3 ms·
Isn't the usa like Canada in that cities don't exist in the constitutional structure, they are basically creations of the state/province and as such can be wipe
by snapplebobapple 3y ago
Isn't the usa like Canada in that cities don't exist in the constitutional structure, they are basically creations of the state/province and as such can be wiped away with a simple ruling from the state/provincial legislature? Isn't that what one should do in this kind of situation, just pass legislation that revokes the current body's authority, fire all the committee members/representatives/whatever until you get down to base government, put in a transitional government committee on top of that that passes all new and improved ordinances and ensures their implementation before going to a vote 2-4 years down the road to replace themselves after the new status quo is entrenched? This would have the added benefit of getting the rest of the cities in line to do their jobs so they avoid the same fate.
- ecshafer 3y agoItd impossible to give a general yes or no here since every state is different. The states determine what the city / county / town divisions are and what powers they have. Some places, like philadelphia the town, county, and city are all one thing, but the rest of pennsyvlania is not like thay. Somw states its an act of legislature but others its a state constitution which may be difficult to change.
- dyno12345 3y agoIn California, yes, cities have no independent right to exist, it's ultimately completely up to the state