4 ms·
> A theory about a conspiracy is when outsiders to the conspiracy try to reason about motives without being privy to the actual motives (if any) of the conspira
by thaumasiotes 3y ago
> A theory about a conspiracy is when outsiders to the conspiracy try to reason about motives without being privy to the actual motives (if any) of the conspiracy. By their nature, conspiracy theories can be far more wide ranging than the actual motives of any conspiracy will be. This is one of the things that makes conspiracy theories problematic.
This seems like it would apply equally well to all theories.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoMotives are a lot more difficult to reality check than are physical properties. Especially if, as ethanbond indicates, the person with the theory doesn't believe what the other people say about their motives.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoYou're trying to use a definition of "conspiracy theory" that, even if you exclude natural phenomena -- which you're only managing to do by special pleading -- says that a conspiracy consists of one or more people cooperating with "each other" in public. And the conclusion you draw is fully general. There are more possibilities for why something happened than there are reasons for it. What are we supposed to have learned? > Especially if, as ethanbond indicates, the person with the theory doesn't believe what the other people say about their motives. The modal case is that, when someone makes a claim about their own motives, they are lying. The second most common case after that is that they don't know their own motives and their reported motive is not accurate.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoI'm "special pleading" because I way overgeneralized in my initial attempt at a definition. > conspiracy consists of one or more people cooperating with "each other" in public. Public doesn't have to have anything to do with it. > What are we supposed to have learned? Yes, I overgeneralized. In general the thing to learn is to try to reality check as much as possible. > The modal case is that, when someone makes a claim about their own motives, they are lying. Granting this point, a razor would attribute base motivations over complex motivations.