7 ms·
DDG founder says Google's phone, manufacturing partnerships thwart competition
- fyokdrigd 3y agonothing propelled me more to the competition like owning a Google made phone.
- pixel8account 3y agoCan you elaborate? I was personally so happy with Pixel4 that I've decided to buy a new version when my phone lost support. I didn't have any specific problems, I didn't feel like I was forced by Google to do things I don't like, and when I started caring about privacy even more, I changed my OS to Graphene (something you can't easily do on Apple owned device, I believe). They're not perfect, but I'm genuinely interested what was the show stopper for you.
- fsflover 3y ago> I'm genuinely interested what was the show stopper for you For some people, directly supporting a huge, unethical, advertising company with money is a show stopper. > when my phone lost support This is another serious problem: e-waste. My phone will not loose support, ever.
- 8organicbits 3y agoWhat phone never loses support? I'd expect that cell network changes alone invalidate that claim.
- fsflover 3y agoI don't think that the OP was talking about the cell network changes when they said that the phone had lost support. GNU/Linux phones (Librem 5 and Pinephone) will never loose software support, since they run mainline Linux. Also, Librem 5 has a replaceable modem.
- rollcat 3y agoOh, Purism. The guys who included a separate chip to deny the user the ability to upgrade the firmware, so that they could meet FSF's completely arbitrary requirements for a honorary badge of freedom (see the hypocrisy?), but neglected an IOMMU, so the baseband (or any other device on the bus) can wreak unlimited havoc (see the irony?). Great alternative indeed.
- fsflover 3y ago> separate chip to deny the user the ability to upgrade the firmware This is false: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26784382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26784382 and https://old.reddit.com/r/Purism/comments/pcos2x/would_it_be_possible_to_put_grapheneos_on_the/hbbmez5/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Purism/comments/pcos2x/would_it_be_... > neglected an IOMMU, so the baseband (or any other device on the bus) can wreak unlimited havoc The Librem 5 doesn't need an IOMMU, because it uses separated components, and it uses serial buses (USB 2.0/3.0, SDIO, I2C and I2S) that don't allow direct memory access, so there is absolute no chance of the WiFi/BT, cellular modem, GNSS and USB controller being able to access the RAM or the SoC's cache From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30769589 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30769589 Do you think that all laptops are also totally insecure, since they use USB?
- lightedman 3y ago"No chance of DMA access" The USB URB structure have a field named 'dma_addr_t transfer_dma', used for DMA access. I've abused that to chain vulnerabilities. To boot, it is possible to develop an I2C-B2C or SPI bus master which is capable of DMA toward the host memory. Linux 2.5 kernels and later, USB device drivers have additional control over how DMA may be used to perform I/O operations. Do any of these guys actually read the hardware specs or do any real hardware hacking?
- graphe 3y agoCommadore 64 also hasn't lost support and McDonald's made a new Gameboy game. Android runs mainline Linux. The Linux phone has no benefits.
- noirscape 3y agoI wouldn't hold up GrapheneOS as a good example of more freedom compared to Apple or Google tbh. Their device depreciation policy is literally just Google, they refuse to support anything that isn't a Pixel (because of the security chip, although as I understand it, there's other manufacturers who could probably work as well - Pixel is simply chosen because Google promised to open up the microcode on the security chip, which hasn't happened yet) and their stance on user privacy is so extreme that it gets in the way of user freedom - they literally offer their own SafetyNet implementation and are aggressively against rooting whilst refusing to understand why people root to begin with (the most common reasons is by far hosts based adblocking and their recommendation, VPN based adblocking, gets in the way of a normal day-to-day VPN or something like Tailscale). (Relatedly - the toxicity problems of their community against criticism of GOS or even being interested in non-GrapheneOS privacy projects are well known at this point and with a smaller community, you're bound to run into something that isn't answered on the general internet at some point. This makes that component somewhat unavoidable. I've never seen a non-corporate, non-FSF run community be such extreme NIH types.) For freedom, I'd moreso point towards projects like LineageOS.
- throwawayapples 3y ago> I wouldn't hold up GrapheneOS as a good example of more freedom compared to Apple or Google tbh. I don't see why we can't have both, but this doesn't really a fair criticism of GP's comment. The specific word GP used was 'privacy', not 'freedom', and you are attacking GrapheneOS's stance on the latter, not the former. GrapheneOS is more focused on privacy over freedom, as you said ("their stance on user privacy is so extreme that it gets in the way of user freedom"). They have chosen to prioritize one over the other. > For freedom, I'd moreso point towards projects like LineageOS. This might be true, but LineageOS doesn't have access to microcode either, and certainly GrapheneOS is more 'private' than Lineage, assuming that GrapheneOS hasn't been compromised either internally or at some point in the AOSS supply chain. Except for niche mfgs like PinePhone et al, Google is probably the most free of the major manufacturers (ironically, less private but more free). I agree that we should aim for both freedom (as in free speech, not necessarily as in free beer although it'd be nice!) and privacy. Both are critically important, and the efficacy of the latter depends in large part on the former.
- mrweasel 3y ago> They're not perfect, but I'm genuinely interested what was the show stopper for you. Not OP, but: Google. I don't believe Google can be trusted with Android. I'm stuck with the iPhone, or getting a phone that can run CalyxOS, because I basically only need apps that a solely available in the Play Store. The thing is, I don't care for messing around and trying to make my phone work and flashing alternative operating system. So I'm stuck on the iPhone, because I trust Apple slightly more than Google.
- Goronmon 3y agoCan you elaborate? I was personally so happy with Pixel4 that I've decided to buy a new version when my phone lost support. I still use Android, but the lifespan of every Android device I've ever owned is two years or less. They just don't survive that long. Whether it was the old Nexus 7 tablet that hit a boot loop issue, or charging issues that I've run into on most Pixel phones. My previous pixel even had to be repaired (thankfully under warranty) because of the charge port failing. But again it died 6 months later right around the 2 year mark. The only saving grace is that I'm usually spending around $300 for the Pixel phones, so it's still likely cheaper than if a bought a higher end Samsung that lasted longer. Funnily enough, the longest lasting "Google" device I've owned is a ChromeOS Lenovo Duet that I purchased back in 2020. The tablet is decidely sluggish these days, so I don't really use it anymore, but at least it still functions.
- jandrese 3y agoOf the three Pixel6a phones I bought for family members less than a year ago two have had their eSIM support mysteriously and permanently stop working, and one has had its physical SIM stop working. Unfortunately, those failures were not evenly spread and now one phone is completely without cell service. Google's tech support response is basically "Wow, sucks to be you". Was quite the 180 compared to taking an iPhone into the Apple store.
- amadeuspagel 3y ago[flagged]
- siva7 3y agoWell, he was called in an antitrust trial against google, so what headline did you expect that doesn't contain the words DDG and Google?
- amadeuspagel 3y agoHe's been saying the same things, always focused on google and never apple, for a long time, and that's also why he was called in the first place.
- dwighttk 3y agoGoogle is a competitor… Apple isn’t
- eviks 3y agoNone of what you've said eliminates the issue highlighted in the title
- arp242 3y agoWhat search engine does iOS use in the US? Regardless, "the other guy is even worse" is a very poor defence. In fact, it's not a defence at all! And since Google is obviously DDG's main competitor, it's not too strange they're mainly focused on Google/Android.
- amadeuspagel 3y ago> What search engine does iOS use in the US? I really love this idea of Apple as an innocent company that has been corrupted by Google. Maybe we can raise some money so that Apple doesn't have to prostitute itself to survive?
- 3y ago
- hackideiomat 3y agowhat's up with the title?
- rickdeckard 3y agoIt's misleading/wrong as an "and" from the article headline was replaced with a comma and it now states that "Google's phone thwart competition", which is certainly not what was said
- taneq 3y agoA large corporation establishes strategic partnerships with manufacturing and distribution partners? Shocked.
- meiraleal 3y agoHere, I fixed for you: A large monopoly colluding with manufacturing and distribution partners
- kevincox 3y agoThe problem isn't that they are making partnerships. The problem is that they are using the success of Android and Google Play Services to force their search engine which should be seen as an unrelated service.
- crossroadsguy 3y agoAnd this gives unfair advantage to Apple. People who would have rather not ventured within a mile of an ‘as closed as it gets’ iPhone are kind of forced to, because Google on the other hand makes it between a rock and a hard place.
- criddell 3y agoI don't think there are very many people who fit that profile. Most iPhone user are pretty happy with the device. If there were a lot of people like that, I think the Microsoft Phone would still be around.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoYeah. Google wiped out all the freedom we used to enjoy with hardware remote attestation. Now there's no reason to put up with Android's inferiority anymore. I'm just waiting for them to finally break Termux. I'll buy an iPhone the very next day. Maybe postmarketOS will gain support for more devices but without WhatsApp support it's hopeless.
- Aardwolf 3y ago> Android's inferiority This must be personal preference. For me the #1 thing I do on my phone is browse the internet, and having choice of browser is a vital priority in this. Android allows you to choose browser, the other big maker only supports a single browser engine.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoAt this point I wouldn't be surprised if Google just got rid of Firefox for having uBlock Origin support.
- jsnell 3y agoSo, what does that actually mean? You think there's a 50% probability that Google waves a magic wand and "gets rid of Firefox" in let's say the next two years? 10%? 1%? 0.01%?
- hunters_laptop 3y ago[dead]
- jmyeet 3y agoMy general stance is to be more aggressive with antitrust matters than the US tends to be. However, antitrust doesn't (and shouldn't) protect you from competition. Too often I see companies just do a really bad job and the leadership just sits there collecting a paycheck and complaining to Congress about [big bad company]. Yelp is the poster child for this. Arguably even Mozilla is guilty of this [1]. DDG ultimately is just repackaged Bing search results. Bing itself lags behind Google and has the resources of a trillion dollar company behind it. It's not just a question of how much money you have but how you spend it. Look at Blue Origin. Look at the Metaverse. So DDG's upper bound seems to be however good Bing is and honestly Bing isn't that good. What is their path to improving? I'm not sure they have one. But I don't think Google's relationship with Apple is the core problem. Back in the day, Microsoft got in trouble (rightly) for bundling the browser. That's because the barrier to installing a new browser was quite high. Here phone manufacturers give you a dropdown to change it (which I think they should be required to do, as they are). Antitrust won't solve poor execution. [1]: https://calpaterson.com/mozilla.html https://calpaterson.com/mozilla.html
- rat9988 3y ago"So DDG's upper bound seems to be however good Bing is and honestly Bing isn't that good. What is their path to improving? I'm not sure they have one. But I don't think Google's relationship with Apple is the core problem." To improve it you need money, and you won't get any if the competition field isn't even. So, it's part of the core problem. It's very reductive to look at it and say you are bad because you lack research and development in this front, but you have to look at the whole picture. "What is their path to improving? I'm not sure they have one." Doesn't mean they don't have one.
- madeofpalk 3y agoAre you saying Microsoft doesn't have enough money to make Bing better? How many dollars would it cost to make Bing better?
- jmyeet 3y agoI specifically addressed this with the examples of Microsoft's billions not stopping Bing lagging behind Google, Meta spending billions on the Metaverse and Bezos spending billions on Jeff Bezos (and still not getting to orbit after 25 years). DDG could improve if Bing improves so the problem isn't Google, it's Bing and DDG's strategy.
- 2-718-281-828 3y ago[flagged]
- tyingq 3y agoI'm not sure HN points mean much other than something like frequency of visits and participation.
- crazygringo 3y ago> But Weinberg testified that getting users to switch from Google was complicated, requiring as many as 30 to 50 steps to change defaults on all their devices, whereas the process could be shortened to just one click on each device.“The search defaults are the primary barrier,’' he said. “It’s too many steps.’' This is hard to take seriously. 30–50 steps across all of your devices, maybe if you have 10 devices. And a desired "one click" is similarly silly. Just opening an app takes a click. It's pretty reasonable to take another couple clicks to get to the setting, and a final click to set it. I mean, Chrome has larger market share than Edge or Safari, and it's not default, and I'd say it takes more work to download and install a browser than change a search default. So it's pretty clear that when users perceive something as better, they switch. None of my non-tech friends have ever even heard of DDG, so that's going to be the start of the problem right there. Not Google's payments.
- manderley 3y agoInstalling another browser is way easier than changing the search default.
- crazygringo 3y agoNo it's not. And it takes much longer too.
- Apofis 3y agoThis is wild. Try to change the search engine of Edge.
- freediver 3y ago> DuckDuckGo’s internal surveys, he said, show privacy is the biggest concern among users, beating their desire for the best search results. Interesting, our own (anecdotal) data is the opposite. Better search results trump everything and this is the main selling point of a paid search engine. Privacy is important, but less people would be ready to pay for a privacy respecting search product without also better search.
- kazinator 3y agoBig words from a flea on the ass of Microsoft.
- joanfihu 3y ago“In court Thursday, Lehman said his best guess is that search engines will shift largely from relying on user data to relying on machine learning.” This is a good point. Foundational/Frontier models already pack lots of contextual knowledge that makes user behaviour data collection less relevant. Whilst building AskPandi, I have only found user’s location to be the only major signal that would greatly improve search results and answers.