3 ms·
So here's a scenario I haven't seen brought up yet. Elbonian hackers manage to steal the singing key of kneebonia who is part of the EU (and also does IT as we
by gustavus 3y ago
So here's a scenario I haven't seen brought up yet.
Elbonian hackers manage to steal the singing key of kneebonia who is part of the EU (and also does IT as well as you would expect a European national government to do) They start publishing a ton of their own certs and start MITM everything out the wazoo.
In the current environment this is noted by the community quickly they respond and revoke the Kneebonian cert, they understand what is happening, they understand why it is happening, they understand why it is bad and they have a vested interest in stopping it.
Compare under the EU rules. The browser vendors cannot now revoke the cert of their own violation without risking significant penalties. They start the process of trying to get it revoked. The individuals involved are largely beauracrats and civil servants the likes of Sir Humphrey. They do not understand the technical jargon they just know the nerds are getting upset. They'll work on discussing the proposed change by evaluating a written request in the Orwellian named "Committee for Public Internet Safety and Electronic Information Security and Cyber protection" this committee meets 3 times a year on March 31st, October 16th and February 29th. In the meantime the entire underlying security model of the internet is broken.
Now some might say "well if it's an emergency they'll respond immediately there will be public outcry and people's lives being ruined." And if it becomes a big deal the EU will act promptly, they will create a taskforce immediately whose job will be to create a recommendation for individuals to serve in a committee to investigate the source of the problem and create a list of possible remediations that could resolve the problem, which it will then present to the parent committee who will draft a response..... Etc etc ad infenitum until everyone involved with the matter has died of old age, and if you think I'm exaggerating when has EU done anything quickly?
- izacus 3y agoYour case is exactly the same as some entity stealing the ability to issue passports for a country. Insinuating that people issuing national identifications don't understand the issue of forging said documents is some ridiculous techbro arrogance. We've been dealing with this shit for centuries and those "beaurocrats" you're insulting have probably gone through more more cases of fraud and forgery than you ever thought about in your life.
- veeti 3y agoSomeone issuing false passports has literally no effect on my life. On the other hand, a government being able to issue unauthorized certificates for gmail.com and browsers being helpless about it does.