3 ms·
Has me thinking about the Drake (RIP) equation, thinking about life in terms of probabilities. Seems like the chances of finding intelligent life on a planet v
by JKCalhoun 3y ago
Has me thinking about the Drake (RIP) equation, thinking about life in terms of probabilities.
Seems like the chances of finding intelligent life on a planet vs. plain ol' plants and sponges life must be markedly smaller. Humans have existed on this planet for what fraction of the whole of life on this planet?
Of course, that's from one data set — and one in fact where the jury's still out as to our longevity as a species.
Sci-fi haș me thinking that pretty much any planet with life also has intelligent life but that doesn't ring true when you look at the numbers.
- kebaman 3y agoAlso, if the asteroid that wiped out the dinosaurs and most life 65M years ago never happened, I don't think homo sapiens would exist.
- tomrod 3y agoNo way to actually know the counterfactual. Life would likely be different though; I'd be curious what filled primate's niche before the asteroid.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI think we can know this counterfactual. On bad science fiction shows like Sliders, they visit "parallel universes" where just one or two things are changed from our world. In one episode, they finally believe themselves to be "home". Until, late in the episode, one of them notices that the Golden Gate Bridge is blue. Supposedly, nothing else is even slightly different than the one they are from. Well, if we examine that premise, it's pretty dumb. At some point in the 1930s when it was built, someone had to source the paint for the damned thing. The plant that made the paint, even if it was the same one, used different pigments. Mined somewhere other than where they found the raw materials for whatever color of orange the bridge really is. Each of these slight changes, 70 years before the protagonists showed up, would have caused even bigger changes. Trucks taking different routes, causing different traffic patterns, different delays. Suddenly, people are being conceived 5 minutes earlier, or 5 minutes later (or not at all). It's doubtful that anyone born after whenever the divergence occurred (whenever that was) is genetically identical. Doubtful that anyone born even half a generation later has the same birth name. Pretty safe to say if the dinosaurs weren't godbombed, there wouldn't be humans. The number of magical convergences is too high, even for a shorter period of time.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoI don't follow your argument. An alternate idea is that mammals, due to some survivability superiority, were the inevitable outcome and that god-bombing only accelerated us to that. The butterfly effect is sci-fi. If you want wild speculation, imagine there was no accelerant and lizard-people eventually ruled the planet — perhaps in the way we're headed, they would end up god-bombing themselves ... and then finally the mammals get their (long over) due. Popular opinion seems to be that the cockroaches are waiting their turn.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoSure, mammals. They already existed. But just because some mammal or another evolves into a sapient doesn't make that sapient "human" in the way we're using the word in this context. The path from the little critters that existed at the time of the dinosaurs to H. sapiens today is very specific, and we know of at least 2 or 3 bottleneck events in our recent evolutionary history. The idea that our species could have arisen anyway is beyond absurd. The universe does not work in this fashion.
- JKCalhoun 3y ago> The idea that our species could have arisen anyway is beyond absurd. The universe does not work in this fashion. Guess that's where I disagree with you.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoOk, so it's your theory that mammals could continue to evolve in a completely different direction, with different evolutionary pressures for say 45 or 55 million years, but then all of the sudden veer off in a wild direction where they follow pretty much the same exact path that early human ancestors followed... Such that, at the end of it all, we have something that either or both looks like an anatomically modern human and would (hypothetically) be able to have fertile offspring with a H. sapiens human? Because, I have to tell you, that's pretty batshit.
- dr-detroit 3y agojust read an article yesterday that its not an asteroid its a super volacano that killed the dinos. of course, I don't care. I wish academics would allow us to study 40K years in the past without it being contraversial or feeling the need to injure peoples reputations
- JKCalhoun 3y agoThat's an interesting proposal.
- fullstackchris 3y agoIt's also extremely interesting to think about how much the statistics or thought process will change if we just find _one single additional planet with life_ - then what kind of life, etc. Somehow finding a second planet with life seems statistically infinitely more significant - the whole thing right now is a data experiment, and for now earth (as far as we know) is an anomoly - a single "positive" data point across thousands and thousands of "negative" data points.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> across thousands and thousands of "negative" data points. Can we even definitely say there is not life anywhere on Mars or Mercury, nor has there ever been?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoSecond planet, or second star?
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoHell, we'd be "lucky" to find anything that's multicellular, or even similar to our eukaryotes. "Life" on this planet has been (and still is) primarily simple prokaryotes, with horizontal gene transfer, no sex, very small size, very small genome, low energy production, etc. First couple billion years was all that, and they still are the vast majority of organisms. And eukaryotes seem to have evolved (only once!) pretty much by chance and not by necessity. Chances are the galaxy is teaming with that kind of thing, but what we get excited about as "life" (stuff like us) is exceedingly rare, and there's no reason to assume that next-level "complex" life will exist in a form we even recognize, if it exists at all.
- AlecSchueler 3y agoWe're talking abut any life here though, right? Not just intelligent life. There was life on earth along time before humans arrived and surely will be for a while after we're gone. Totally get that post industrial life is theoretically easier to detect via radio signals etc but the article didn't seem to specify anything so particular.
- credit_guy 3y agoPeople keep thinking in terms of Drake's equation, and I for one am puzzled. Don't people realize that under any imaginable and non-imaginable scenarios, life outside our galaxy is irrelevant for us? There's no way we can exchange a single "Hello" with a neighbor in Andromeda, and that's the closest galaxy out there. I don't personally deny that there could be life in other galaxies, but equally, there could be angels dancing on the tip of a hairpin. Maybe there are, but neither can affect my life in any way.
- generic92034 3y agoAndromeda does not seem to be such a good example for your point, though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda%E2%80%93Milky_Way_collision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda%E2%80%93Milky_Way_co... We would just need to wait for "some time". ;)
- lijok 3y ago> Maybe there are, but neither can affect my life in any way. Materialistic thinking. If confirmation of life beyond earth would not have a psyche-altering effect on you, I would ask if you were human? Besides that, confirmation of extra-terrestrial life would have immense effect on most things here on Earth, material or not.
- cryptoz 3y agoThe Drake equation specifically only deals with the Milky Way Galaxy and has no comment about any other galaxies.