a-percent-of-p... Yes other components of personal expenditure are affected by gas prices which affects the percentage, but when an individual is considering where to live the only component of gas price that matters is it's direct cost.
- bodigital 15y agoYou mean indicator of inflation. Inflation is the cause.
- sien 15y agoIt is the case. Natural gas spot prices are at a low. http://mjperry.blogspot.com.au/2012/04/natural-gas-prices-fall-below-2-might.html http://mjperry.blogspot.com.au/2012/04/natural-gas-prices-fa... As fracking takes off globally they'll probably decline even further. Cars can run on natural gas. Many, perhaps even the majority of taxis do in Australia. When people get self-driving cars whatever is most economic, natural gas, petroleum or electric power will be used.