2 ms·
It’s better to read the SCOTUSblog coverage without the editorializing: https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/securities-and-exchange-commission-v-jarkesy
by rayiner 3y ago
It’s better to read the SCOTUSblog coverage without the editorializing: https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/securities-and-exchange-commission-v-jarkesy https://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/securities-and-e.... The issues in the case are:
> 1) Whether statutory provisions that empower the Securities and Exchange Commission to initiate and adjudicate administrative enforcement proceedings seeking civil penalties violate the Seventh Amendment; (2) whether statutory provisions that authorize the SEC to choose to enforce the securities laws through an agency adjudication instead of filing a district court action violate the nondelegation doctrine; and (3) whether Congress violated Article II by granting for-cause removal protection to administrative law judges in agencies whose heads enjoy for-cause removal protection.
Reading newspaper coverage of legal cases is a wild ride. Imagine The Atlantic trying to summarize a contentious GitHub issue for some widely used piece of software. Joking aside, it’s worth addressing a specific point raised in the article:
> This is wild stuff. Not long ago, a lawyer would have been laughed out of court for making such nondelegation claims.
The non-delegation doctrine is not “wild stuff.” Apart from being inherent in the idea of three branches of government with distinct, separated powers, the Supreme Court explained back in 1928 that there were limits on Congress’s ability to delegate lawmaking powers to regulatory agencies.
It so happens that—under the threat of court packing—Supreme Court in the 1930s whittled separation of powers down to almost nothing. It is entirely permissible and appropriate for those precedents to be revisited. The thing is, it probably is unconstitutional to have these executive branch agencies that exercise the powers of all three branches of government: making regulations with the force of law, prosecuting people for violating them, and adjudicating those cases. Stare decisis is a discretionary doctrine. We’re not stuck with those old, wrongly decided precedents forever.
- r00fus 3y agoThe Supreme Court sure seems like they want to challenge everything that Congress or the Executive branch executes. They threaten to do so publicly. Congress ought to likewise threaten to pass laws that have allow no judicial review or the President should threaten to reform the Court. Both are explicitly allowed in the Constitution.
- remarkEon 3y ago>The Supreme Court sure seems like they want to challenge everything that Congress or the Executive branch executes. They threaten to do so publicly. So, working as intended then.
- rayiner 3y agoThe Supreme Court is mostly fixing its own precedents which are clearly wrong. You have to huff the glue off a bunch of law review book bindings to think that the framers went to all this trouble to create a tripartite government of distinct powers, but that they permitted Congress to create executive agencies that exercise the power of all three branches at once. The fact that we even pretend that’s constitutional is merely the result of the last time the President threatened to pack the Court to achieve political ends. (And no, the power to set the size of the Supreme Court is not meant to be used to “threaten” it to decide cases in particular ways. That’s an insane interpretation of that provision.)
- throwaway1249 3y agoAgreed that the article is extremely opinionated. Separation of powers contains a lot of very subtle and non-obvious answers to society's fundamental organizacional sociology. Particularly noticeable with regards to this subject is https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalist_No._78 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federalist_No._78 where Hamilton posits that the Judicial power is the most frail one: with the executive holding the military power and the congress holding the money.