4 ms·
> Yes, I know, Germany made a gigantic mistake decomissioning their nuclear reactors early. I strongly disagree with that choice, and I think there's a deeply r
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Yes, I know, Germany made a gigantic mistake decomissioning their nuclear reactors early. I strongly disagree with that choice, and I think there's a deeply rooted misunderstanding and fear of nuclear power in this country which is a big shame. Despite this, good progress is being made however.
You're not from Bavaria, I take it? Here, to this day hunters and shroom gatherers have to scan their produce for radioactivity because of the aftereffect of Chernobyl [1], but also due to the aftereffects of worldwide nuclear weapon tests [2].
Besides: the three NPPs that were shut down this year only had 1.4GW each - and we're building ~2GW in renewables each month. The capacity of the NPPs has long since been replaced by renewables.
[1] https://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/bayern-pilze-radioaktiv-belastung-1.6112342 https://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/bayern-pilze-radioaktiv-b...
[2] https://www.br.de/nachrichten/wissen/bayerns-wildschweine-von-atomwaffentests-radioaktiv-belastet,ToV9xN5 https://www.br.de/nachrichten/wissen/bayerns-wildschweine-vo...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> capacity of the NPPs has long since been replaced by renewables All while Germany continues burning Russian oil and coal [1]. Anti-nuclear pro-climate is oxymoronic. It’s also destructive in introducing irrelevant preferences into an important debate; if you get nukes then someone else gets solar panels and windmills ruining their view. [1] https://emlab.ucsb.edu/blog/out-phase-costs-and-benefits-germanys-nuclear-phase-out https://emlab.ucsb.edu/blog/out-phase-costs-and-benefits-ger...
- mschuster91 3y ago> if you get nukes then someone else gets solar panels and windmills ruining their view. No view-ruining if you run offshore wind. Europe has a lot of potential there, even though the French have been ... slow in building that one out given their "cheap" nuclear.
- kortilla 3y ago>You're not from Bavaria, I take it? Here, to this day hunters and shroom gatherers have to scan their produce for radioactivity because of the aftereffect of Chernobyl. “I read about a train derailment that killed people so I’ll never take public transit” >The capacity of the NPPs has long since been replaced by renewables. The two sources aren’t fungible unless the renewables are dams. Nuclear provides a reliable base load. Neither solar nor wind can do that. You need storage to make them reliable and that’s not even close to a solved problem.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 3y ago> The two sources aren’t fungible unless the renewables are dams. Nuclear provides a reliable base load. Neither solar nor wind can do that. That's only a question of a reliable, widespread grid. France, Portugal and Spain have almost consistent wind from the Atlantic and Mediterranean Sea, it's only a question of how much you want to invest into a truly European Grid.
- kortilla 3y agoNot just grid, the wind farms need to be massively overbuilt to support a scenario where only one windy coast has to power the entire EU.
- mschuster91 3y agoThere's other renewable sources that can be tapped. Running-water hydro provides constant baseload (with the exception of summer when rivers run dry, but there, solar fills the gap), geothermal energy is a massive reserve that's completely constant, biomass (aka burning cow dung and other compost gases) releases CO2 but it's better to have that CO2 than have the fermentation methane release into the atmosphere and you can store the gas in the regular gas grid storage to burn it in times of need, pumped hydro and distributed battery packs / EVs can provide peak regulation power... And in any case: it makes sense to massively over-build wind and solar generation because air and maritime travel will need a massive amount of power-to-liquid synthfuel as there's no way to power either of these using conventional batteries.
- eigenspace 3y agoThis is exactly what I'm talking about. Yes, 4000 becquerels of Cesium 137 per kg of mushroom sure does sound scary, especially if you're raised in the German media environment that constantly plays up the nuclear boogeyman. Cesium 137 is a beta emitter and doesn't bioaccumulate in humans. Potassium in bananas has a similar radiological and chemical properties to cesium. A kilogram of bananas is around 250 Bq of naturally occurring radioactive potassium. I'd be a lot more worried about industrial chemicals that leeched into my wild mushrooms than I would about such low levels of cesium If you ate 80,000 Bq worth of those mushrooms (i.e. you found and ate 20kg worth of the most radioactive mushrooms these people were able to find), you'd get a 1 millisievert radiation dose which is less than half of a normal person's yearly ambient radiation dose. 20kg is a *lot* of mushrooms.