4 ms·
I like your comment — it points out that our RADAR displays were a both a product of the technology that was used to generate them (the sweep) but also that it
by JKCalhoun 3y ago
I like your comment — it points out that our RADAR displays were a both a product of the technology that was used to generate them (the sweep) but also that it was a deliberate way to make clear what it was you were observing (target distance was represented by distance from center, target bearing by angle around the circle).
To your point though, perhaps emulating the sweep was the questionable design decision — the bright colors, map-less background not controversial at all since they help focus on the intent of the display.
I did notice that as I turn with the phone, the compass-tracking feature broke the illusion of the sweep. :-)
- seanc 3y agoNow I have a funny vision in my head of a WWII radio tech standing in a field, wearing an absurdly large RADAR rig, with a big sweeping antenna protruding from a backpack and a massive screen on his chest, turning this way and that, all confused by how the sweep doesn't look quite right...
- test6554 3y agoThat'd be a fun Halloween costume. "I'm a functional radar."
- Full_Clark 3y agoThat's not too far off, actually. Airborne radar as recently as the F-14 needed time to "settle down" an extrapolated track after maneuvering, to the point that they could give false indications of targets changing heading. This phantom turn looked aggressive and contributed to the US downing 2 Libyan fighter jets in 1989. source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RyMfC3M0fZQ?t=12m32s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RyMfC3M0fZQ?t=12m32s
- jakey_bakey 3y agoThis is a great point - it’d be easy to de-anchor the sweep from turning but it’d be enormously complex to re-write the logic for the planes to make them fade in their own time (using the angular gradient to accomplish both the sweep and the fade was probably the best shortcut of the whole project!)