4 ms·
Given that we actually give kids massive amount of attention compared to historical standards ... calling current situation "degenerate" is absurd. Also conside
by watwut 3y ago
Given that we actually give kids massive amount of attention compared to historical standards ... calling current situation "degenerate" is absurd. Also considering that by many statistics, children do better then they used to just a few decades ago.
- elmomle 3y agoFor some definitions of attention, yes, but not necessarily historically massive amounts of physical contact and (non -neurotic) care. Think of the images from the world over of indigenous women going about their days largely with their young children strapped to them.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Think of the images from the world over of indigenous women going about their days largely with their young children strapped to them. Until they can walk at which point they are increasingly gone to do the vital growing that happens away from adults.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cplusplusfellow 3y agoThis is not advocacy for replicating indigenous societies parental habits, but perhaps a key is hyper-focused for 2-3 years and then a steeper dropoff on the hand-holding (literally and figuratively).
- watwut 3y agoThey have another child in 18 months. This one is then unstrapped and you don't see it on the pic. Nor you see even older siblings. And those women work with infant strapped cause they have to, they can't stop working once the kid is toddler. And by the time they are 5 they play alone unsupervised. Which was even the same in villages in Europe even after WWII. My grandma was herding goats with pack of kids at 5 and remember it as normal. School started at 6.
- latency-guy2 3y ago> Think of the images from the world over of indigenous women going about their days largely with their young children strapped to them. Note how the extent you went is imagery rather than hard numbers, you don't have a leg to stand on.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Given that we actually give kids massive amount of attention compared to historical standards ... calling current situation "degenerate" is absurd. This seems to assume that ~all attention is positive and that attention is still beneficial after the Xth hour. After a time the adult role becomes less parent and more like prison guard duty. It also seems to assume adult-time is enough for kids and that peer-only time isn't an irreplaceable environment for kids to develop their core social skills.
- watwut 3y agoWe also spank them significantly less and yell at them significantly less (speaking of negative attention).
- LegibleCrimson 3y agoSignificantly better than some historical standards and significantly worse than others. We aren't doing the best that has ever been done across all cultures and history in this regard, not by far.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Given that we actually give kids massive amount of attention compared to historical standards ... This is literally based on a comparison with hunger-gatherer societies. To the extent that there is any accuracy to your "compared to historical standards", its probably based on a low point reached (in the "developed" world) somewhere between the first industrial revolution and mid-20th century,
- Erratic6576 3y agoPrimitive hunter-gatherer societies might have raised their children in a communal way, with relatives and friends living nearby, always interrupting and nagging us. We, the supreme civilisation, at the summit of evolution, are locked in in individual cages, disconnected from each other, so we can spend more quality time attached to our screens. We are “civilised to death”
- latency-guy2 3y agoThe accuracy of most statements in this thread are the same.