11 ms·
Here's the list of SEC crypto enforcement actions.[1] They start about two or three cases a month. 30 cases so far this year. At first, they focused on the out
by Animats 3y ago
Here's the list of SEC crypto enforcement actions.[1] They start about two or three cases a month. 30 cases so far this year. At first, they focused on the out and out scams. Then, they shut down the ICO industry by sending out letters asking why each ICO wasn't registered as a security. Then they went after some of the NFT guys. They went after some paid influencers. Now they're going after the bigger exchanges. Plus, along the way, the usual out and out scams: "fraud for misappropriating at least $12 million of offering proceeds to purchase luxury goods including sports cars, watches, and a 555-carat black diamond..."
The SEC's position is simple: the same rules apply to crypto as to other financial products. After FTX, nobody is seriously opposing that any more. The "crypto is special" argument is dead.
The scams are not even original - the scams are Ponzi schemes, pump and dump, front-running, insider trading, and just plain stealing customer assets. All of those were known before 1900.
The crypto crowd isn't really that innovative.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/cybersecurity-enforcement-actions https://www.sec.gov/spotlight/cybersecurity-enforcement-acti...
- injeolmi_love 3y agoThere are over 1.8 million crypto tokens. If the SEC is going to shut down the industry, they’ll need to at least start shutting down more projects per month than are starting up.
- growse 3y agoWhere's the tax dollars to pay for this?
- PoignardAzur 3y agoIf the fines are high enough, seems like it could be self-financing.
- ajb 3y agoUsually this kind of enforcement attempts to reimburse victims, or failing that, goes to general funds. Anything else is a moral hazard for enforcement (eg, USA local police confiscations)
- lazide 3y agoAre you trying to say USA local police confiscations don’t exist at large scale?
- ajb 3y agoNo, I'm saying that they are an example of moral hazard.
- lazide 3y agoSure, but one that continues to exist after decades of being used no? It’s an example of folks not caring about that hazard and doing it anyway.
- ajb 3y agoSo? That doesn't mean the feds should do it too.
- lazide 3y agoThe local seizures are run under a Federal program. [https://www.justice.gov/afp/types-federal-forfeiture https://www.justice.gov/afp/types-federal-forfeiture] [https://www.forfeiture.gov/ https://www.forfeiture.gov/] That is why it is so prevalent everywhere in the US. The feds use it too, extensively.
- ajb 3y agoOkay - worse than I thought.
- 3y ago
- hurtuvac78 3y agoAccording to the article: To make this palatable to the American public, those whistleblower rewards are not courtesy of the taxpayer; they’re courtesy of money seized from previous Bond villains. A portion of Binance’s settlement(s) will go to pay the whistleblowers at the next Bond villain. It’s a circle of life.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> Where's the tax dollars to pay for this? You're kidding right? The US government is one of the biggest holder of Bitcoin. They seized insane amount of Bitcoins. And the US is a country where capital gains are taxed. The US government is making a shitload of money when cryptocurrencies go up. You cannot have it both ways: if you tax your citizens on their capital gains made on crypto, then you prosecute the scammers like SBF when they prey on US citizens.
- growse 3y agoI don't disagree, but you're arguing that the government gives a greater share of its tax receipts to the SEC. This is a question for Congress, not the agency. The usual assertion of "let's spend more money on x" results in the obvious question "instead of what?". OP was suggesting that the SEC ramp up the rate of actions, which will need funding (at least, initially). I don't see Congress doing that?
- gbear605 3y agoThe SEC is largely self-funded by fees on banks, no need for tax dollars.
- ensignavenger 3y agoA government mandated fee is an excise tax, they are essentially the same thing.
- alistairSH 3y agoThe SEC is largely self-funded via fees charged to financial institutions. Funding increased enforcement of crypto entities doesn’t have to require more tax revenue.
- raccoonDivider 3y agoDo any of them reach even 1% of Binance's size? If crypto stays a bunch of niche projects that only enthusiasts invest in, isn't that the SEC's goal accomplished? I can't imagine they would care about a coin that doesn't attract either a lot of retail customers or big financial institutions.
- injeolmi_love 3y agoBinance value comes from servicing those niche projects - it’s an exchange. As long as those niche projects exist, new projects will emerge to service demand. What will change is design; future exchanges will be less regulatable. Already dexes are waiting in the wings; UNI has been in a price uptrend due to these decisions. A smarter strategy would be to do what the US Justice dept is doing; co-opt the biggest players, install plants, and cut down any upstarts. Government enforced monopolies have worked for hundreds of years as an effective way to control industries.
- codeflo 3y agoAll of that's assuming that demand will continue. What this will do is remove crypto from the mainstream. And without paid celebrity endorsements, where will the new dumb money inflow come from? And if that dries up, how will the mining rigs pay their electricity bills?
- injeolmi_love 3y agoA lot of people use crypto for utility, which is why it doesn’t go to zero in bear markets. Not everyone needs or wants crypto tokens, but those that do form the base of the ecosystem. You can call it dumb money if you want to be elitist, but it’s the same so called dumb as any consumer activity.
- csomar 3y agoIf you start an ICO, you are harmless until you get someone to buy into your token. For the SEC, you are harmless until you collect "millions" of dollars. Otherwise, you are just another one of these small scams that are happening all the time regardless of it using crypto or not.
- injeolmi_love 3y agoUnless they do a complete and total eradication program, that will just create a selective environment for tokens that are able to avoid SEC fines. What you’re saying does seem to be the SEC strategy, and it is probably the profit maximizing strategy in the short term. It also requires the least effort; rule making that allowed for regular fee collection instead of sporadic ones might be profitable in the long term, but it would be a complex activity the SEC might not be capable of.
- eastbound 3y agoRemains the question: Why was it allowed to even live a little, when for the first dimes, it was clear it was a scheme that necessitated illegal actions at every step?
- graphe 3y agoWhat’s illegal step is mining crypto on your gpu?
- matheusmoreira 3y agoNothing illegal about proof of work.
- pjc50 3y agoNo, but there should be a ban on proof of waste.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoWaste? Better forget about crypto then. Even at its peak it didn't even amount to 1% of global energy consumption. Maybe you should suggest putting a ban on trading with China instead.
- doctor_eval 3y ago1% of global energy consumption is outrageous.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoMore like 0.5%. A literal drop of water into the ocean of western wastefulness. My only objection to it is the fact all that energy is being poured into obsolete technology like bitcoin. I wouldn't even mind if Monero used even more energy. That energy is buying us something: a true cryptocurrency.
- ThePhysicist 3y agoI think this quote of the prosecutor in Bankman-Frieds' case summarizes it well: "The crypto industry might be new, the players like Sam Bankman-Fried may be new, but this kind of fraud is as old as time and we have no patience for it".
- jgilias 3y agoNote though that the fraud that the prosecutor addresses here doesn’t have anything to do with crypto per se. As in, it’s not about securities laws, or even AML stuff. The fraud that scam bank man fraud got sentenced for was plain old theft. Taking customers assets (mainly crypto assets) and using it as his personal piggy bank.
- BobaFloutist 3y agoThat's literally what the prosecutor said.
- kemitchell 3y ago> Note though that the fraud that the prosecutor addresses here doesn’t have anything to do with crypto per se. As in, it’s not about securities laws, or even AML stuff. That's playing pretty tight with definitions to push "crypto" out of the picture. SEC's press releases was "SEC Charges Samuel Bankman-Fried with Defrauding Investors in Crypto Asset Trading Platform FTX". https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2022-219 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2022-219 The release said "crypto" ten times.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoTruth be told, the FTX case isn't even a cryptocurrency case. The Bankman essentially ran an unregulated bank. People deposited money into it and he just took it. He pretty much robbed his depositors. It's ironic. Cryptocurrency was supposed to put an end to guys like that by ending the need for banks.
- smodo 3y agoWell put. Following that line of thought I’d say that by now crypto has shown that you can never trust a system, in the end you have to trust the people behind it. I find people to be more trustworthy when they go to jail if they do wrong.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoCrypto could have been special. Sadly it turned into stocks instead and people reinvented the entire financial system on top of it. I don't even mind their attempts to regulate this stuff anymore. Exchanges are literally banks. They should stop just short of regulating the underlying cryptocurrencies themselves. Just treat these institutions like they're banks.
- pjc50 3y ago> Crypto could have been special. Sadly it turned into stocks This is the libertarian version of "true communism has never been tried". Of course people wanted to reinvent the financial system, it was profitable to do so.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoNot really. True cryptocurrencies were tried. They even work. Monero is the truest cryptocurrency, it's what bitcoin should have been since the beginning and it already works. The tragedy is nobody's actually using it because everyone's too busy feeding their money into literal banks and speculating with it.
- vasco 3y agoIt's as much of a tragedy that people don't use Monero as people who go walking down the street and don't stop to look under every rock. They could do it, but not sure the point.
- Qwertious 3y ago>The tragedy is nobody's actually using it because everyone's too busy feeding their money into literal banks and speculating with it. To borrow a phrase: Nice idea, wrong species.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoOnce very large financial interests (those capable of destabilising international trade, funding transnational smuggling operations, or --gulp!-- financing war) are attracted to an opportunity, the game is way beyond the scope of inconsequential small-scale adopters. The latter will be wistful about their dashed hopes. The libertarian ideology, like many others, is at best an extraordinarily naive interpretation of the individual and the world.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rovek 3y agoNothing soured my (already negative) opinion of Crypto as much as regular conversations with a Crypto VC. Every time we spoke they were either sceptical or very excited about something that, to me, was obviously a trivial example of 1 or more classic scams. Whether or not they were excited about it didn't seem to track with the scamminess.
- fsloth 3y agoThat’s sort of general problem with people regardless of industry who’ve drunk the startup coolaid … wrong way around, let’s say. The point of innovation is not to reinvent the wheel. Saying you are startuppy does not excuse you from actually learning about the field. One could even radically propose knowledge of field helps to find innovations. What one should avoid is saying ’no’ just because such a thing does not exist yet. If the thing exists, has a name like ’Big Bad Mistake’, you should at least acknowledge it. (Yeah yeah, rockets were impossible and Musk beat them but that happened via respect of existing art and extending it, not completely ignoring it).
- vidarh 3y agoWhen I did my second startup and first to get proper VC funding, we were young and stupid and got talked into changing strategy because the VC, while not going for an actual scam, was very clearly thinking we could win a game of musical chairs that necessarily would end badly - this was a the height of the dot-com boom, and they wanted us to chase signups over revenue because per-user valuations were way out of whack with what there was any reasonable hope of earning from users who had signed up for a free service. Their hope was we could exit before the music stopped (we didn't; we survived, barely, thanks to mostly sheer luck of having closed our B-round weeks before the bubble burst, and managed to pivot and survive with massive cuts). We still hoped we could make it profitable without that, but there was no way we could generate enough revenue to justify the exit we were hoping for, but the proportion of our budget that went to marketing certainly made achieving profitability much harder. Which is to say that VC's often chase very high-risk ways of getting growth even in cases where they know it's just a question of time before valuations will collapse, because most of them are in the business of producing returns, not sustainable companies, and many of them are "dumb money". It's a tough business. I spend a few years in one, analysing the track records of other funds among other things, and I saw so much stupidity in that dataset.
- legutierr 3y ago> The SEC's position is simple: the same rules apply to crypto as to other financial products. If you only reference the SEC's own press releases, you are going to miss the nuance here. The SEC on its own doesn't get to decide when and how existing securities law applies to cryptocurrencies. Absent a settlement, any action undertaken by the SEC must be decided by a federal court. Importantly, the SEC has been losing in court. For instance, the SEC, which had been blocking a spot Bitcoin ETF, was told in unequivocal terms by the DC Court of Appeals that its reasons for not allowing the ETF to issue were completely unsound. More pertinent to the question of enforcement: another federal court recently found that exchange-traded Ripple XRP tokens are not securities, with the implication that the SEC does not have jurisdiction to regulate the trading of Ripple XRP tokens on exchanges. If you extrapolate this finding to other cryptocurrencies, the SEC cases against Kraken and Coinbase are on shaky ground. The fact that the SEC can list so many victories on its website is more a function of how costly it is to fight the SEC in court, rather than being a function of whether the SEC is right in all of its assertions. There have been too many cases of fraud in the crypto industry, and it's good that the SEC has pursued enforcement against them. There are cases, however, where SEC has gone too far, and continues to go too far—especially in light of the fact that the SEC refuses to set forth clear criteria as to which crypto tokens it considers securities, and which crypto tokens it does not consider securities. Now that the SEC is going after larger players, we are starting so see more cases actually go to court. If the trend continues, one or more of these cases will end up before the Supreme Court, and we will find out what the actual law is in the United States with regards to which crypto tokens are securities and which ones are not, and whether the SEC does in fact have any jurisdiction at all over the crypto exchanges. You should not be surprised if after everything is said and done—after we have a Supreme Court opinion—crypto is in fact a special case under US securities law, at least with regards to some tokens. You should also not be surprised if some of the cases in the list that you reference lose their legal support once the law is clarified by the Supreme Court. In hindsight, some of these SEC enforcement actions may be seen as unfair and unjust.
- davedx 3y ago> the SEC refuses to set forth clear criteria as to which crypto tokens it considers securities, and which crypto tokens it does not consider securities. Here you go: "A security is a fungible, negotiable financial instrument that represents some type of financial value" It's not the responsible of enforcement agencies to educate people as to what crimes are. This is like pleading ignorance.
- cs702 3y ago"Fools, as it has long been said, are indeed separated, soon or eventually, from their money. So, alas, are those who, responding to a general mood of optimism, are captured by a sense of their own financial acumen. Thus it has been for centuries; thus in the long future it will also be." - John Kenneth Galbraith Source: https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/10115990-fools-as-it-has-long-been-said-are-indeed-separated https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/10115990-fools-as-it-has-lo...
- infogulch 3y agoAs always, new technology is neutral, but the latency between a new technology appearing and the attention of the law breeds scams that are completely mundane.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoSo, the underlying issue is the wrong people are scamming money from the poors. I base this entirely on the trackrecord of the SEC and the market. Now, to wait for someone to argue that PFOF and Dark Pool trading is "fair".