Please note that the case was not appealed, certain questions were remanded to the European Court of Justice for it to decide sine the applicable rules are harm

Please note that the case was not appealed, certain questions were remanded to the European Court of Justice for it to decide sine the applicable rules are harmonized within the EU. Further the Advocate-General does not decide anything, he/she merely presents a recommendation to the Court. The actual decision is still pending and it is not publicly known when it will be available. In other words it is presently not known what the law is in the EU regarding the copyrightability of programming languages.