3 ms·
Statistics. If you have a pool of people, some of whom would not be willing to jump without a good rate and some of whom would be, you offer it to everyone and
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Statistics. If you have a pool of people, some of whom would not be willing to jump without a good rate and some of whom would be, you offer it to everyone and you make more money than those who don't offer the good rate.
This effect is known as the "consumer surplus". People willing to pay more get the same price as those who aren't.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoBut is not a given it works out that way. It depends on the statistics. You could just as easily give to everyone and lose tons of money.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNo, they're losing money right now by not offering it. Right now they're losing money on their 3% mortgages. If it converts to 5% it turns a loss into a small profit. OTOH, if you don't offer the 5%, there are 3 scenarios: 1. the homeowner keeps the 3% and you keep losing money 2. the homeowner converts to a 7% with you and get a large profit 3. the homeowner converts to a 7% with somebody else and you make no profit. #1 and #3 are by far the most likely options, IMO.
- dmurray 3y agoThere's a fourth scenario - the homeowner pays off the mortgage early. In the US, early payment can involve a penalty, so the homeowner buys out the loan significantly above market rate. Over the course of a mortgage, a significant number of homeowners will find they "need" to relocate for work or to join a partner or to upsize or downsize. Offering these people a big improvement on "pay a penalty rate to discharge your loan early" would cost the banks money, so they need to pitch any refinancing offer where it makes enough profit off the other homeowners to be worthwhile.