2 ms·
I see a lot of people upset about the openness of the web or whatever, and I am too, but I don't see many who point to specific harms that this causes. Of cours
by saagarjha 3y ago
I see a lot of people upset about the openness of the web or whatever, and I am too, but I don't see many who point to specific harms that this causes. Of course, this leads others to believe that the complaints are nitpicky and lazy. Since I use this feature heavily, I feel like I might weigh in why this really sucks.
First off, I have a GitHub account. But I'm often in contexts where signing into it is annoying, and intentionally so (it lets me push code!) I usually don't want it on my work machine, even though I search GitHub a whole lot from there. Some of it is of course related to my job directly, which you might plausibly make the argument for that my employer should somehow compensate them for a free service that indirectly makes them money, but a lot of it is literally my work computer being a second machine that I work on, with open source code running on it, and usually these searches are to contribute value back to the community–either because I want to file a bug against it later, or maybe even deciding whether it is worth my while to contribute code to it. And I do this all the time from other devices, too: I might have logged into GitHub on my phone once, but my iPad? My mom's computer? Being able to search GitHub is an excellent way for answer people's tech questions at any time, much like if Google asked you to sign in everywhere it would be a massive pain.
Second, and also quite important, is that I can't use GitHub links as a way of pointing people at code anymore. I frequently (check my history!) will post a comment like "yeah the Foo project uses bar API a bunch like this, [GitHub search link]". It's a very quick and very direct way of sharing this information. Of course I have no idea if the people on the other side are logged in or not, which means that if you put them behind a login wall I will slowly stop sharing these, because people will complain that they can't see what I sent them. It's the same way I hesitate to send people links to Twitter/X these days, because whether the content will be accessible is a coin flip. And I'm definitely not going to ask people to clone the repo (on what, their phones?) to see what I'm seeing, so I might as well link to Sourcegraph instead.