3 ms·
Now that he’s back with MSOAI I think we’ve got AGI disaster in 7 years. Thin possibility of good path for humanity. I wish he’d stuck to his guns and gone his
by keepamovin 3y ago
Now that he’s back with MSOAI I think we’ve got AGI disaster in 7 years. Thin possibility of good path for humanity. I wish he’d stuck to his guns and gone his own way, no MS, and no OAI. No disrespect to MS, they good, but this path is bad.
- Abekkus 3y agoIf you want to be a doomer, you don't need agi, just autonomous weapons, which ML can definitely help build.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoYou don’t even need ML for that plus it already exists, Soviets had Dead Hand decades ago, an autonomous weapon system capable of ending the world.
- Abekkus 3y agoAutononous weapons capable of ending the world are old, yes. Autonomous weapons capable of securing territory and resources, and personnel, that's on the way.
- keepamovin 3y agoInteresting. Do you have any specific program heads-up about this? I'm curious to read more. :)
- kjkjadksj 3y agoWhat might be interesting to think about is the prevalence of human controlled drones in warfare today, in various environments and climates as we currently speak. Right now they require a human to operate and identify targets or perform defensive maneuvering. All of this videography is undoubtedly being logged and used for training more autonomously controlled drones. Eventually an operator would just deploy a swarm at a sector akin to flagging it for an air strike, and drones would eliminate anyone or anything of interest there.
- rvba 3y agoSounds like Terminator 2
- keepamovin 3y agoMaybe I'm reading you wrong, but...So any counterpoint to your AGI view is irrational pessimism? I'm not bein doomer, this is just what I see going forward. I think AGI can be positive, but it depends vastly how we configure that. And this is not the path that I see is best. That's it. I get if you're a 100% AGI optimist and see any dissent to that as out of touch, but it's a leeetl disrespectfully reductive to try to frame other people's views that way, don't ya think?
- Abekkus 3y ago“DisRespect and insult” is a strange take on strategic advice. And While I’m already probably on a few lists, I don’t feel safe spelling it all out
- keepamovin 3y agoI didn't say "insult", but "doomer" is not strategic advice, right? That's what I meant. "Doomer" is a bad thing, yeah? You didn't have to say that. Maybe I'm reading you wrong, but it just seems like you were being disrespectful and reductive of other people's views, as I said.
- Abekkus 3y ago"Doomer" is a description of someone who is predicting doom, it doesn't have to be dismissive. Barring some miracles, I'm a "doomer".
- nfkcjbf 3y ago[flagged]
- EvanAnderson 3y agoWe don't need AGI for an AI disaster. Enough humans using AI-based tools to drive important decisions (read: outsourcing thinking) will stand in place of the "G" just fine. Corporations have been acting in this capacity (making massive changes to the ecosystem, human lives, etc) just fine. The corporate "organisms" have caused humans to erect massive projects to shave a few milliseconds from HFT, for example. AI-based decision support tools will just make that process more efficient.
- keepamovin 3y agoI agree with you there, that's a good point too. But it doesn't mean that we can't have a disaster from AGI, too. Hahaha! :) So many disasters, how to keep track of it. Easier not to think I guess. I'm going to go back to programming my remote browser, it's a lot simpler than trying to think of the fate of the world. Hahahah! :) Corporations have been acting in this capacity (making massive changes to the ecosystem, human lives, etc) just fine. The corporate "organisms" have caused humans to erect massive projects to shave a few milliseconds from HFT, for example. AI-based decision support tools will just make that process more efficient. I like your thinking man, I want to hear more of it. Where can I read your blog? When I have time, away from saving the world of course. Hahaha! :)
- qeternity 3y ago> The corporate "organisms" have caused humans to erect massive projects to shave a few milliseconds from HFT, for example. I will never understand peoples obsession with HFT. It is a shockingly small industry when compared to what it does (one of the reasons pay is so good). The bias is totally unwarranted: if a retailer were to come out and discuss how engineering efforts that improved response times increased sales, we would all read and congratulate them. But when HFT do it, they are lambasted.
- rsanek 3y agoIt sounds like he did stick to his guns though right? He still gets to do whatever he wants with the people he picked.
- keepamovin 3y agoIdk. I don't see it like that. He capitulated in coming back. Returning to a structure that had betrayed him. Hopefully the board reset enhances his power, based on the view that we want him to win, but I think striking out on his own would have been the better path for humanity, and equate with sticking to his guns.