2 ms·
> No one living in Terra Haute, Indiana would be better off. No one in Boise, no one in Richmond, Virginia. Why not? They have zoning restrictions there too. N
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> No one living in Terra Haute, Indiana would be better off. No one in Boise, no one in Richmond, Virginia.
Why not? They have zoning restrictions there too. Nobody would be building skyscrapers there, but they would be building multi-family homes instead of single-family homes.
The only places it wouldn't matter is where land is really not scarce, i.e. rural areas or cities with long-term negative population growth. But those are the places with the cheapest housing at present -- that's not where the problem is.
> The flip-side of "housing costs too much" is "oh shit, the builders built way too much" and then the economy craters when that does more than just cool, but freezes over for a decade.
What was the date of the last housing crash in the US caused by overproduction of housing?
> What if there are too many people who need goods (homes, of course, but other things too), but who can't ever have viable livelihoods no matter how much low-quality education we stamp on their foreheads with C+ grades? What if UBI doesn't work, because in the part of the economy that is actually worthwhile, there's just not enough excess to tax away and send to them as welfare? What if we're still 150 years away from the technology that would give you your Star Trek post-scarcity utopia?
These things are two sides of a coin. Absent some supervillain extracting the surplus to store in an evil supervillain mattress, automation technology that eliminates jobs also lowers the cost of living.
If things aren't very automated then there is plenty of work to do and plenty of jobs available. If things are very automated then automated production results in cheap goods which allows people to make a living by working fewer hours.
It can even be both at once, because rather than working for fewer hours, people generally prefer to keep working their existing hours and then use the extra money to buy more stuff. Which increases demand, which requires more labor to produce the additional stuff, which creates new jobs. Notice how we've already automated many things that used to be manual and the unemployment rate is still very low.