7 ms·
Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017)
- pschuegr 3y agoI'm personally convinced that a lot of arguments in modern life boil down to not going to a sufficient level of detail. Mostly I find that both parties in an disagreement have valid points and simply haven't defined their terms precisely enough or been clear that they are talking about a p95 vs a p5 situation.
- emmelaich 3y agoI agree, most of the time you need to refine and quantify the question. People are resistant to that though. If I'm being generous I think they think it's just saving time, because they 'know' the right answer. But the melancholy cynic in me wonders if it is just ego.
- pschuegr 3y agoI don't think it's cynicism to realize that people are imperfect creatures subject to the whims of insecurity and ego, not being well slept, yadda yada. To me that's just realism.
- tsiike 3y agoit can be hard for me to admit that my entrenched beliefs may be flawed but enhanced with an updated worldview…now me thinks this is my ego…actually i am now sure of it…a detail i had not previously flushed out…
- bwestergard 3y agoThis basic idea was the foundation of the logical atomist philosophy of Bertrand Russell and the early Wittgenstein.
- Slow_Hand 3y agoAgreed. A lot of the past conflict in my life boils down to this as well. Conversely, I'm now in the habit of asking big "obvious" or "dumb" questions; questions that will highlight assumptions being made by each party. I'll often go slow at first to establish that these large unspoken thoughts are aligned and then work my way down to lower levels of detail until we hit an actual disagreement, rather than a mere misunderstanding. It drives me crazy to spend 30 minutes arguing with someone only to find that "Wait, you're talking about THAT? I thought we were talking about THIS." It's too common for people to find themselves arguing in the direction of the same general concept, but differences in their understanding/interpretation will diverge more and more the farther you get into the discussion. It's so helpful to lay out terms at the start when possible.
- scubbo 3y agoAgreed - and this is why I find it _so_ frustrating when I try to take a step back (or down, or whichever direction seems most intuitive to you) and actually define terms, only to get met with a "you're just nitpicking about terminology, I'm trying to communicate ideas!" If we aren't using the same terminology, we can't possibly communicate ideas.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tuatoru 3y agoAbsolutely. I summarise it as "abstraction is the curse of the age". My wife works in governance, and when a proposed new policy is being discussed, she is always the one to say "so, how would the policy work in this situation, with these people involved? [Outlines a situation.] Tell me the steps." And, of course, the elegant, abstract policy is shown to be unworkable or lead to manifestly unfair or absurd outcomes. I admire my wife's patience greatly.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI usually phrase it as arguing parties discussing a high-dimensional idea by projecting it down to a much lower dimensional space, and if they can't seem to agree, it means they're projecting to widely different bases - considering different aspects. Visual analogy: take a cylinder floating in the middle of the room, and a single light source you move around. As you move the light around, it'll cast shadows of very different shapes. This is merely projecting a 3D object to 2D, but if all anyone in the argument has is a single snapshot of a shadow, you could see how a person seeing a circle might have trouble agreeing with a person seeing a rectangle - and yet they're still talking about the same thing. (The biggest hurdle is to get people to realize their view on a topic is a low-dimensional projection of a high-dimensional thing, and not just the thing - and that to do something productive with it, one must be willing to "walk around" a bit, project to different bases.)
- k__ 3y agoLet's build an API. I need a CI/CD pipeline to deploy it. I should use a static code analysis tool. I need an observability tool! Let's to security code reviews. Do I have a SBOM? Which MFA should I use? Should I put it inside a container or go serverless? Better generate a OpenAPI spec! Do I have enough tests? Oh, I need blue/green deployments! Should I deploy to the edge?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kristianp 3y agoPrevious threads with 100+ comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29429385 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29429385 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22020495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22020495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255
- dang 3y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38304840 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38304840 - Nov 2023 (1 comment) Reality has a surprising amount of detail - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36309597 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36309597 - June 2023 (1 comment) Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29429385 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29429385 - Dec 2021 (118 comments) Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28006256 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28006256 - July 2021 (1 comment) Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22020495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22020495 - Jan 2020 (115 comments) Reality has a surprising amount of detail (2017) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16184255 - Jan 2018 (294 comments)
- kristianp 3y agoThis was a beautiful read until I got to the part about disagreements. I think it may distract from the main message about the complexity of tasks and the value of experience.
- huijzer 3y agoAlso related to the ending, I‘ve come to realise more and more that most people reason out of belief first and arguments second on a lot of things (maybe most things?) Climate change deniers are an obvious example. But also more nuanced views such as "the software I make makes the world a better place" (I belief this myself), "me being a healthcare worker is a great thing for humanity", or "I need to game at least once a week to relax." And it makes sense. Many things are extremely complex and so picking one side and going for that will make sense in many cases. It’s often necessary to be able to make decisions. However, the risk is getting too stuck in certain ideas. It’s easier to accept a long held belief and reject opposing information than to re-evaluate.
- TheOtherHobbes 3y agoProfessional deniers are propagandists, not good-faith debaters. Lack of nuance is one problem, but there's a far bigger problem with groups of people knowingly trying to poison and undermine anything that resembles reality-based consensus.
- switchbak 3y agoAbsolutely - PR firms, lobbyists, astroturfers, troll farms - I'm in full agreement, and there's a lot of them around. Also a problem are those who label the undecided or free thinking among us as not being good faith actors. And unfortunately it's a tough position to be in, as you get attacked from all sides for not choosing a side.
- mistermann 3y ago"reality-based" and "consensus" is an interesting combo, in general but particularly if one considers the history of consensus of "reality".
- Pearse 3y agoFor some reason this really speaks to me. I think it's because we create a story about every part of us and our life. Every thing we do (sometimes we even do it after the fact). I feel like those beliefs are what's keeping us grounded in the sense of understanding the world, of being in control. so it makes sense that we would start with them even if we are not aware of it. And it makes sense that it's hard to let them go because without them you get a sense that you are just floating away and don't have any to "hang" your assumptions on. You can reason a lot but there comes a point when things get bigger than you and you have to trust some other authority or just trust your gut. There's not many people that could comfortably reason from first principles and be satisfied with where they end up. (I don't think I could do that)
- _hi_again_dang 3y ago[flagged]
- zubairq 3y agoI agree that looking at the details really helps when reasoning about things. But that is hard as it is always easier to look at things from 10,000 feet
- incompatible 3y agoThe interesting thing is that we somehow manage to cope with all this complexity, both as individuals, and as a society, and survive. When you look at all the details, and all the things that can go wrong, it looks like maybe it wouldn't be possible. Also at a natural (non-man made) level, the complexity of biochemistry and the need to get 30 trillion or so cells working together as a single animal, in the presence of another 30 trillion or so single-celled organisms of random species, doesn't really seem like something that's going to succeed.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> cope with all this complexity, both as individuals, and as a society, and survive. Surviving is not thriving. Like roman construction, we just have very big error margings and margin of safety. Things do not have to work perfectly to finction
- akira2501 3y ago> to get 30 trillion or so cells working together as a single animal It's no coincidence then that your brain has a circuit to create backwards explanations for behavior that you didn't initiate, it helps create the illusion that you are a single animal, when in practice, you mostly aren't.
- hyperthesis 3y ago> In retrospect, I think I saw the fundamental difficulty in what we were doing and I don’t think he appreciated it (look at the stairs picture and see if you can figure it out) What was it?
- two_handfuls 3y agoYou can’t rest the ladder against the wall and trace where to cut. Because the wall will stop the ladder.
- andrewflnr 3y agoThe biggest problem I see is that the part of the board you need to cut off intersects the ground. If you're leaning the board on the ground, you need to somehow trace a line parallel to the ground several inches above it. Hopefully you can solve that by using a spare chunk of 2x6 and tracing along that. Similar story for the vertical joint. I don't know if that's what the author meant, though.
- CamperBob2 3y agoatan2() to the rescue. Interestingly, as crude as the diagram is, you can feed it to ChatGPT's data analysis plugin and it will not only recognize what's depicted, but offer to calculate the cut angles for the 2x12s given the rise and run. I was pretty impressed that it recognized the problem without any prompting other than the image itself.
- andrewflnr 3y agoTrig was already mentioned. It's definitely not the answer to the question GP is asking.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hyperthesis 3y agoAdding to the previous discussions on counter-steering bicycles: you can see it in tyre tracks. e.g. ride through a puddle; or, ride from rain to under cover. Consider: how do you steer riding no-hands? Shifting your body weight makes the front wheel turn (because of the "rake"), but now your bodyweight is on the outer side of the turn! Hold it for a (brief!) moment, then lean the bicycle the other way and you have a nice turn in the opposite direction - which is what you wanted all along.
- rpmisms 3y agoThis is a critical skill on motorcycles, and most people learn it subconsciously, but real masters can throw the bike into turns in ways that make no sense unless you take countersteering into account. I'd love to be good enough someday to make physics seem confusing...
- hyperthesis 3y agoMotorcycle licence tests cover counter-steering, as an obstacle avoidance technique. I think gyroscopic effects are also in play, and more pronounced on a motorcycle, with its wheels having greater mass and angular velocity.
- rpmisms 3y agoNot in the US, or at least not in Tennessee. It's taught, but not tested on. Absolutely. They're very unique vehicles, and I find them to be a fun mechanical exercise.
- wlonkly 3y agoAs a cyclist and motorcyclist, I've always found that bicycles will let you get away with not knowing you're countersteering, but on motorcycles you really need to be explicit about "push harder to turn tighter".
- hyperthesis 3y agoNo matter how closely you look, there is always more to it. However you think things are, good or bad, you are "wrong". But you may have sufficient precision to make some specific technique operate. (The technique is predicated on an implicit theory simplifying how things are. Both the technique and theory are "wrong".) In finding correlations between two things, a tricky bit is finding which two things (a thing can be an arbitrary composites of other things). When we do find a correlation, that becomes how we see it, and we think in terms of this particular simplifying theory of reality. i.e. there are two issues: (1) reality is complex. (2) we simplify it.
- mistermann 3y ago> However you think things are, good or bad, you are "wrong". Does this principle apply to this sentence? ;)
- hyperthesis 3y agoStolen from previous discussion https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Coastline_paradox https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Coastline_paradox The gif of Great Britain looks like it freezes at the end, but zoom in... it's just adding in finer detail.
- hnfong 3y agoI thought about fractals while reading the article too. And I'm starting to worry that maybe fractal-like concepts not only apply to geometry (as in, "how long is the coastline", or "what direction is the coastline at point (x,y)?"), but to truths in general. Just like the article describes, "rough" facts like "water boils at 100C" can have tonnes of nuance, and when you drill down into the details, you might discover that the truth is so much more complicated that the notion of truth and falsity is lost among the vast sea of complex details. (eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase_diagram#/media/File:Phase_diagram_of_water.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phase_diagram#/media/File:Phas... ... who'd have thought something taught in elementary school would be so complicated :-/ ) So is it possible that most "truths" in which we have absolute conviction are actually just rough understandings, and if we dig deep enough we'd find that we're actually mostly wrong? It seems insane to think that way, but I have a strong intuition that this might actually be the case.
- genman 3y agoI think the main message is this here: "If you’re a programmer, you might think that the fiddliness of programming is a special feature of programming, but really it’s that everything is fiddly, but you only notice the fiddliness when you’re new, and in programming you do new things more often.". I've done programming and construction and more than often construction is like programming, especially when you are renovating.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoThis is non-intuitive to me because programming languages (above the level of assembly, probably) are made by humans to represent human concepts, while construction is based on physics. While writing that sentence I realized that programming does have a lot to do with logic, which is a construct of reality, and not humanity. So I guess it does makes sense that programming would be fiddly. I am not a programmer.
- anamexis 3y agoAlso, construction designs, materials, and tools are made by humans.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoProgramming languages can theoretically abstract things away to the extent a properly formulated phrase will get working code from an LLM. Construction designs and materials are still concretely limited by what physics will allow.
- anamexis 3y agoWell, programming languages are limited by what logic will allow, and computers (and by extension programming languages and LLMs) are also limited by what physics will allow.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago
- ipython 3y agoI enjoyed the stair story here quite a bit - I find that I always have a newfound appreciation for the “real” jobs when I find a fine craftsman at work. We had a curved staircase fabricated for our house and it was absolutely fascinating to watch the planning and execution go into this task. The original measurements were plugged into a cad drawing where we could adjust the number of treads and the position of the top and bottom steps based on our preference. Then they fabricated the entire assembly offsite and brought it in via crane in one piece. Even building the handrail was fascinating as there was a jig built in place to bend the wood to the curve required. The physical constraints and fractal complexity is fascinating for someone like me who is used to deterministic machines moving bits on a daily basis.
- ulizzle 3y agoExcept when it comes to driverless cars & so-called AI. That’s easier done than said, supposedly
- nappy-doo 3y agoAside: Building stairs that way is a really bad idea. Don't use angle brackets – you cut stringers. And besides the first and last step, stringers are pretty straightforward to layout with a carpenter's square with some stair guides (two little posts that screw to the square). And, generally you just layout 8" rise, 12" deep stairs, so you really don't lay out anything at all. But, really, don't build stairs like OP suggested.
- jcims 3y agoSomehow as easy as it is conceptually, I still find cutting 3 stringers that line up well to be surprisingly difficult. In part because I’ve only has to do it a handful of times in my life.
- jacquesm 3y agoEither you use jigs or you tie them together temporarily and cut the stack.
- dylan604 3y agopretty amazing how the simplest of solutions seems to be so elusive. i've been guilty on more than one occassion of making something seemingly simple as difficult as wrangling cats.
- jacquesm 3y agoIt's just experience. Everything you've done before or that you've seen done by people that knew what they were doing is trivial, everything you haven't done before is difficult.
- lelanthran 3y agoYup. If you're doing almost anything in wood, a set of clamps is more useful than you'd think. I made a table. The legs are all exactly the same length, but don't ask me what that exact length is - I eyeballed the height I wanted and then clamped all the legs together before cutting them. Another tip for building things with legs - a 3-legged object is stable on any uneven surface while a 4-legged objects will wobble on uneven surfaces. This is because 3 points make a plane, adding a 4th point that is not on that plane introduces a wobble.
- contravariant 3y agoI blame this phenomenon for why people feel mathematics is not useful. It is, it's just that reality is more complex than high school mathematics can properly prepare you for. To understand the mathematical solution, should you encounter it, does however require some foundational knowledge so if you don't know any then you can't even begin to understand it (possibly even failing to identify it is mathematical). I mean take something practical like a mortgage. It's fairly easy to calculate the annuities using a geometric series, but that places it beyond most people's mathematical skills. Sure you could use a special calculator, or if you're adventurous look up the formula (beware though, Wikipedia is bound to lead to errors by defining the monthly rate as yearly rate / 12), and then it probably may not like doing mathematics at all but neither do you really understand what's happening.
- dieselgate 3y ago"If people do not believe that mathematics is simple, it is only because they do not realize how complicated life is" - John von Neumann [1] Saw this quote on an art blog showing SEMs of diatoms [2] [1] https://butdoesitfloat.com/Diatoms https://butdoesitfloat.com/Diatoms [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diatom edit link
- hyperthesis 3y agoYay John von Neumann, genius of geniuses, also said Young man, in mathematics you don't understand things. You just get used to them.
- nlitened 3y agoYep, 10x that for real life.
- jiggawatts 3y agoThen you can start layering on the complexity by estimating repayments based on the expected variability of future interest rates, convert to Real Dollars based on inflation and expected wage growth, then compare with alternative options such as renting + investing, etc...
- maxglute 3y agoThere's a reason a huge part of technical architecture drawings is referred to as "detailing".
- gerdesj 3y ago"The first problem you’ll encounter is that cutting your 2x12s to the right angle is a bit complicated because there’s no obvious way to trace the correct angles." Rubbish or as we say here: bollocks. Chippies have been doing first fit for centuries. Its lovely that someone is discovering how wood and homes work. All power to you. Tomorrow - bricks?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- quantum_state 3y agoFeel all depends how one looks at things. For example, the vacuum, supposedly there should be nothing there. However, uncertainty principle allows fluctuations of all kinds which are not physically directly observable. If one looks at things at the level of principle, it is simple. However, if one tries to look into the actual fluctuations, there is infinite and unknown amount of complexity.
- jmugan 3y agoTo me, it's not so much that reality has a surprising amount of detail, it's that our brains make us feel like whatever model we have is complete. Same thing, of course, but focusing on the brain gets us closer to the cause.
- Probiotic6081 3y ago[flagged]
- bonyt 3y agoI have this comic on my wall at my desk.[1] It's about how much work goes into every detail of the everyday things we take for granted. I practice law, mostly patent litigation, and often my job entails untangling one of these stories. [1]: https://xkcd.com/1741/ https://xkcd.com/1741/
- narag 3y agoSeeing this here again, I was wondering if it's related to current events. I hope it isn't too soon, sorry to bother you in that case. Can't you see? Let me explain. The point of the post is that when you try to translate ideas to the physical world, there are plenty of quirks and you quickly find out what's the difference between theory and practice. That's why many people think that the chatting performance of an AI isn't a good measure of its ability to conquest the world. And that's why some are so fed up with the doom prophecies, they seem disconnected from reality. But I believe the general opinion has swung too much in the other direction and maybe, just maybe, it's not wise to completely stop thinking about safety.
- somewhereoutth 3y agoIf this comment is the best LLMs can do then really we have nothing to worry about
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- omneity 3y agoThis was a brilliant read for me back in the day (still is!) and gave me the inspiration to write a post[0] about detail abstraction, market forces and why you can't fit big cups in coffee machines. [0]: https://omarkama.li/blog/the-market-decides-your-project-scope https://omarkama.li/blog/the-market-decides-your-project-sco...
- akoboldfrying 3y ago>Frames are made out of the details that seem important to you. Beautiful, and explains so much.
- ashu1461 3y agoThis reminds of Dunning Kruger Effect https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FGnb2lgPBA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4FGnb2lgPBA people often tend to over estimate their capabilities and then only later once they start working on a project after some time realise that things are not that straightforward.
- mcmoor 3y ago> If you’re trying to do impossible things, this effect should chill you to your bones. It means you could be intellectually stuck right at this very moment, with the evidence right in front of your face and you just can’t see it. It has always chilled me to my bones. Whenever I tried to do a slightly non trivial things, I am afraid I miss the super obvious easy solution and get stuck for years before getting it. And it already happened several times too! Really, the only solution I can come up with is "experience"... and a lot of asking from different perspective.
- gregfjohnson 3y agoAfter much initial resistance, I've become a fan of pair programming. When things are clicking, ideas spark back and forth. Frames collide and interfere, bits of partial insight are exchanged, and you and your partner arrive at a solution that would have been impossible for either of you to get to working individually. There is the famous psychological notion of flow. The thing is, this can happen among multiple people. Think of a lovely choir or orchestra. Or a basketball team where every team member just seems to be reading other team members' minds. The book (and presumably the upcoming movie) "The Boys in the Boat" really emphasizes this and crystallizes this. As the linked article mentions, the author and his father butted heads for three hours because they were not listening to each other and pairing very effectively! Really good pairing does take work and practice. But when it starts to work there can be moments when it feels like magic. It is a great way to grapple with the myriad of unforeseen "details" that are actually life-or-death critical issues to project success.
- ulizzle 3y agoI actually think it's far better to pair program with ChatGPT instead of another human.
- ozfive 3y agoYes, because... Physics and you know, Math.
- clumsyninza 3y agoThe link doesn't seem to work.
- clumsyninza 3y agoThe link doesn't seem to work
- RagnarD 3y agoThis is an unusually rare, worthwhile piece. It's rare for somebody to be both very grounded, with a personal history of hands-on practical competence, yet simultaneously abstracting his experience to a high philosophic level.
- RagnarD 3y agoA nitpick is this statement: "The massive difference in weight between a rocket full of fuel and an empty one means that a reusable rocket can’t hover if it can’t throttle down to a very small fraction of its original thrust, which in turn means it must plan its trajectory very precisely to achieve 0 velocity at exactly the moment it reaches the ground." I don't think this is how SpaceX does it. When you have closed loop feedback control using velocity and distance measurements from radar and vectoring thrusters, it's no longer an impossibly difficult ballistic problem. I suppose that highlights the necessity of not making assumptions about solution methods.
- pjc50 3y agoThe original statement is correct: the rocket cannot throttle down to a small fraction, to an equivalent thrust to the mass of the rocket. SpaceX rockets indeed do not "hover" for any significant length of time. The trajectory is planned to achieve 0 velocity at just above ground level. The feedback control comes in because it's impossible to know the exact performance and atmospheric characteristics, so if you tried to do it by dead reckoning it would be off vertically by tens of meters, so the trajectory is continuously adjusted.
- keithalewis 3y agoAnother surprising detail is parents are exempt from child labor laws. /s
- dvas 3y agoThat's the thing with details; sometimes you don't know the extent or context in which they will occur. Your perceptiveness at a particular moment could determine a good or not-so-good outcome. However, you may not have the expertise or familiarity in a domain to spot micro, mini, or normal details. My personal takeaway is to be mindful when you are on autopilot to avoid missing details and to avoid keeping your blinders on.
- xg15 3y ago> The first problem you’ll encounter is that cutting your 2x12s to the right angle is a bit complicated because there’s no obvious way to trace the correct angles. You can either get creative (there is a way to trace it), or you can bust out your trig book and figure out how to calculate the angle and position of the cuts. My first thought would be using a string: Fix a string to the floor at one end and to the wall with the other end, at the places where you want the upper edge of the 2x12 to meet the floor and wall (the exact locations are "input parameters" that depend on your design, i.e. on how steep you want the stairs to be - you can't trace or calculate them) Then pull the string taut and now you can measure the exact length that is suspended in the air (which will be the length of the 2x12's upper edge) as well as the inner angles it has with the ground and wall (which will be the cutting angles from the upper edge towards the lower edge). Of course even this is easier said than done. I'd assume that keeping the string taut and not hanging through might be a problem (catenary curve etc).
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> If you’re trying to do impossible things, this effect should chill you to your bones. > It means you could be intellectually stuck right at this very moment, with the evidence right in front of your face and you just can’t see it. This speaks to me. It's terrifying knowing deep in your soul that something is possible but getting stuck trying to make it happen. When you try to talk to people, you seem a bit unhinged. Like some crazy person who's creating his own problems by avoiding the easy established solutions. People will straight up tell you it can't be done, they will ask you why you can't do it in the normal way. It's tempting to take their word for it and just give up. However, if you persevere a little and ask the right questions, they might just see that it is possible to do things differently. If you persevere a lot, you might figure out all the details and end up proving that it was possible after all. I achieved a small victory just like this a few days ago and I'm really proud of it, I'm actually preparing to Show HN.
- Misdicorl 3y agoEvery time this is posted I want to rebut the water boiling portion. It's finally time. The author gets the details of boiling water wrong. He commits a fairly common error: using his experience of a practical and common phenomena to make/guess a technical definition. The technical definition of boiling water is simply the temperature beyond which liquid water will not go (let's ignore super heating- too much detail!). The rest of the exposition is unnecessary and wrong given the true definition (although could probably be reworked from a cooking perspective)
- pinusc 3y agoThat's fair to point out. However, I don't think it detracts from the point: the definition is in some sense a detail, because there is a connection between "bubbles forming" and "the temperature water will not rise beyond", but it's subtle and assuming that one equals the other leads to error. The very reason we have that definition is that it's more precise, because in the real world there's details that escape narrow definitions as seen in school or in the kitchen. As an aside: I love the bubbling patterns of water as it heats, and it's actually a useful skill in the world of tea-making (especially in the gongfu tradition) to estimate the temperature of water based on the amount and size of bubbles. Nowadays I use a temperature-controlled kettle, but in the past I would get by with a clear borosilicate glass kettle and paying attention to the details, which is fun and rewarding in itself—if far less precise.
- wrs 3y agoThe way I read it, that’s why you’re supposed to imagine it’s the 1800s. All you have is the simple-sounding concept of “boiling”, and you’re trying to codify it by finding the temperature beyond which water will not go. At which point you start really paying attention and find the phenomenon is way more complex than your initial model of “water is either boiling or it isn’t”.
- Misdicorl 3y agoBut it rather isn't. The temperature keeps going up as you add more fire. And then it stops going up even if you add more fire. That point is the temperature of interest and was from the very start. It isn't hard to find. It isn't hard to understand. It's just a bad example for this essay
- Xcelerate 3y agoI’m a data scientist, and it always surprises me how much work goes into fields that do not require a degree — easily just as much (or more) thought is required to solve “daily” work tasks. I needed to redo a closet in my house where the original wireframe shelves were not installed correctly and fell out as soon as any weight was put on them. First you’ve got to patch the holes. But spackle will show flashing. Ok, so I’ll use joint compound instead. But there’s 27 brands and types, all for slightly different purposes. And there might still be flashing if you don’t use the right type of PVA primer. And you need the right sanding tools and, oh, it turns out I suck at applying joint compound so I have to call someone anyway to make it look like years of expertise went into that. On to the new shelves. Well I don’t want the closet to look like I did it myself, so I’ll get some floating shelves to make it look nice and modern. Wait, $1,200 for a piece of wood?? Can’t I just find a tree in the backyard and cut that myself? Oh... I need specialized equipment to make that look nice too. Whatever I’ll just order the shelves. Have the shelves, but now it turns out the tolerances on the walls in the closet weren’t that tight when it was built. It seems like the width of the closet varies quite a bit as you move away from the wall. So now there’s a gap. And the floating shelf metal bracket misses the nearest wall stud by 1/8th of an inch, which would halve its load capacity. I’ll just drill another hole in it. Oh, it’s stainless steel and that requires specialized equipment and fluid to prevent overheating and... So yeah, I totally agree with this article in every way. It’s amazing anything works at all in society.
- dymk 3y agoThe stairs in the article are probably not code compliant, even with all that work. The uppermost tread is cut short. Most locations require all treads to be the same depth, so his half-tread probably won't pass inspection. The stringers either need to land a little further away from the wall, or the stairs the need to be at a slightly steeper angle (but check local building code for the max permitted angle!). I built stairs with a friend years ago, and there are a lot of constraints to solve for if you want to build code-compliant stairs. A good parametric CAD system was very helpful. We could specify overall dimensions: stair rise/run, number of treads, thickness and width of the stock. It'd solve for the critical dimensions to verify, like tread rise, stair angle, tread depth, and the angles to cut the stringer ends to.