6 ms·
A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "100 percent fatal"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rebuilder 3y agoWhy, exactly, will people in the future want to take the preserved brains of dead people and bring them back to life in some digital heaven? I can think of a few incentives for them to do so and it doesn’t seem appealing to me from that point of view alone.
- xenospn 3y agoIf you haven’t watched “the creator” yet, there’s a scene that depicts exactly that. Bringing a dead soldier’s “mind” back to life in another’s body so they could recount their last moments.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- prepend 3y agoI think the first few preserved will be a novelty. I have associates who are really into trans humanism and the services they’ve bought include the resurrection in the price. So the person interested in resurrecting is the same individual paying to preserve themself.
- duskwuff 3y ago"Get a load of this guy's brain! He thought he was some kind of AI pioneer and we'd build him some kind of robot body in the future..."
- sterlind 3y agowhy do people digitize old books? why do archaeologists use CT scanners to painstakingly read fragile rolled-up scrolls from thousands of years ago?
- softg 3y ago>why do archaeologists use CT scanners to painstakingly read fragile rolled-up scrolls from thousands of years ago? I was under the impression that we haven't read a lot of old scrolls, tablets, etc. because it costs money and most of them are uninteresting. A lot of clay tablets just document financial transactions iirc. I imagine the first human to be "revived" from a frozen brain would be quite a feat. 100000th? Not so much. Would the future archelogist still care about that? I think I'd like to have my brain frozen -ideally after a long and fulfilling life- just for the heck of it but the chances of a future civilization with the means and the will to resusciate a large quantity of random damaged brains from the past is low.
- arcastroe 3y agoI'm more concerned about TOO many people wanting to revive your preserved digitized brain. Imagine the technology is so mature, anyone can take your "johndoe.brain" file and simulate it on their local hardware/machine. Worse, your digital brain is now in the public domain and free for anyone to download and use for any purpose.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoIf someone wants to read a fictional story that takes a deeper look at this scenario, "Lena" is an excellent read in the format of a Wikipedia article: https://qntm.org/lena https://qntm.org/lena
- arcastroe 3y agoThis was a very entertaining and frightening read, thank you. I loved the Wikipedia format.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoPlease check out the rest of Sam's fiction - it's all very, very goodl.
- ChainOfFools 3y agobrilliant and sublimely haunting piece. I knew it would come up in this thread somewhere. I only wish it were slightly shorter and less involved in some of the weedier details, because it's current form is rather Limited in the audience that I can share it with, most people just don't have the time even if they do have the curiosity. would be an excellent way to introduce the bigger picture agency problems, of effectively handing out -intentionally or not - a perpetual "clone me" license to anyone who wishes to use your consciousness for any purpose up to and including unrestricted torture and sadism. "uploading your consciousness into a computer" gets generally positive interest from people ( like myself, before encountering some of this material) who haven't given much consideration to the consequences of subjecting ones individual human consciousness to open source licensing and 'market forces.'
- graemep 3y agoThe article says they preserved a pig brain. Can they preserve it. It seems to assume that all the information that constitutes the brain function that defines some one can be physically preserved. What if some is in the form of signals that require the brain to function continually to be preserved?
- LoganDark 3y ago> What if some is in the form of signals that require the brain to function continually to be preserved? This. We don't know if a brain keeps all information necessary for a "reboot" or not. It may decay over time if whatever machinery necessary to first "start" consciousness is never used after birth. I've used some psychedelics recreationally, and as far as I can tell, at least my consciousness is definitely affected on an ongoing basis by whatever signals happen to be in the brain. It's some sort of feedback loop and I'm not so sure how easy it would be to just start up again if it ever ended. Simulators may have to just guess, and the simulated brains could end up with an altered consciousness compared to when they were alive.
- aftoprokrustes 3y ago> This. We don't know if a brain keeps all information necessary for a "reboot" or not. It may decay over time if whatever machinery necessary to first "start" consciousness is never used after birth. We do not even know what consciousness is. I am not even sure there is an agreed upon definition that would fit the layman's understanding of what consciousness is. The hypothesis that consciousness is a by-product of brain/nervous system/body activity is, in its current state, just this: an hypothesis. Not only that, but it is pretty much an hypothesis outside of the field of modern scientific models, which are based on a materialist methodology (assuming that everything has a material cause), such that we do not really have mature ways to study anything else. The materialist ontology ("there is nothing else than matter") only developed later in history, once the methodology was so established it became accepted as fact, rather than just as a (very successful) method of working. It might be polemic, but there is also data from the study of NDEs and memories of past lives in infancy which, in my opinion and that of many others, should at least motivate us to stay open to the possibility that consciousness is something more than a by product of brain activity. Some propose that the nervous system could act as a form of "receptor", in the same way a radio receives a program. You cannot experience the radio program without the device, but it does not mean that the radio "creates" the program. Obviously those theories are no less wild guesses than the consciousness-as-byproduct ones, but they show that other models can have internal validity and cannot just be rejected because "obviously the cause must be in matter". I could go on and on, but to people interested in going down this rabbit hole, I always recommend the report of the Galileo commission, and detailed call by academics to open the width of interpretations of consciousness that are considered acceptable enough to be studied: https://galileocommission.org/ https://galileocommission.org/ All of this to say: we do not know anything about consciousness, so any such business is just preying on rich people afraid of loosing it all or unwilling to contemplate their life decisions, as one feels drawn to when the end feels close. It is sad and absurd. (Before I get burned to the altar of scientific wisdom: I did not say that the theory of consciousness-as-a-byproduct is absurd or should not be studied. It is good to test it and try to make it work, and I have deep respect for the researchers in this field. I just argue that, in the current state of our science, there is no reason for it to be the only acceptable theory)
- jnwatson 3y agoThere's a great show on Amazon Prime with a similar premise. The uploading process is hilariously gruesome and also 100% fatal.
- LoganDark 3y agoWhat's the name?
- throwaway5959 3y agoUpload. It’s hilarious and has totally put me off the idea.
- dudul 3y agoSeason 1 was great. Been going steeply downhill since then. But yes it does have this premise.
- athriren 3y agoThere is also an animated show called Pantheon that deals with “uploaded intelligence” and the process is likewise fatal. I can’t recommend it highly enough. It had two seasons and the story was completed.
- gerikson 3y agoPantheon is great. I had almost given up on good SF in visual media when this was recommended to me.
- LoganDark 3y agoI would never be on board with such a thing. Because even if I were to be backed up, I wouldn't get to experience the simulation. I would experience death, and then a backup would experience the simulation. SOMA is a great game that touches on this topic, btw. It's like a movie, so watching a playthrough is almost as good as the game itself.
- brhsagain 3y agoSomeday we may be able revive the brain itself by connecting it to a body, in which case you would experience falling asleep and waking back up.
- fu7kt 3y agoOr you end up with a pile of dead wolverines in the fish tank in your basement.
- catchnear4321 3y agothere’s your problem right there. wolverines don’t breath water. you gotta leave them out of the fish tank.
- LoganDark 3y agoI'd love to wake back up in a non-human body, honestly. That could, theoretically, be a way to appease those who suffer from species dysphoria. Not any time soon, though. I'm not sure if there have been any studies on it yet - people are only just starting to recognize gender dysphoria as a legitimate condition. Species dysphoria probably sounds utterly insane.
- Reyka9 3y agoI assume you're a therian? I don't experience either gender or species dysphoria, but that seems like a way to "cure" species dysphoria, unlike gender dysphoria which is actually workable. I know a few therians and really feel for them, having such a condition and not being able to do much of anything doesn't sound like a fun existence.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThe mind is more than the brain, we are just learning the connection to the gut for example...
- LoganDark 3y agoI like the theory that the CNS is part of the brain. So the spine, organs, connections between them... there are actual neurons in the stomach, for example.
- sterlind 3y agoYes, but in quadriplegics that connection is severed, and while it results in a lot of unpleasant medical issues, spinal cord injury doesn't alter cognition (other than the depression from coping with a severe disability.)
- LoganDark 3y agoOf course it doesn't affect consciousness to a significant degree, since metacognition largely (or entirely) happens within the actual brain. But you still receive signals from other places, and losing them detracts from the experience of actually having a body, imho. I'm sure quadriplegics can attest to feeling like they've lost parts of their body, since they sort of have.
- sniperjoe360 3y agoI wouldn't have my brain frozen unless we have a better understanding of the fundamental stuff that makes up consciousness. The mind is more than the neurons and synapses. Yes it's a necessary condition to have a brain but consider the following anecdotes: 1. Under anesthesia, the neurons within the brain are fully connected and have access to blood and other resources of the body, yet it is not functioning at all. No pain, respiratory drive, no memory 2. Patients with large parts of their brains removed, or large parts of their brains injured by stroke, can recover fully to a point that is functionally indistinguishable from their previous intact state.
- jlpom 3y ago1. The neurons are simply not firing /exchanging neurotransmitters. 2. That’s not true. They might look they have recovered but passing a standard cognitive test and the artifice will go away. The brain is notoriously bad at healing itself because mammals and especially humans don’t produce new neurons after teenage apart from very restricted areas (SVZ, stratium, which are still controversial btw).
- realusername 3y agoI see the usual joke 'it's not a backup if you haven't tried to restore it" also applies here. Absolutely nothing guarantees you the "backup" can be used for anything in the future.
- wgj 3y ago(2018)
- robwwilliams 3y agoThis is silly, at least to a neuroscientist. Yes, let’s assume that the physicalist or naturalist interpretation of our sense of self and its content are entirely held within our cranium. And furthermore assume that a reboot is possible—as from deep sleep or anesthesia. This leave the open question if what resolution is required to take a snapshot of the embeddings? I don’t think mist neuroscientists would be satisfied with just a perfect synaptic-level connectome. One would almost certainly need to know the the deeper state of each presynaptic and postsynaptic junction. The postsynaptic molecular complex is an assembly of over 500 protein species embedded in and below the plasma membrane. And many of these molecules are labeled by their phosphorylation states in functionally very important ways. The resolution required to obtain a functional read-out is almost certainly at the atomic level. We are beginning to get close to this level with cryo-electron tomography, but it will take an atomic resolution version of magnetic resonance imaging to achieve the throughput one would need. The dataset would probably be measured in exabytes. In comparison, a superAGI might be able to run a damn fine simulation of you or me if given 25 years of sensory input and all behavioral output. But to what purpose other than some ill-defined vanity. Try a mouse or rat first before soliciting VC funds. Has the Human Brain Initiative even managed to nail one 500 mg mouse brain? Not even close!