4 ms·
Tesla sues Swedish government after worker rebellion cripples car biz
- amarant 3y agoAs a Swede, this lawsuit is actually more interesting than it might seem. The issue at hand here is that a government agency is failing to provide the service it legally must provide (delivering licence plates), due to it's dependency on a private actor (postnord) which is refusing to make the deliveries due to a sympathy strike against Tesla. Trafikverket (the agency in question) is saying that they've fulfilled their legal obligations as they've delivered the plates to postnord, and Tesla quite understandably disagrees with this, as they're not getting any plates. IANAL but it seems to me that something is legally questionable here, but whether that is trafikverket refusing to let Tesla pick up the plates themselves, or if it's on postnord for, at least arguably, stealing mail, I don't know! (Since Tesla is asking to pick up the plates at trafikverket, I imagine they're willing to pick them up from whatever facility postnord is keeping them in, but postnord won't let them) Whatever your opinion on the morality of the suit,I don't think it's entirely clear-cut legally. Again, IANAL, so it might be to someone with legal literacy, but to this layman the outcome is far from obvious! The strike itself is very interesting as a Swede: very few Tesla employees seem interested in this strike, some have even openly criticised the union for misrepresenting them. That signals a huge loss of influence for the unions in Sweden, which are the be-all end-all to Swedish labour laws(we don't have legally mandated minimum wages, instead the unions are free to do.. Well what they're doing now basically) Some union reps are worried this might be the end of the Swedish model and that we might end up switching to legally enforced minimum wages and less powerful unions. How likely that is to happen I leave for you to decide. The low participation rate among Tesla employees has also led to some quite interesting sideeffects: some small repair shops are actually losing business to Tesla, since they don't dare deal with Tesla owners(and thus draw the ire of the unions) but since Tesla own shops are still operating, Tesla owners who need repairs are forced to go to those shops instead! It's interesting to see how intertwined and interdependent the economy is, where a strike against one company ends up negatively impacting some of its competitors (in the servicing cars market, not the building cars market) I'm the end, I really don't see how signing a collective agreement could possibly be worse for Tesla than all of this trouble. From a pure business perspective, it seems logical to just sign already.
- belltaco 3y ago> The strike itself is very interesting as a Swede: very few Tesla employees seem interested in this strike, some have even openly criticised the union for misrepresenting them. Are there sources for this? Swedish ones are fine.
- apienx 3y agoTesla is hoping that this will be settled by the EU, not Sweden. A lot of swedes are looking at this situation through a moral lens rather than a legal one (also, union membership figures are steadily declining). This will likely end up in reform.
- amarant 3y agoI mean it might, but then again it might not. Tesla is far from the only company in Sweden that doesn't have a collective bargaining deal in place, in fact it's quite common to not have one. This is supported by the Swedish model. I think if the unions had more Tesla employees on their side, Tesla would be forced to sign in short order, but they don't seem interested. Exact numbers are hard to come by since the union refuse to disclose them, but indications are something like 90% of Tesla employees are still going to work, despite the unions offer of 130% compensation for strikers from day one, even from workers who wasn't previously members of the Union. this is very unusual for a union to be this generous, usually they offer 80% pay, and workers join the strike because they want to improve their workplace. In this case it seems workers actually don't want the collective bargain, only the union wants it. Honestly nobody is looking very good in this mess, not Tesla, not IF Metal, and I think this is a pretty clear view of the dark side of the Swedish model (unions are so powerful they can ignore workers, which is just weird) Personally I think the Swedish model is mostly good, but like all things, it could be improved. For example I'm not sure it's a great idea to have the unions be responsible for unemployment benefits, they've been leveraging that to force unwilling workers to strike, which I think is kind of overstepping a bit, and makes me wonder if working conditions are really what IF Metal is even worried about here. Unions being powerful is mostly a good thing, but there needs to be some checks on that power, or it'll be misused eventually. And I'm starting to wonder if "eventually" is actually "now". Maybe some kind of rule where you can't start a strike against a company unless you have the support of at least 30% of the workforce in that company? I dunno, I think the unions need to be more convincing to the workers here, since they don't seem to have their support. Then again, they currently don't need it!
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38431147 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38431147
- dang 3y agoComments moved thither. Thanks!