6 ms·
Extremely large telescopes at risk
- system2 3y agoFor those who might not read the whole thing, here is a summary: The Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes have astounded with cosmic images, but a new era of Extremely Large Telescopes (ELTs) is emerging. With mirrors up to 39m in diameter and advanced optics, ELTs promise 100 times Hubble's light-gathering power. The European Southern Observatory (ESO) aims to complete the 39m European ELT in Chile by the decade's end. The US projects, Giant Magellan Telescope and Thirty Meter Telescope, face funding challenges, prompting a call for the US National Science Foundation to lead and consolidate efforts into a single ELT project.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 3y agoSo there doesn't seem to be any 'risk' as all projects are going ahead just fine. Well except Hawaii but that's not a new problem. The space based platforms are also not at any risk, they still have capabilities the land based ones will not have such as the ability to see wavelengths absorbed by the atmosphere, weather independence and the lack of satellite interference.
- Dalewyn 3y agoHubble is going to require a reboost and perhaps even a maintenance mission some time within the next decade, so that's a very real risk to that mission ending. I hope we can figure something out. At this point, I argue even just keeping Hubble flying is a great boon for space exploration advocacy. Otherwise though, I agree there isn't any "risk" insofar as anything hitherto unseen. Science projects fighting for funding is nothing new and positively mundane.
- gruturo 3y agoWouldn't it make sense to allow it to decay and spend the money on something more modern? Optical sensors have had great advances in the meantime, the original Hubble lenses were wrong and a correction had to be installed, and the cost to put something in low orbit went down a lot. Also we have better understanding of the failure modes of gyro bearings so we can build them to be less failure-prone (someone more knowledgeable please correct me if I didn't get this right). The original solar panels must have degraded quite a bit by now, so you'd eventually have to replace those too - overall it doesn't feel cost effective to keep fixing the thing.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>Wouldn't it make sense to allow it to decay and spend the money on something more modern? Objectively speaking? Yes, money would be better spent developing and launching a newer and better Hubble 2.0. But remember: This is the Hubble Space Telescope we're talking about here, Hubble has acted as the de facto ambassador of space for many generations of people today. The Hubble Space Telescope is a cultural icon of space exploration, it isn't just a space telescope anymore. Consider that when the Space Shuttle program was on its final legs, NASA was convinced to fly one last reboost and maintenance mission to the Hubble because it is the one and only Hubble Space Telescope. I personally think it's worth spending money to preserve and use Hubble as long and far as we can.
- gruturo 3y agoValid point but the solution is right in your own post: Just call it Hubble 2.0 and preserve its symbolic value. Spend a little telescope time to repeat a few of its most iconic shots (Ultra Deep Field for example), post them side to side, people will love it and it'll still be Hubble.
- light_hue_1 3y ago> Wouldn't it make sense to allow it to decay and spend the money on something more modern? It wouldn't. The cost to boost Hubble and keep it around is small. About the cost of an ISS resupply, less than $150M. The cost to build a replacement? Unbounded. JWST was supposed to be completed in ~5 years and cost $1B. It took over 20 years and $10B. The cost of boosting Hubble won't impact any replacement we might design.
- DiogenesKynikos 3y agoGround-based telescopes have capabilities that space-based telescopes do not. You can build much larger telescopes on the ground, attach much larger and heavier instruments to them, and perform regular maintenance and upgrades. Space-based and ground-based telescopes are not interchangeable, and you need both in the modern day.
- zzbn00 3y agoThe editorial is a little indirect but the funding challenge is the key bit. What the editorial is saying is that both the currently private projects in US to build the new generation of ground telescopes need government money to be completed but it is unrealistic for government to fund both. Therefore the government should pick one to take over and then make sure it has enough money to be built.
- throw0101b 3y agoTom Scott on the ELT in Chile: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QqRREz0iBes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QqRREz0iBes
- OldGuyInTheClub 3y agoGiant Magellan has several of its 8+m mirrors built while Thirty Meter has been fighting native Hawaiians who are not happy with any telescopes on Mauna Kea. GMT would be the safer bet. Blows my mind that the larger EELT will beat them both to first light.
- wthomp 3y agoThere’s a bit more to it than that. GMT is further along but its design has many compromises versus TMT. Also, a second ELT in the southern hemisphere is less useful than one in both Hemispheres. The situation for TMT on Maunakea is definitely tricky, but it’s also a better site than either of GMT’s or EELTs.
- OldGuyInTheClub 3y agoI've been told (but can't confirm) that the GMT instruments are farther along, as well. I agree that a northern hemisphere telescope is necessary and I'd like to see both get built. I'll defer to others on whether Mauna Kea is superior to the EELT site since Chile hosts a lot of extremely successful observatories. I like to think I'm sensitive to the wrongs done to indigenous populations but can't come to grips with the Native Hawaiian's protests. Nevertheless, they have worked and there is no end in sight. Isn't TMT still hedging with a backup site in the Canary Islands? It looks like NSF has to arrange a shotgun wedding between Carnegie and Caltech the way it did with Caltech and MIT over LIGO. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/behind-tomorrow-s-telescopes-a-bitter-rivalry-from-yesterday/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/behind-tomorrow-s...
- wthomp 3y agoMy understanding is that the AO system for GMT is going to pose quite a challenge. A big topic of ongoing research is dealing with “petaling” where the separate primary mirrors in phase due to the atmosphere. For combining the projects, it does seem like that may be the only option funding wise, but it’s hard to imagine what the resulting observatory would look like. Maybe it would have to be a completely new design?
- ck2 3y agoWe must build the ELT if only so we finally have a ground telescope that can resolve the lunar landing sites, lol (it would only be a few pixels but still that's insanely harder than you'd think, no previous other telescope, no gigapixel image can resolve it otherwise)
- bhaak 3y agoWe already pretty good images of some landing sites. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_evidence_for_Apollo_Moon_landings#Ground-based_telescopes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-party_evidence_for_Apoll...
- Sharlin 3y agoOnly from lunar orbit.
- falserum 3y agoI’ve read somewhere that to see flag sized objects we would need telescope size of entire earth. Not true?
- alfiopuglisi 3y agoNot true, but you still need a pretty big one. In order to resolve a 50cm object 238k miles away (average Moon distance) at visible light wavelengths you need a telescope with a diameter of 500 meters. In order to resolve some details on such object, say have 10 distinct pixels on it, you need 10 times as much. Since resolving power only depends on the distance between the two extreme viewpoints, you could get away with two separate telescopes separated by 5km. But optical interferometry is extremely hard and, to this day, not very successfull.
- sapiogram 3y agoWonderful comment, thank you!
- BenjiWiebe 3y ago
- cratermoon 3y agoAnother risk to ground-based telescopes: "Bright satellites are disrupting astronomy research worldwide" https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-03610-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-03610-5
- 3seashells 3y agoEvery mass produced sattelite should have an eye on the away from earth side. Constellations should be telescopes by default
- OldGuyInTheClub 3y agoSynching multiple optical telescopes into a single aperture is ... hard. Observatories also have special-purpose instruments behind the glass. Can't imagine those being split into small enough pieces to disperse into a constellation. Also, low LEO isn't great for many kinds of astronomy.
- sapiogram 3y agoYou won't be able to do much astronomy with a smartphone camera mounted to a cubesat, unfortunately. It would be very cool, but not useful.
- mkl 3y agoWe're not talking about cubesats and smartphone cameras. The second-generation Starlink satellites are so big they're waiting for Starship to be ready (2000kg each, with solar arrays 20m long [1]). [1] https://starlinkinsider.com/starlink-gen2-satellites/ https://starlinkinsider.com/starlink-gen2-satellites/
- imiric 3y agoAnd yet there are tech apologists who claim that dark paint, sky size and AI filtering make this a non-issue. I have much more primitive objections to this. I want an unobstructed view of the universe with the naked eye. I want to know that when I look up I won't have to wonder whether a bright object is an artificial satellite or an object in space. It's bad enough that light pollution has made it impossible to see the universe from cities. The tradeoff of losing visibility of space from anywhere on the planet for the convenience that these things provide is not worth it. Especially when many of them are used for spying and military purposes.
- codeulike 3y agoTelescope naming conventions need some work https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Large_Array https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_Large_Array https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-Mile_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Half-Mile_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-Mile_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-Mile_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremely_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extremely_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overwhelmingly_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overwhelmingly_Large_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kilodegree_Extremely_Little_Telescope https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kilodegree_Extremely_Little_Te...
- stargazer-3 3y agoObligatory xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1294/ https://xkcd.com/1294/
- Yizahi 3y agoMissing some, to cover the whole spectrum :) Barely Acceptable Telescope Mildly Average Telescope Just Big Enough Telescope
- xanderlewis 3y agoOK You’ve Made Your Point This Is Getting Silly Now Gigantic Telescope
- Sharlin 3y agoIf telescopes were named like Culture ships
- candiodari 3y ago[flagged]
- pvaldes 3y ago
- 7373737373 3y agoIt might be insightful to see a cost breakdown of these projects