5 ms·
> It's so pleasant to deal with fiber. Consumers are absolutely brutal to cables. Minimum bend radius of copper cables get violated all the time, but copper ha
by Aurornis 3y ago
> It's so pleasant to deal with fiber.
Consumers are absolutely brutal to cables. Minimum bend radius of copper cables get violated all the time, but copper has a decent chance of continuing to work if bent back. Not so with fiber. Fiber would only work with some heavy armor.
Consumer fiber was actually tried in the past: Optical TOSLINK was briefly popular in the audio world. It was cheap relative to what you’d need for modern high speed fiber, but even that was too much to win out over copper. It faded away.
Even within professionally maintained data centers, direct attach copper is often preferred over fiber interconnects when it’s possible to get away with it.
Fiber is great when called for, but copper wins in practicality when you can get away with it. It’s been proven over and over again across industries.
> Meanwhile, Apple wants $70 a pop for a single, 1m Thunderbolt 4 cable, and that's only been increasing.
You picked the absolute most expensive cable as your benchmark. Look anywhere else and prices are lower and decreasing.
Also, you are wrong about Apple cable prices increasing. They’ve actually dropped the price of their longer cables.
But again, look to the overall market and you’ll see prices going down.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Consumer fiber was actually tried in the past: [...] It faded away. Not everywhere. It's still not as popular as copper but it's not extinct.
- ender341341 3y agoto be fair TOSLINK was a particularly bad standard and offers lower audio quality to similar or cheaper analogue devices. It's whole selling point was basically "it's fiber optic so that makes it better" while not actually being better.
- yummypaint 3y agoIt's literally the exact same digital signal sent over copper S/PDIF. The only meaningful advantage it offers is electrical isolation.
- xnzakg 3y agoDidn't stop manufacturers from making gold plated TOSLINK connectors though.
- pdpi 3y agoI wish I could dismiss that as a joke, but I have in fact seen some of those.
- pdntspa 3y agoIt fools the same people who somehow think toslink audio quality is worse over a bitperfect link
- ender341341 3y agoNo one's saying it didn't transmit the data bit perfect, but it re-encoded the media at a relatively low bitrate with a decently crappy codec which is where the crappy audio came from. EDIT: Looking closer at the wiki (it's been forever since I saw it used), it's when it's being used for surround sound that it compresses it super poorly, for stereo it's just PCM and sounds fine.
- ender341341 3y agoS/PDIF is also crappy in comparison to analogue audio of the time. EDIT: Looking closer at the wiki (it's been forever since I saw it used), it's when it's being used for surround sound that it compresses it super poorly, for stereo it's just PCM and sounds fine.
- RF_Savage 3y agoNo ground loops is a feature.
- atoav 3y agoLower audio quality? Nope. Toslink sends the actual bits that make up you audio digitally over the cable. If the receiving device does a shit job at converting the signal to analog, this is barely the fault of the standard.
- ender341341 3y agoThe codec they transmitted over the wire (regardless of the wire media) was crappy, not the wire itself, but in this case those imply the same thing as as far as I'm aware there was only the one format that it'd transmit over that connector.
- neckro23 3y agoWhat codec? It's PCM. You could also use that PCM stream to transmit Dolby Digital or DTS, but that's up to the device, not TOSLINK.
- ender341341 3y agookay, looking closer at the wiki (it's been forever since I actually tried it), for stereo it's full bandwidth, it's when it's surround sound it's super compressed.
- atoav 3y agoSuper compressed compared to what? Bluetooth?
- ender341341 3y agoCompared to pretty much any other output you'd have on an av receiver 15/20ish years ago (so hdmi, XLR, or some other standard analogue like rca or speaker wire). Possibly similar to the compression level of blutooth, don't have access to any systems that'd be easy to compare against these days for toslink.
- conradfr 3y agoIt's still used to link audio interfaces with ADAT.
- vlan0 3y agoHave you played with the newest bend insensitive fiber? You can wrap it around a pencil and an otdr shows no or minimal loss. But I think you’re correct about damage from average consumers. They’d destroy the ferrule in no time.
- Aurornis 3y agoThe failure mode with consumers is usually pulling cables against a sharp edge. Even a pencil has a larger radius than the edge of your desk or the corner of your computer case. You can buffer the radius by putting a thick jacket around the fiber, which is about the only thing that works. But fiber still isn’t a free lunch. The longest high speed cables already use fiber internally, but they’re expensive because they need extra optics and transceivers inside. Moving the extra fiber hardware into the laptop and client device would make the cables cheaper but make the hardware more expensive. That’s not a trade off that most people would take as most people don’t actually need long cable runs. The above comment was trying to use Apple premium cables as the reference for being too expensive, but opening Amazon shows plenty of Thunderbolt 4 cables in the $20-$30 range from other vendors. It’s really hard to imagine a scenario where forcing every cable to be a combination of fiber and copper would make things cheaper for us consumers.
- solardev 3y agoDo third party thunderbolt cables suffer the quality issues that usb cables have? (counterfeits, different standards, unclear specs, etc.?)
- DannyBee 3y agoB3/A3 Bend insensitive ginger can handle 5mm bend radius. You can wind it around a pencil with no issue. It does fine on the edge of a desk. 5mm is less than a quarter of an inch. I can send you video of beating the crap out of it against the edge of a desk if you want. I've watched tons of modern fiber and cat6 be abused. My dog dug up and chewed some. 0.5db loss. The copper next to it was a complete loss The fiber always wins. As for pricing. Once you get to 10gbps+ its at best a wash. Transceivers are 10-20 bucks. Cheap rj45 10gbps sfp+ are 2-3x that price. Produce a ton of heat as well. This will only get worse. 25gbps fiber transceivers are now almost as cheap as 10 gbps. Meanwhie, higher speed copper standards are much more expensive and produce even more heat. Higher speed fiber is dropping in price. Higher speed copper is not because nothing drives it anymore.
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoI've never even heard of a minimum bend radius, and I care about my kit so I do tend to read the docs that come with it. Where are such details given, because I'm now curious, thanks.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoI don't know about all cables, but Cat 6 has a generally accepted minimum radius of 4 times cable width and there's some standards to back that up. You can also find datasheets for industrial cable that specify it for fixed installations and repeated flex applications: https://www.sab-kablo.com/fileadmin/user_upload/pdf/catalog_gb/kapitel_E/CATLine_CAT_6A_DR_CATLine_CAT_7A_DR_en.pdf https://www.sab-kablo.com/fileadmin/user_upload/pdf/catalog_... (notably this has 5 times the diameter, so it wouldn't pass some standards) Consumer cables, not just Ethernet, probably do have such specifications when produced in bulk, but the manufacturer that turns reels of 1000 metres of raw cable might not include it in the end manual (just like they usually don't include the frequency response curves in there).