4 ms·
Crypto could have been special. Sadly it turned into stocks instead and people reinvented the entire financial system on top of it. I don't even mind their atte
by matheusmoreira 3y ago
Crypto could have been special. Sadly it turned into stocks instead and people reinvented the entire financial system on top of it. I don't even mind their attempts to regulate this stuff anymore. Exchanges are literally banks.
They should stop just short of regulating the underlying cryptocurrencies themselves. Just treat these institutions like they're banks.
- pjc50 3y ago> Crypto could have been special. Sadly it turned into stocks This is the libertarian version of "true communism has never been tried". Of course people wanted to reinvent the financial system, it was profitable to do so.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoNot really. True cryptocurrencies were tried. They even work. Monero is the truest cryptocurrency, it's what bitcoin should have been since the beginning and it already works. The tragedy is nobody's actually using it because everyone's too busy feeding their money into literal banks and speculating with it.
- vasco 3y agoIt's as much of a tragedy that people don't use Monero as people who go walking down the street and don't stop to look under every rock. They could do it, but not sure the point.
- Qwertious 3y ago>The tragedy is nobody's actually using it because everyone's too busy feeding their money into literal banks and speculating with it. To borrow a phrase: Nice idea, wrong species.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoOnce very large financial interests (those capable of destabilising international trade, funding transnational smuggling operations, or --gulp!-- financing war) are attracted to an opportunity, the game is way beyond the scope of inconsequential small-scale adopters. The latter will be wistful about their dashed hopes. The libertarian ideology, like many others, is at best an extraordinarily naive interpretation of the individual and the world.
- pixl97 3y ago"Libertarians are like house cats: absolutely convinced of their fierce independence while utterly dependent on a system they don't appreciate or understand."
- rollcat 3y ago> They should stop just short of regulating the underlying cryptocurrencies themselves. The problem with not regulating a currency at all, is that it implies a permission for someone to print it at will. Cryptocurrency is no exception to this scenario; you are asked to trust the developers (technocracy) and node operators (50%+1 attack and all the usual power dynamics of the rich having more say than the majority) to not do it. The most important question you must ask yourself is, how long will the interests of that elite continue to align with yours (if they ever did). The dream of a decentralized, community-run, grassroots infrastructure died sometime around the first GPU PoC - Satoshi themselves expressed discontent, saying GPUs would trivially out-mine the common man. Communities can self-regulate because they run on trust; it's extremely difficult to build trust in a system designed around distrusting every single one of your peers.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> The problem with not regulating a currency at all, is that it implies a permission for someone to print it at will. Not a problem. This is determined by code in ways everyone can see and understand. It's actually better than governments printing money whenever they feel like it. The economic impact of money printing is actually minimal. Most inflation is actually generated by fractional reserve banking and their loans which is already something exchanges do. BTC maxis don't seem to grasp this fact. > you are asked to trust the developers (technocracy) You are asked to trust code. Either way I'm actually OK with this. I actually trust them a whole lot more than the communists in charge of my country's economy right now. > node operators (50%+1 attack and all the usual power dynamics of the rich having more say than the majority) The only problem with this is it turned out cryptocurrency mining is not actually as decentralized as it was supposed to be. It should have been one CPU one vote but it turned into massive operations involving custom hardware. New cryptocurrencies need technology to fix that problem. Monero uses ASIC resistant proof of work algorithms to mitigate it. > The dream of a decentralized, community-run, grassroots infrastructure died sometime around the first GPU PoC - Satoshi themselves expressed discontent, saying GPUs would trivially out-mine the common man. Exactly. That's the true tragedy of cryptocurrencies.
- 3y ago
- jalapenos 3y agoNo, it straight up doesn't work as a money, outside of very niche use cases like crime and evading the state. Most people have no use for that, or speculation upon that, and just want a money that's simple, easy, fast, and reliable. A decade after bitcoin, no-one but crooks and when-moon fanboys use it. Contrast that with AI: the moment it hit the retail market every man and his dog is using it for everything.
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> it straight up doesn't work as a money I've gotten paid for services via Monero. > money that's simple, easy, fast, and reliable That was my exact experience with Monero. Ever tried to set up a Stripe account for GitHub Sponsors? I literally had to open a new bank account for that. With cryptocurrency, you just generate a private key in your wallet app. > A decade after bitcoin, no-one but crooks and when-moon fanboys use it. Yeah, that's kind of my point. It's tragic. I don't understand it.
- jalapenos 3y agoYou're a techie - everyone else views the complexity and unreliability of computers as "computers are a necessary evil" rather than "oh this is an interesting challenge!". To the layman, a single unfamiliar word or concept equals "my money will disappear".
- matheusmoreira 3y agoEven among techies there's no adoption. Just look at this site.
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoShopify takes payments in USDC (Coinbase’s stable coin that’s pegged to USD). They use Solana Pay to do it, and the fees are considerably lower than traditional banking alternatives. https://solanapay.com/ https://solanapay.com/
- hanniabu 3y ago> people reinvented the entire financial system on top of it That's the goal, to remove intermediaries and trust. There are permissionless and trustless application, but HN likes to use centralized scams like FTX to dunk on crypto and feel smug. It'd be like me pointing to bernie madoff and saying "see, I told you all of the stock market was a scam!"
- DontchaKnowit 3y agoOkay but what percentage of the total value transacted in crypto happens on centralized exchanges? If I had to guess, probably something like nearly all of it. You are talking about a fringe minority or crypto transactions. everyone else is talking about the reality on the ground.