5 ms·
A group of scientists set out to study quick learners. Then saw they don't exist
- catchnear4321 3y ago> This story was written by Jill Barshay and produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. that explains the smell.
- ShamelessC 3y agoGASP!
- zlg_codes 3y agoQuick learners absolutely exist, or everyone would learn at the same rate in school. I was regularly hamstrung by curriculae because I learned quickly. Schools chose to throw a bunch of busywork at me instead of deepening or questioning my understanding. "Your peers aren't on that yet." I don't care what my peers are doing. They made their decision about me years ago. If school can't be intellectually challenging then what's the damn point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vosper 3y agoIf schools were run like Khan Lab School then they’d put students together by subject-matter capability, not age. https://support.khanacademy.org/hc/en-us/articles/115002683151-What-is-the-Khan-Lab-School- https://support.khanacademy.org/hc/en-us/articles/1150026831...
- esafak 3y agoMulti-age classrooms are part of the Montessori philosophy.
- PartiallyTyped 3y ago> what’s the damn point To churn out proletariats who will be happy and replaceable little cogs in the capitalist machine. No, for real, schools follow the same damn paradigm established in the Industrial Revolution. They have no interest in deepening your understanding and you can see that in the people hired to teach.
- zlg_codes 3y agoYou are correct, but it's sad that education isn't about knowledge. We're forced by market conditions to seek money more than knowledge. I've developed quite a cynical view of the world, with each new truth that's revealed about our society and the nature of people, my faith and trust lowers. But is it really cynical if, everywhere you look, you find evidence of its truth? Rhetorical question but I think about it daily.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoYou can very much make education about knowledge, god knows i have always been thirsty for knowledge, but that’s the adhd in me seeking novelty. I think that the broader society doesn’t encourage those who seek knowledge for the sake of knowledge, the know-it-alls, it doesn’t promote curiosity because curious minds question everything and leave no stone untouched, you don’t want that, you dont want people questioning your authority or capacity to rule metaphorical kingdoms. But I don’t think this view implies something sinister either. I think it just shows how much trauma we carry through from our upbringing. I don’t think the average person wakes up and chooses some form of punishment for others. I think ultimately we are all just trying to live some decent lives, and part of that includes avoiding confrontation with our shortcomings because that’s a difficult thing to do, especially if you are not used to.
- oceanplexian 3y agoThe world needs ditch diggers as much as it needs PhD’s. We can come up with fictional stories about how robots or AI will magically do everything, but in the real world you need people to dig holes. Training people to follow instructions is a necessary kind of education. You can already see problems forming as a result of how education has changed in the last few years. Lots of people who can code but a massive shortage of anyone who can put up drywall or service a boiler.
- toss1 3y agoBig, if true. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and I'm not sure that single study meets the bar. It is certainly a valid issue to measure starting point as well as ending point to measure learning rates, but to claim that this entirely accounts for apparent differences in learning rates such that there are no differences exceeding 1% just strains credulity. Just looking at my own learning rates on different fields I can see myself picking up some things far faster than other things, and the reverse in friends and family (e.g., quickly picking up things I'm slower to learn). Seems more like an intriguing start to more research rather than the conclusive tone presented in the article.
- christofosho 3y agoThere are so many factors. Compounding knowledge, ability to focus, and environment are crucial components to learning. That plus motivation and interest, diet, sleep, and knowing how your brain learns best. It's interesting to look back in time at things you did that maybe didn't add much to your schema/knowledge bank. Also interesting to look around at what others focused on.
- vannevar 3y agoIt seems unlikely that everyone learns at an identical rate, and the article itself seems to contradict that conclusion: "The fastest quarter of students improved their accuracy on each concept (or knowledge component) by about 2.6 percentage points after each practice attempt, while the slowest quarter of students improved by about 1.7 percentage points." That's a small difference in a single incremental component, but it represents a difference in learning rate of a whopping 35%; over ten practice attempt, the fast learner would've accumulated 26 percentage points of improvement, the slow learner only 17 percentage points. And there is a bit of a compounding effect, as the accumulated advantage of the fast learner would unlock progress on additional components that the slower learner lacked enough background for. Add these two effects over the thousands of components that would make up a curriculum throughout a K-12 career and it wouldn't surprise me if you had top learners accumulating over twice the progress of their slower learning peers, and much of that knowledge would be in higher value components inaccessible to the slower learning students (eg, learning calculus and AP biology over geometry and basic science).
- g42gregory 3y agoIf this is true, which I think it is, this bring another, very important question: How this article got published? Who initiated it, who paid for it and why? What was the motive behind this publication?
- wmil 3y ago"This story was written by Jill Barshay and produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education." I'm sure The Hechinger Report wants to promote the idea that achievement gaps can be closed by simply giving The Hechinger Report more funding.
- rapind 3y ago> And there is a bit of a compounding effect, as the accumulated advantage of the fast learner would unlock progress on additional components that the slower learner lacked enough background for. I’m not sure about this. Could you give an example (any subject) that would help me understand?
- solumunus 3y agoThis is obviously complete nonsense, no need to read the article.
- gnicholas 3y agoOne interesting fact is that they concede that some students are able to memorize more quickly than other students. It is hard to believe that students who can memorize easily would, as a group, not learn at a faster rate than students who struggle to memorize.
- whatever1 3y agoTo an outsider I look like a programming language fast learner. I picked up python in a month and passed multiple big tech interviews. Reality is that I had been programming in C++, fortran and DSL for over a decade. Similar examples from colleagues in college and schoolmates. People with strong foundations seem to learn faster, but the reality is that there is past effort that you don’t see.
- lhuser123 3y ago> but the reality is that there is past effort that you don’t see. This. Always this.
- ecshafer 3y agoLearning a second programming language is always easier than the first, or rather second language within a paradigm. Going from C++/Java to Prolog is for example a really alien experience. But to C#, its largely just syntax.
- lewisjoe 3y agoTrue. This might be confirmation bias so take it with a grain of salt: At school both students and teachers used to consider me brilliant. They saw me picking up concepts faster. But I knew all I had was a headstart. Everytime I was supplied books at the start of a new level,I just read them all and hunt for interesting knowledge.
- HKH2 3y agoA lot of students depend on extrinsic motivation - they want a reward for learning, or they don't want to be punished. While you may disagree with labels, there is a positive correlation between intrinsic motivation and intelligence.
- actuallyalys 3y agoProgramming is probably an extreme case, since some people begin it as a hobby in middle school or high school and others go into introductory CS classes having done no programming at all, but it's not hard to imagine similar factors happening in other subjects. For example, I did well in high school English courses, which I and my peers obviously had years of classes in already—but I also did extra curricular reading and writing, mostly because it was something I enjoyed. Now, would I say natural aptitude is negligible or non-existent, as the headline does? No, I don't think a single study is that definitive (and it did find a difference, just a small one).
- closed 3y agoPeople questioning the headline are missing the point of the underlying article. The underlying study is not about just rate of learning, but rate of learning under favorable conditions. The article describes where the data comes from: > In particular, we model learning using 27 datasets with over 1.3 million student performance observations from 6,946 learners in 12 different courses ranging across math, science, and language learning, across educational levels from late elementary to college, and across educational technologies including intelligent tutoring systems, educational games, and online courses And the authors argue this is favorable learning conditions because of providing things like immediate feedback on errors, etc.. Lots of room for nuance, but "favorable learning conditions" is key here. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2221311120 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2221311120
- likeclockwork 3y agoAccess to "favorable learning conditions" comes back to access to resources which some people won't engage with at all.
- lIl-IIIl 3y agoI remember reading a study that a classic bell curve doesn't exist for home schooled students - all students reached a certain level of aptitude. However, if you graph "time taken to reach target aptitude", the bell curve comes back. Unfortunately now I can't find where I read that despite extensive searching. I want to say it was attributed to Maslow. Anyway, this article claims the exact opposite by saying people learn at the same rates.
- VikingCoder 3y agoThis made me go look this up: Actress Marilu Henner, best known for her role as Elaine Nardo in the hit sitcom Taxi, has a highly superior autobiographical memory (HSAM), a rare condition shared by only 100 people worldwide. I suspect those 100 people would be able to learn certain material faster than others. I'm also curious about people who have learned mnemonic tricks. I've seen people memorize the order of the US Presidents in just a few minutes once they are taught a memory trick... But yeah, the point of the article, in my mind, is that nothing beats investing a lot of time in especially in early childhood exposing people to all kinds of learning opportunities.
- djmips 3y agoThere's also the question of what to learn. I don't know if this has really been proven but it seems to me that some people who seem to learn quickly are those that have mastered the art of learning the minimum needed to accomplish their goal. And then there's those that go deep and venture into every nook and cranny of the subject and gather immensely more knowledge than what is needed for the task at hand.
- VeejayRampay 3y ago[flagged]
- NanoYohaneTSU 3y agoAnother slam dunk psychological study straight into the garbage bin. It's very frustrating with these studies because they don't attempt to normalize anything at all. Imagine teaching derivatives and finding that some students learn faster than others. Their excuse? Oh it must be because they did fractions when making pancakes. One of the easiest ways to create a replicable study, which they won't ever do, would be to place students who have no experience typing (which is common for every generation) and see which ones learn fastest. If you are bothered by this then we can do learning piano, filtering out any student which may have musical practice ahead of time. It would be easy to find. Hypothesis would be that those with higher IQ have a higher rate of mastery.
- gnicholas 3y ago> Despite being in the same course, students’ initial performance varies substantially from about 55% correct for those in the lower half to 75% for those in the upper half. In contrast, and much to our surprise, we found students to be astonishingly similar in estimated learning rate, typically increasing by about 0.1 log odds or 2.5% in accuracy per opportunity. It sounds like students were pre-tested, given instruction, and then post-tested. The researchers assume that students who did better on a pre-test were solely leveraging prior knowledge. The researchers do not consider that higher pre-test scores could have been due to the ability of some students to discern the correct answer from context, analogies, or first principles. Students who are able to do so would be seen as "quick learners" by their teachers and peers — though not by these researchers. These students would not need as much time to master all of the content in a lesson, since they would grasp perhaps 50% more of it than their peers right out of the gate. The researchers focus on the fact that these students appear to learn the additional bits at roughly the same rate as their peers. But of course, if they have much less left to cover in a given lesson, then they will be done with the lesson well before their peers. By most definitions, this makes them 'quicker learners', assuming their initial performance was not based solely on prior knowledge, but was also based on their ability to figure out some of the material from the initial questions themselves. Also, one would assume that the last parts of a lesson are the hardest to learn, so a student who understood 90% of the lesson at first might still be learning the last 10% faster than a student who came into the lesson understanding 50% of the lesson (when such student gets to the 90% point). However, the student who student who starts at 90% might appear to learn at the same rate as the other student because the other student is getting the 'low-hanging fruit' and moving from 50% to 60%. This should not be considered equivalent to moving from 90% to 100%.
- quit-the-woke 3y ago[flagged]
- trimethylpurine 3y agoBased on this article, anyone complaining about how hard their classes were just didn't drink as much I did. They certainly couldn't have studied less. That I'm certain of.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoThis is not natural science, but these scientists are doing the best they can to support their theories anyway. I wouldn't consider myself an expert in non-natural science, even though I do understand some of it to an extent. So I could take this at face value, it's quite plausible that nobody has ever been fast. This fully explains the confirmation of different learning rates universally observed over the millennia, we're all just different degrees of slow.
- vineetsinha 3y agoFWIK public school systems create workers. Private school systems create employers. Courtesy General Education Board / JD Rockefeller / a time when labor advantages in America were in demand.