3 ms·
I’m rather annoyed that Google has locked accounts behind phone based 2FA, before this move. Tie your phone number to all your accounts, or they get deleted.
by al_borland 3y ago
I’m rather annoyed that Google has locked accounts behind phone based 2FA, before this move. Tie your phone number to all your accounts, or they get deleted.
- liotier 3y agoI suspect that the reason for WhatsApp, Signal, Google & co's insistence on requiring a legacy phone number for account creation is that linking it to the user's profile is the easiest and cheapest way to associate it to an individual person for legal compliance, linking it to a national jurisdiction.
- orangepurple 3y agoProbably makes your information easier to query in XKEYSCORE
- kyrra 3y agoYes it helps with KYC, but it also helps with fake accounts. People/groups that want to do fraudulent activity on Google have many of pre-created accounts to do their various schemes. It likely helps limit that. Plus, if an account is associated with a phone number, it will help with account takeover issues.
- the8472 3y agowe need the equivalent of ipv6 privacy extensions for phone numbers
- bonton89 3y agoI'm not sure how long that would last. Services already typically block anything that isn't a mobile number for sign ups. Sometimes they even block pre-paid mobile numbers.
- lapsis_beeftech 3y agoIt is more like phone based 1FA at this point. My Google account cannot be recovered at all even though I know the password and still control the recovery e-mail because at one point I made the mistake of adding a (now inaccessible) phone number.
- lifestyleguru 3y agoHell, I have diligently backed up recovery codes and security question answers to dozens of services... including Google and banks... and many of these providers require my phone number or their already activated mobile app to log in.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoHave you tried calling the number to see if whomever has it will send you the code it receives?
- al_borland 3y agoIf someone called me with a request like this I would assume it was a phishing attempt to take over my own accounts.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoRemember the average and unsophisticated. Humans are the weakest link.
- discard_jjd8wk 3y agoYou don't need to use a phone for 2FA, at least not in my experience (never connected mine). It can be with a hardware key instead (yubikey, etc). They don't make it very clear in the UI process, but it definitely has worked for me. That said, not a fan of forcing 2FA if people don't want it.