4 ms·
This is a nice feature but the root problem is how trusting people are of the totally insecure phone system. We all have to have “the talk” with our elderly par
by ryandrake 3y ago
This is a nice feature but the root problem is how trusting people are of the totally insecure phone system. We all have to have “the talk” with our elderly parents, where we try to convince them to never do business over phone or e-mail unless they themselves initiated the conversation. No legitimate business will call you and expect you to pay money, give them access to a computer, ask for security codes, or anything like that. Always hang up, and if you think it’s actually life-or-death important (hint: it isn’t), call them back in their official number.
My parents got scammed in the past so they are on the lookout, but I still don’t think they are careful enough. And due to their age they get attacked a lot! Last time I visited, their phone was ringing every hour or two--all scam/spam. It’s only a matter of time until the next one is clever enough to get through.
I think these “external caller” scams are going to be with us until that generation dies out. The “trust the phone” instinct is too strong. Of course for my generation, the scammers will find something we inherently trust and exploit that, I have no doubt.
- otteromkram 3y agoI think this should be hammered into everyone's head and am surprised it isn't already. I get regular emails from retailers and banks reminding me that they will never call and ask for money or personal info. Then they state exactly what you said; hang up and call the institution's official number if you're unsure who is calling. (Note: a quick way to find the official number is by looking on your debit/credit card. It should be printed on there.) (Note note: Don't sign your credit/debit card. Put "SEE ID" or something in the signature area.)
- aqfamnzc 3y agoWhy not sign the card?
- CharlieDigital 3y ago"SEE ID" is an explicit instruction. But I haven't had anyone check the card in ages.
- lxgr 3y agoBut not a meaningful one. It's a signature panel, not an endorsement one like on checks, or a free-form message to card-accepting merchants. Best case everybody will ignore it; worst case your card will be declined because somebody will still actually attempt to compare the signatures on the receipt and card, and “SEE ID” is not a signature.
- CharlieDigital 3y agoThe purpose of "SEE ID" is that a cashier or server actually requests a photo ID like a license and verify the name and visual identity to the person presenting the card. This seems like the second most secure form of identity check (chip + PIN #1) if everyone could be made to follow it consistently.
- lxgr 3y ago> This seems like the second most secure form of identity check (chip + PIN #1) if everyone could be made to follow it consistently. Yes, but that's not happening since there is no incentive for the merchant to do it. Merchants are generally not liable for card-present lost/stolen card fraud, so the only thing this does for them is add friction. It's a textbook principal-agent problem (in addition to requiring a human in the loop), and I highly doubt that the schemes would ever introduce anything like that, especially given that there are viable alternatives available (PIN entry on the terminal, on-device authentication for mobile wallets etc.)
- lxgr 3y ago> Note note: Don't sign your credit/debit card. Put "SEE ID" or something in the signature area. When is the last time anybody has even looked at the back of your card? Signature comparison (or even asking for a signature) is no longer required in most circumstances under the card schemes’ rules, whatever the signature panel says.
- PeterisP 3y ago> My parents got scammed in the past so they are on the lookout, but I still don’t think they are careful enough. And due to their age they get attacked a lot! I'd bet that it's not because of their age, but because they have been scammed in the past, so their data now is on the lists of "verified victims" which get passed around as those are thought to be more likely to fall for the next scam than simply a random number.
- callalex 3y agoIt’s somewhere in-between. They have a landline. Only really old people have landlines, so those are specifically targeted.