8 ms·
US govt pays AT&T to let cops search Americans' phone records without warrant
- moose44 3y agoDoes anyone know if using a Jabber client instead of a carrier can work to prevent this sort of thing?
- gaogao 3y agoBetter to use something with robust end-to-end encryption like Signal
- _8j50 3y agoIs that why Signal collects your phone number? Hah. Any E2E app that doesn't collect your phone number or any identifiable info that you can use as a standalone app on the desktop and E2EE is the only way it works (not optional or opportunistic like jabber/xmpp, whatsapp, matrix, telegram,etc...) and is developed ouside the US by a well known/reputed dev(s). Is what I recommed. Check out wire and briar if they meet these requirements. Personally, I would not use digital media if I don't want the US gov knowing about it entirely. The solution is legislative not technical. Kind of like how you get a free TSA body massage at the airport, the people have willed it.
- jvanderbot 3y agoWell there's layers here. You could easily snoop who is messaging whom, but it's very different than knowing what is being messaged. End to end encryption would protect the second. Carrying a second phone intuitively protects the first, but in reality does not.
- woodruffw 3y ago“End-to-end encrypted” and “private identity mapping” are orthogonal properties: a chat system can have both, but doing so is significantly harder (both in terms of engineering complexity and teaching users to operate the system safely). Signal chooses (or more accurately chose, since they’re working on eliminating it) to depend on telephone numbers for identity mapping, which was and is a reasonable design constraint given their target audience.
- throw10920 3y ago> which was and is a reasonable design constraint given their target audience Who do you think their target audience is, and why do you think that this a reasonable constraint?
- barsonme 3y agoTheir target audience is literally the general population. It should be obvious why phone numbers are a reasonable constraint.
- _8j50 3y agoNo, that's the deception of signal. The general population is already using other identifiers like whatsapp and viber numbers (which almost every country outside the US use even more than sms). Signal refuses to opt-out of phone number collection and usage. With the tens of millions at their disposal and with the time they spend on mobile payments, crypto,etc... you are telling me they can't auto-generate identifiers as alternative to phone numbers? They can't make it alphanumeric and consider any id that is all numbers a phone? It's all culting around tech/crypto personalities and ignoring the obvious things that don't pass the smell test. Explain to me why Signal is special as opposed to more popular apps made for the general population that also do E2EE? Explain to me specifically why phone numbers and mobile usage is not optional? Even after like a decade of people begging for it? This is a lot like PGP email, the same circles of people promoted it (still do in some cases) but the government loves it because email metadata is unencrypted and tech circles insist on email dependency on every app because of the same cult mindset even though hostile middle parties love it. Everything I do in amazon, netflix, uber, slack you name it you can tell my whole life pattern just looking at email subjecte in the clear on an MTA! All because of tech sector refusal to apply critical thinking and creativity when it comes to these things. So again I ask, if I am allowed to criticaly examine Signal: why is it special and unique that it needs phone numbers no matter what? Especially given device compromise of people you talk to is not in their threat model. e.g.: you are a source and the journalist's phone is compromised, that is exactly what governments do! If signal didn't collect phone numbers all they would see on the journalist's phone would be your nick or in-app id, but thanks to signal they can find out who the source is, and using exploit kits like pegasus this way is not uncommon! Real people are put in danger by signal. Look at all my downvotes and tell me this is not tech sector conspiracy or at best culting after personalities.
- moose44 3y agoI use signal but, most of my contacts do not. I've opted for porting my phone number to JMP.chat which does offer E2EE. However, the recipient must also have an encrypted Jabber account.
- madars 3y agoThe claimed features (see pg 5 of https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/wyden_hemisphere_surveillance_letter_112023.pdf https://www.wyden.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/wyden_hemisphere_...) operate at a cell service level, so as long as your phone is still connecting to base stations the answer would be "no." Take, for example, "Linking multiple devices/phone numbers to an identified target" -- even if you use Signal on two phones and never do regular text/call, if the two devices travel together (e.g. connect to the same carrier base stations) one can make a guess that they are related. This has much wider applicability than the drug investigation mandate: e.g. you could use such capability to identify who is meeting with which investigative journalist.
- rollcat 3y agoI think most privacy-conscious people have a pretty good idea about how to maintain proper private key hygiene (key should never leave the device, use FDE + a passphrase or a hardware token, etc). But we've been leaking metadata (such as mail headers) left and right ever since PGP was a hot new thing, something which should've been our primary concern no later than since Snowden/2013. It would be good to have a proper field guide written down, that's a little more in-depth than "leave your phone at home", weighing risks vs convenience, going into detail on what kinds of metadata you might be leaking, etc. Most of us have some rough idea but it isn't at all obvious the way we know "MD5 is broken".
- moose44 3y agoInteresting. Thank you for sharing. So faraday bags and removing sim cards all together is the best course of action?
- xethos 3y agoIf you want generic advice, it's "Faraday bag or pull the battery". "Off" isn't "Everything is off and nothing will communicate via any radio" on every handset, and some will connect to towers without a SIM in case you need to make an emergency call.
- upofadown 3y ago
- fredgrott 3y agoits the meta-data they are accessing not the call itself, which means the title is somewhat misleading as no one would ever need a warrant in the first place!
- RyJones 3y agoProbably SS7
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sschueller 3y agoIs the system restricted enough that some 20 person town with one sheriff can't access a persons phone records located 1000 miles away?
- lupusreal 3y agoOf course not.
- lettergram 3y agoDoes it matter?
- sschueller 3y agoYes, some small town cop might not have any oversight and if he starts requesting phone records of "famous" people it can quickly become a huge issue not that warrent-less access isn't already an issue for everyone else.
- altcognito 3y agoThe rich and powerful always have ways of protecting themselves. Whether they choose to avail themselves of those services is another matter.
- Ensorceled 3y agoSo .... All good? They deserve what they get? Not sure the point of this comment.
- SpaceL10n 3y agoI'm not a cop, but how can I get access to this Hemisphere system? Do I pretend to be a cop and walk into a police station, open the start menu and click on Hemisphere, and then "search all"? Seems doable.
- cj 3y agoYou'd probably be arrested. Not for accessing Hemisphere, but impersonating a cop.
- youcantcook 3y agoYou willfully ignoring the main question which is how does one physically go about making this happen
- halJordan 3y agoNo, you, and the author, are assuming the antecedent which we have to do to make your question relevant. If we do assume that what is done in public, which you've willfully involved a 3rd party in, is somehow 4th amendment protected- it isnt and never has.
- alt227 3y agoAT&T are a private company. Ring them up and offer them $1 Billion and they will probably give you access.
- rockskon 3y agoThey're being offered 8 million here, no?
- kotaKat 3y agoThere are jurisdictions in the US that elect local judges and justices of the court that have zero votes at election-time[1]. You could always just move to the middle of nowhere and write yourself in and hope for the best. And in some places like New York, you need no experience to become one.[2] [1] https://www.wwnytv.com/2023/11/15/st-lawrence-county-struggling-find-judges/ https://www.wwnytv.com/2023/11/15/st-lawrence-county-struggl... [2] https://www.northcountrypublicradio.org/news/story/35988/20180412/how-does-ny-go-about-turning-a-regular-person-into-a-judge https://www.northcountrypublicradio.org/news/story/35988/201...
- luxuryballs 3y agoIt kinda sounds like they are AT&T’s phone records.
- lettergram 3y agoThat’s not historically how it works in the US. If government comes to you and says, “hey, so we have the ability to regulate you, imprison you, etc. Now we can do that, or you can accept this payment to give us access to private records — you have a day to decide” Most people call that blackmail, even if it is government. Second, it’s still a search and seizure of your records. You made the call, AT&T was only the common carrier connecting you. Regardless, of whether or not they paid to conduct the search. Now the judiciary is pretty slanted to supporting law enforcement so it will take time to play out. Often the higher courts are more apt at deciding these issues (ie less bias) That said, there’s a tendency in the US justice system to protect the system. So we will see how it shakes out in 5 years while this makes its way through
- Jensson 3y ago> If government comes to you and says, “hey, so we have the ability to regulate you, imprison you, etc. Now we can do that, or you can accept this payment to give us access to private records — you have a day to decide” Who said the Government blackmailed them? These companies are selling this data to every large corp asking, not just the Government. You give private corporations way too much credit here, if they can earn a buck they will sell your soul.
- orochimaaru 3y agoThe government does blackmail. They will freeze you out of government and defense contracts if you do not cooperate. I would also bet that every other carrier has a similar arrangement, not just AT&T. Furthermore, if the DOJ contracted them to build the system there would have been due diligence on the legality and process.
- Jensson 3y ago
- sobakistodor 3y ago[dead]
- krapp 3y agoAmerica's government actually innovates a simple free market solution to the bureaucratic and regulatory burden of the Fourth Amendment, and Americans have the gall to complain. The nerve. Just imagine how many tax dollars are being saved on bribing judges alone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- asynchronous 3y agoI believe there’s a Lennin quote somewhere about capitalists “selling the rope with which we will hang them with”.
- annoyingnoob 3y agoEven with recent FCC changes, I still get as many spam phone calls as legitimate phone calls. There should be a nearly unlimited number of these spam call records, should be easy to investigate the sources and stop them.
- NvrTronaldDump 3y agoIf this got used to support the schemes of Project 2025… I can’t imagine anything darker.
- DangitBobby 3y agoSo who's going to jail for violating constitutional rights?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> who's going to jail for violating constitutional rights? Why does someone always have to go to jail? Just stop the program. Once it’s clearly illegal you can start adding to our list of incarcerated.
- doublerabbit 3y agoWhy not both?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Why not both? Because if I do what my boss told me to do, what has been done for ages without consequence, and you’re going to pass a law putting me in jail for it, I will expend every effort to thwart it. If, on the other hand, you’re saying “stop it,” my give-a-shit factor is lower. The broader public is indifferent about the Fourth Amendment. Polling and elections and listening to phone calls from constituents shows this. Activating a concentrated mass of political energy against yourself, in this context, is not a bright idea. Also, it’s wild how cavalierly we’re willing to contemplate taking away someone’s freedoms in a conversation about other freedoms.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoThis was supposed to be an important freedom; a pivotal one in fact. It deserves more protection than "oopsie! Ok we promise to stop violating the rights of untold thousands". I think it shows considerable restraint, to ask for the incarceration of a handful of offenders, compared to the flagrant abuse of the rest of everybody.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago
- SN76477 3y agoIf you do not know what you are looking for you should not look. If you know what you are looking for get a warrant.
- account-5 3y agoSpot on.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoCurious that the annual funding has dropped to extremely low levels. It looks like they have no more than two or three people supporting this program. I wonder if AT&T has alternate revenue streams for this data.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tagyro 3y agoMore info about Hemisphere on the EFF website @ https://www.eff.org/cases/hemisphere https://www.eff.org/cases/hemisphere
- rsingel 3y agoAlso a reminder that AT&T has long done more than just collect records and let the feds have them. They've been data-mining them to create community maps and maybe even your historical location. They've done so for decades and in the early 2000s even invented their own programming language to do it. https://web.archive.org/web/20170129095532/https://www.wired.com/2007/10/att-invents-pro/ https://web.archive.org/web/20170129095532/https://www.wired...
- MaryGab 3y ago[flagged]
- rabbitofdeath 3y agoThis reminds me of one of my favorite articles: https://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2013/06/09/using-metadata-to-find-paul-revere/ https://kieranhealy.org/blog/archives/2013/06/09/using-metad... This is a great article to share with friends who don't understand how dangerous this is.
- b112 3y agoI wonder. After all, this is a demonstration on how the British could have identified, and stopped key players in a rebellion, yes? And you think people will be upset about the concept? This is a poor example to use. edit: I see lots of downvoting, but people... be realistic. The average person will only see that a rebellion could be stopped. This isn't an example which explains negative outcomes to them well. People will give up all due to fear. Hell, people will give up all privacy to Google for beads and trinkets! And this example shows a government being able to thrwart an actual, violent rebellion! The average Sally and Joe will think "great"!
- JadeNB 3y ago> edit: I see lots of downvoting, but people... be realistic. The average person will only see that a rebellion could be stopped. This isn't an example which explains negative outcomes to them well. I think you underestimate the American investment in our founding myths/stories. This is probably a bad example to convince an English person, but I imagine it would have considerable visceral appeal to an American.
- thangalin 3y agohttps://dave.autonoma.ca/blog/2019/06/06/web-of-knowledge/ https://dave.autonoma.ca/blog/2019/06/06/web-of-knowledge/ "Metadata is information about information. A library’s card catalogue is an example of metadata: it contains details about the library’s books, which themselves are treasure troves of information. Metadata about a phone call can include: who called whom, what date and time the call was placed, each party’s location, and the call’s duration. ... "Had such metadata been available to the Third Reich, it is easy to imagine that Kelly would have been flagged by encoding 3 (homosexual) on a punched card, arrested, and his death recorded by encoding 4 (execution), having been found guilty by association. There are other explanations for Kelly’s actions that, knowing the conversations’ contents, would lead to completely different interpretations."
- Dig1t 3y agoWhy doesn’t anyone organize a protest or march for stuff like this? I would join that.
- closetnerd 3y agoI would join as well. And donate.
- Andrex 3y agoBecause movements that get large enough get co-opted by one side or the other, filled with bad-faith actors from the other side, and filtered through an agreed-upon media narrative. AT&T did divest CNN at least, and no thanks to the US Gov't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- verisimi 3y agoIt's necessary that government and large corporations work in tandem to prevent terrorists and child abuse. The point of government is to keep us safe. Without government, licensing, laws, fines, taxes, etc, etc we would keep 40% more income... But no one would want to build roads sadly, and the terrorists and child abusers would be rampant, unlike today. Thank you big G!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pubutil 3y agoI can’t say that I’m terribly surprised. AT&T has been complicit in mass surveillance in the past. The first example that comes to mind is Room 641A: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A Frankly, I think it’s safer to assume that most (American) communications companies are involved in some level of surveillance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- patrick451 3y agoWe need lifetime jail sentences for people who violate the bill of rights. They entire department and any cop who uses this should be rotting behind bars in solitary confinement for eternity.
- sneak 3y agoExtended solitary confinement is torture that causes permanent physiological damage to the mind; we should not be torturing criminals, regardless of their crimes.
- patrick451 3y agoThe J6 protestors would like a word. Violating the 4th amendment is as bad or worse than the crimes they committed.
- krapp 3y agoThe same bill of rights that bars excessive, cruel and unusual punishment?
- patrick451 3y agoCruel is being hanged, drawn and quartered or skinned alive or sent to Guantanamo Bay.
- brudgers 3y agoThe motivations and behaviors of the GDR were not unique to the GDR. It just had the will to pursue those behaviors in analog.
- philsnow 3y ago> "We defer to the Justice Department, to whom Senator Wyden's letter is addressed, for comment," the AT&T spokesperson said. "Like all companies, we are required by law to comply with subpoenas, warrants and court orders from government and law enforcement agencies." Okay, sure. But, are they compelled by law to keep 40 years’ worth of call records, and not only keep them but in an easily indexed manner? If they aren’t, then clearly there is something going on. Those records probably aren’t that cheap to keep around, compared to not keeping them around. They’re a public company with shareholders; if it were less costly for them to get rid of the records they presumably would have already gotten rid of them, so.. what’s going on?
- landemva 3y agoFeds would typically pay yearly through classified budget to have this access. They simply procure it like everything else, then hide it in reams of black budget.
- TriangleEdge 3y agoMorality discussion aside, isn't this anti-competitive? Instead of passing a law for all carriers, the govt picked a winner and gave them money?
- sandworm101 3y ago>> the govt picked a winner and gave them money? That is what government procurement means. Any competitive process comes before the award of the contract. After that point everyone is generally locked into a one-customer one-seller situation.
- mcmcmc 3y agoJust because it’s how it’s done doesn’t mean it’s not anti-competitive. Government procurement should be sourcing from multiple vendors and requiring interoperability from all of them. Otherwise it’s way too easy for megacorps to lobby their way into a contract and offer products at a loss before cranking up replacement and repair costs by a 10,000% markup since the govt has no choice but to pay it.
- closetnerd 3y agoThis is unacceptable.
- alfredpawney 3y agoOh my gosh. This kind of thing was suposed to be harder after the breakup of Bell.
- Eji1700 3y agoAnd might have been had we cared at all as they rebuilt it way larger.
- AnonCoward1969 3y agoAn even better reason to start using open source phone operating systems and E2E encrypted communication. hint: https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Devices https://wiki.postmarketos.org/wiki/Devices
- okdood64 3y agoSerious question: How is this any better than using an iPhone, and using a legitimate E2E communication app?
- SamuelAdams 3y agoIt depends. Phone carriers can still get metadata about iMessage. What phone numbers you are connecting with, when you send them, etc. Even if the actual content is encrypted, the metadata could be useful.
- okdood64 3y agoSignal or Telegram?
- rzl1235 3y ago[dead]
- SamuelAdams 3y agoThis here. Consumers should expect that their data will be sold as soon as it is available to another company. Facebook, Google, etc proved that user data is lucrative. Why is it surprising when other companies want to jump on the same money-making stream? Users don’t read terms and service agreements anymore. As long as companies include data collection and selling the data in the ToS, and customers continue to agree to it, what is the problem? Customers can either vote with their wallet and move to a provider who respects their data, or they can push their elected politicians to make the sale of data like this illegal.
- celdon25 3y agoDidn’t something like this happen during the George W Bush presidency with AT&T as well?
- heroprotagonist 3y agoThis is the trade-off you have to make if you want your flagrantly problematic mergers and acquisitions to pass anti-trust evaluation.
- maerF0x0 3y agois the implication here a form of quid pro quo between the Government not threatening anti-trust for information in return?
- maerF0x0 3y ago> Few have made a dent: it appears that the Feds are doing everything they can to keep Hemisphere secret. This to me is the most concerning part. The government has a legal way to get that information, but belligerence to serve the rights of their citizens? That's particularly concerning, like they've forgotten who they serve and work for.
- wutwutwat 3y agoThey didn't forget, they just never worked for the people you thought they did.
- ssss11 3y agoHmmm I wonder why large corporates can collect so much data on everyone without competent regulations….. /s
- bioinformatics 3y agoBiden ia the best president in history
- MaryGab 3y ago[flagged]