2 ms·
CSAM isn't just an arbitrary violation of law in context of phone monitoring. A false positive on CSAM detection won't just "report you to authorities". It will
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
CSAM isn't just an arbitrary violation of law in context of phone monitoring. A false positive on CSAM detection won't just "report you to authorities". It will straight up ruin your life. In terms of false positives, you'd be better off with a car that cuts off your hand when it detects alcohol in your breath, than with a CSAM scanner. The impact of losing a limb on your life will likely be less than having a mere suspicion of you perusing CSAM go around in the community.
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> will straight up ruin your life. If you are travelling between two cities in winter in Russia by car, and it refuses to start halfway, you die.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoFair. My point is more about this line from sillysaurusx's comment: > People had a problem with Apple monitoring CSAM on their phones. But monitoring blood alcohol in cars gets a pass. I.e. the objection would be fine if it was "Apple monitoring ${X} on their phones" for most values of X, but for X=CSAM, this is a qualitatively different issue - false positives are life-destroying, and you'd be at risk just by having an iPhone - a far more common situation than finding yourself in the middle of nowhere in a Russian winter.