4 ms·
Worker's death from blunt force injuries resulted in $7k fine for Amazon
- 29athrowaway 3y ago$7,000 fine? That is ridiculous.
- pizzalife 3y agoYes it is, but the reason that it is so ridiculously low is because of politicians in Indiana. Republican states tend to heavily favor corporations and business over individual workers.
- gruez 3y agoBut OSHA is a federal agency? Also, from the article: >Indiana regulators found that the warehouse could have done more to fix or manage hazards that were "causing or likely to cause death,"
- drewcoo 3y agoThis is not about OSHA. The article is confusing.
- brianwawok 3y agoAnd this is one of the many things I love about living in Indiana. (not sarcastic). We aren't a swing state, but for sure we go blue once in a while. At the city level things are fairly blue. And my state is not broke, we were running a surplus last I checked.
- lowercased 3y agoIf that's the max the law allows... the laws and regulations need to be changed. Then enforced.
- pempem 3y agoGuess who is busy gutting the folks who do enforcement and de-toothing regulations?
- elil17 3y agoThis article misses two key points: - The worker's family can still sue Amazon - Most OSHA fines aren't for accidents, there for "failure to abate" - this means, if Amazon didn't implement safeguards to stop a similar accident from happening again, they could be fined $15,000 per day. I do think OSHA fines are to low, but it makes sense to fine for failure to abate rather than accidents, especially when you think about smaller businesses - you don't want to take money away from a company before it has a chance to use that money to fix the issue.
- drewcoo 3y agoThe fine was issued by the state of Indiana. That's stated in the article and you can confirm by looking up further sources. OSHA is federal and under the US Dept of Labor. The state-level IOSHA is a part of the Indiana Dept of Labor. I have no idea why the article keeps mentioning OSHA. It clearly is not to show the disparity between state and federal enforcement. Maybe just to confuse comments on HN . . .
- elil17 3y agoI think that this is really confusing because IOSHA should only have authority over state and local government, not private workplaces.
- i_am_jl 3y agoIndiana's OSHA is one of the state plans that has authority over most private workplaces. https://www.osha.gov/stateplans/ https://www.osha.gov/stateplans/
- bradknowles 3y agoIMO, corporate fines like this should be structured in terms of percentages of gross annual revenue + total Market Cap + total gross assets. And start at integer percentages above 0%. Make them start at a number that the board will actually notice and want to actively avoid. So, if you're a trillion-dollar company, then the fines start at 1% of a trillion dollars, and goes up from there.
- ratsmack 3y ago>Gruesbeck was driving a one-man lift when he struck his head on an overhead conveyance system, Amazon said. According to the company, he was working to fix a jam on the conveyor and was trained on how to use the lift. It sounds like it was something that would be difficult to foresee. Without seeing the entire picture, it would be pointless to speculate beyond that.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoA veritable fortune!