4 ms·
All good points, but I do want to add context for users of this site who don't have any experience with manufacturing or physical trades - the commentary above
by digdugdirk 3y ago
All good points, but I do want to add context for users of this site who don't have any experience with manufacturing or physical trades - the commentary above about manufacturing welding should not be interpreted as welding being a low skill activity.
The same distinction between "manufacturing" welding and "construction" welding should probably just be applied within all types of welding in general. It's all about the application. Welding just sticks two pieces of metal together, so to use glue as an analogy - it can be used to stick macaroni to paper for a primary school activity, or used during surgery to save someone's life. Same action, two wildly different skill levels required for a successful result.
Having spent some time with prototyping shops and custom product manufacturing houses - those welders are insanely talented. There is an wild amount of knowledge required (metallurgy, chemistry, physics, electronics) to be used in practice, and the physical demands (fine motor control, holding pieces or your body under complete control at various angles/positions) should not be underestimated. Couple that with the understanding of the product being produced and how their actions can improve the end design, and you're left with what I tend to see as the closest thing to a wizard as we have in the modern era.
It's like the old saying goes - "Give a man a hammer and everything starts to look like a nail. Give a man a welder and everything starts looking like whatever the hell he wants it to be."
- hef19898 3y agoCame here to point out the fact that manufacturing welding, for anything that is supposed to hold against loads, is anything but unskilled labour.
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoI get that when it matters they will examine and x ray joints etc. But still, it really is humbling/scary to think how dependent each of us is on someone else doing their job just right. So many instances across our lifetime, one mistake and you would not be here anymore.
- hef19898 3y agoThis dependence is a thing since someone else made your hunting spear. Good thing, today way more than one thing needs to go wrong to end in a catastrophy (human error excluded).