3 ms·
That's a very interesting question. There are a ton of specialized tools for EMC/EMI simulation, I think they all work on the basic principle of assuming that a
by jacquesm 3y ago
That's a very interesting question. There are a ton of specialized tools for EMC/EMI simulation, I think they all work on the basic principle of assuming that a portion of your board will be exposed and that that part will be causing some radiation and will receive some from outside. After that it's decisions that will affect cost that will likely drive how far you want to strive for perfection, you could encase everything in grounded copper and it would be as close to perfection as you can manage or you can stick your board in plastic and live with the consequences. Usually, depending on how critical the application is some interference is acceptable as long as the device continues to operate. But on radiated power there are some very strict limits and for say a motor controller any malfunction could cause serious trouble so you will want to be extra careful there. The hardest to control for me: wiring, connectors, density of carbon sprayed inside plastic, anything using inductors (including what orientation to put them in, you want them at right angles to the surface of the board for mechanical stability and lack of coupling between inductors on the same board, but you want them parallel to the board to minimize radiated power and susceptibility to EMI).
Apart from shielding and carefully modeling your board (especially the ground plane, supply and any connections that carry a significant fraction of inbound power) you will always end up testing for compliance and that's the gold standard. I think simulation is very useful and can cut down on the number of physical test runs significantly but I've yet to see a design that did exactly what was predicted. Wiring, what happens just outside of the board enclosure, environmental factors, it all adds up. I see simulation as a way to be more efficient, not as a silver bullet to be able to guarantee certification is a one-shot, but possibly others have better experience.
There are a couple of very simple tricks to test for EMI sensitivity (a handful of coins, an old fashioned piezo based stove lighter and the oldest cell phone you can get in close proximity to the board), as well as a simple field strength meter. Between those you can probably identify and eliminate the worst and after that it's trial run time at the certification authorities if you are making a device that is to be used in a regulated market.
Especially the piezo lighter is interesting, I've had circuits that required substantial redesign just to get them to the point that they would not lock up hard.
What's interesting about this stuff is how un-intuitive some of it is. Note that this field is continuously in development and that new tools and techniques are brought to market all the time. Look the other way for a few years and you feel like a dinosaur.