3 ms·
You think the framers went to all that trouble to create this complex process for making laws between two houses of the legislature and the signature of the pre
by rayiner 3y ago
You think the framers went to all that trouble to create this complex process for making laws between two houses of the legislature and the signature of the president, but thought it would be totally cool for unelected bureaucrats in some executive branch agency to do the same thing?
Arguments about the “current scale of the US” obviously don’t tell you what the Constitution means. And even on its own terms that argument makes no sense. The federal government isn’t in charge of “running the entire nation.” It’s pretty remarkable to say that we should ignore the tripartite system of government because that’s makes it easier to disregard federalism.
- defrost 3y agos/tasked with running/tasked with coordinating states and federal matters/ I think nothing about the US framers - not my country. I simply answered the question posed without delving into the merits of any specific position. On the matter of stock exchanges and securities Congress did lawfully choose to regulate and bind public companies to declare honest and true infomation to the public yada yada .. that's within the scope of Congress. The delegation is to have a seperate ideally independant group oversee that every one of hundreds of thousands of listed companies abide by regulation - just as Congress doesn't ride shotgun on every stagecoach. It's fair to bring back to Congress any disagreements with how regulation is being managed, just as it's fair to bring back to a judge a complaint that an appointed sheriff is a lying conniving son of a bitch using a badge as an ATM (for example).
- friend_and_foe 3y agoWell, it's really pretty simple. The way the US government is supposed to work, courts adjudicate, legislature makes the rules and the executive enforces them. All this hand wringing is about returning to that. The legislature cannot create an executive department that is able to create what amount to laws, execute them and adjudicate them. You can have an SEC; it can only enforce laws passed by Congress and if you dispute it goes to a federal court. That's how it's supposed to work.
- tptacek 3y agoThat's clearly not the case; for instance, Congress has created Article I courts since the dawn of the republic.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoCongress can create courts, I'm not sure what point you're making. The president can veto also and congress can impeach, they each have a power over the other branch but that doesn't mean they can delegate the duties of each branch how they please.
- tptacek 3y agoArticle I courts are courts that aren't run by the Judiciary Branch.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoThey are subject to review of article 3 courts though, and limited in their purview. And we aren't talking about them, we are talking about executive departments adjudicating their own cases.
- tptacek 3y agoSo are ALJs.