4 ms·
The real Turing test is not out of date. Two important considerations: - The interrogator is against two players, a bot and a human, and can ask questions to b
by GuB-42 3y ago
The real Turing test is not out of date. Two important considerations:
- The interrogator is against two players, a bot and a human, and can ask questions to both of them, both try to convince the interrogator that they are the human, and in the end, the interrogator must tell which one is which.
- The test is to be done by experts, both the human player and the interrogator are expected to play to win. The goal is not to have some chit-chat and try to guess afterwards, the goal is to actively try to find the bot, and come in well prepared.
For now, there is absolutely no way GPT-4 can pass a real Turing test. Remember, both the human player and the interrogator are trained in bot detection, and they collaborate. The only thing that is not allowed is for the two humans to know each other from before as to not use shared secrets against the bot. But using common knowledge anti-bot techniques together is fair game.
The thing described in the paper is a weak variant of the Turing test that only tests the ability of AI designers to trick unsuspecting humans.