3 ms·
A lender does not have $1M tied up in a 3% loan. Many lenders have small pieces of that $1M tied up in multiple mortgage backed securities with various tranche
by lotsofpulp 3y ago
A lender does not have $1M tied up in a 3% loan. Many lenders have small pieces of that $1M tied up in multiple mortgage backed securities with various tranches of seniority.
The paperwork required to undo all of that and re-underwrite the debt would be enormous.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoYes, but that is the question and premise. There is a lot of money to be made if someone can figure out how to do that paperwork. There are 12 trillion dollars of mortgage loans in the US, so converting a tiny fraction from 3% to 5% would be a goldmine. Essentially a 66% return for doing "the paperwork". That's 660k profit for doing the paperwork on a loan previously worth 1mm. This is obviously rare today due to the paperwork complexity. That complexity IS the alleged market failure.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 3y agoHow are you calculating the 66% return/$660k profit?
- s1artibartfast 3y agojust ballparking it based on the ratios of the rates, 5/3. This is concervative due to the way loans compound and amortize. If you had a loan you were looking to net 1mm profit, you would net > 5/3 or >166% the profit a the the higher rate. If you put it in an actual calculator, a 2 million,3%, 30-year loan will pay the bank back 3mm (1mm profit). The same principal at 5% will pay the bank back 3.8mm (1.8 profit, e.g >166%) The numbers themselves are less relevant than the value proposition. If you could tell a bank that you will increase the profit on already invested capital, with no additional investment, they should jump on it.