4 ms·
Is it too late to keep global warming below 1.5 °C?
- TheTxT 3y ago> When representatives from 197 countries arrive in Dubai this month > Is it too late to keep global warming below 1.5 °C? Seems like it, yeah
- fwsgonzo 3y agoConsidering that no matter what we do we will go to 2C, I'm not exactly understanding this article? The UN currently warns that we will go to 3C at the current rate: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/20/world-facing-hellish-3c-of-climate-heating-un-warns-before-cop28 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/20/world-fa... Is this some kind of lobbyist think-tank article that 1.5C is still achievable? Citing IPCC reports is not funny anymore.
- Yizahi 3y agoThis is what greenwashing gets us. Instead of at least attempting combating climate change for real (gas sequestration, sun shield, spraying chems in the atmo), we are busy shuffling existing emissions around with "credits" and label polluting stuff "green". I remember last thread on the gas sequestration on HN ended with a uniform hate on the initiative, because it was proposed by the oil&gas corpos (sure, they are bad, but someone needs to at least start trying to capture and bury GH gasses). Oh well, guess our children will be happy with 490-500 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere by 2100 and all the nice "green" energy around.
- esarbe 3y agoI'm not sure if climate engineering should have been the first tool to reach for. Limiting emissions would have definitively been the correct first step. Alas, this comes 40 years too late. The oil and gas companies really kneecapped any action since the 1980ies with their FUD and denialism and sponsored attacks on climate scientists.
- Yizahi 3y agoActually now that that I think about it I can agree in principle that climate engineering should not be our current priority. Because it is too late for it. The known possible solutions are way too hard and underdeveloped for humanity to even attempt in the reasonable timeframe (100 years for example). We probably should start preparing for the mass cascade failures of ecosystems and instead develop genetically engineered crops for future projected climate zones, and genetically engineered animals, insects, fish etc. to accompany them. Genetically engineered humans too (gasp! horibul eugenics, no wai!).
- jfengel 3y agoLimiting emissions would have definitively been the correct first step. Acknowledging that it's a real thing would have been the correct first step. Instead, we're still deluged with the conspiracy theory that it's all a massive hoax.
- Yizahi 3y agoIsn't current estimate at around 2.4-2.9C? And that's current one. Considering that emissions only increase, we may blew past 3.0C easily.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- suoduandao3 3y agoI think this headline broke Betteridge's law.
- esarbe 3y agoIt did, didn't it?
- esarbe 3y agoNo, of course not. We'll just continue business as usual and keep expanding our industrial base and the associated emissions until a magic technology appears and we're all saved. I mean, that the plan, right?
- volkadav 3y agolol. we'll be lucky to keep it under 3x that, given that drastic coordinated action on the scale of the second world war with no fuckups or backsliding would be required to keep at two degrees, and people are involved in implementing any of that, with all the falliability humanity brings to anything and everything. i hate to be a doomer, but i'm just not optimistic that humanity is capable of that degree of coordination on a global scale.
- iteratethis 3y agoThe trajectory is 2.5C or even more. People will resist draconian measures because most won't be alive to witness the worst of it anyway. Behavioral changes as well as tax/cost increases will not get us where we want to be with any speed. Our only hope is technology and exponential progress. Many models assume a linear progress in their calculations, but sometimes a fly-wheel occurs where all of a sudden, everything happens all at once. In my town (population: 10K), 10 years ago nobody had solar. 5 years ago, 5% had it. Now you won't see a roof without it. It's contagious. We need to make this go viral in a way that does not belittle or stress people, it should be seen as beneficial to the individual.
- psychoslave 3y agoMaking an exception to Betteridge's law of headlines, I would say YES. Ok, I mean, maybe "no", if humankind disappear completely in a matter of weeks, or some significant part at least, to the point industrial civilization won’t be logistically possible anymore for at least a few centuries. Otherwise my bet is we are collectively too dumb to overcome issues generated by our own technical advancements. I sincerely hope I’m wrong though. Also, I don’t think there is really anything we can do that will make Earth completely inhabitable. Maybe unsustainable for any human, but surely life will go on still for a few [bm]illion years here in one form or an other. :D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines
- esarbe 3y agoI'm not worried about Earth. Earth will be fine. Give or take a few million years and not much of mankind's adventurism will be left and the ecosystem will have restored itself. It will just be the end of that whole "mankind" experiment.
- TacticalCoder 3y agoGive or take a few billions years and earth won't be fine. These aren't reasons to not worry about what concerns us directly now. > It will just be the end of that whole "mankind" experiment. Even the universe shall come to standstill eventually, when the last moving photon will stop moving or something. Should we be nihilistic and do nothing because of that?
- esarbe 3y ago> Should we be nihilistic and do nothing because of that? No, not at all. But let's be honest about the stakes. We don't need to save Earth for Earth's sake. We need to save Earth for our own sake. This is not about tree-hugging and kumbaia-singing. This is about the survival of our global civilization.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> When representatives from 197 countries arrive in Dubai this month... An emirate who's development wouldn't have been possible without the invention of air conditioning (and that's not a criticism). It's kinda weird to picture representatives from the entire world discussing global warming in one of the warmest countries on earth, where basically the entire country runs on air conditioning.
- incomingpain 3y agoYes, I will soon have tropical weather in Canada. Changing from Brrr climate to beach weather climate. #winning.
- seec 3y agoConsidering the behavior of people around me I wonder why we still waste time talking about it. In my opinion there are only 2 possibilities: - an authoritarian government spread globally and put in place consumption/production restrictions to all humans. Of course, that's basically impossible and saying it would be unpopular is an understatement. As it is, the rich countries are barely reducing and that's with delocalizing a good amount of the larger emitters like manufacturing. Now go tell 3rd world countries they still stay poor because if they try to achieve western lifestyle, we will all burn. Good luck. - many catastrophic failures occur and enforce an emission reduction but mostly because many humans die and the rest feel content with what they have now. Outside of that it's not even worth discussing. I see everyday people with enough money to not have to work or do any kind of consuming activity burn more petrol in a week than some do in their lifetime. There is just no way out of that. The rich are the ones who should be responsible yet they are the least likely to comply, so it doesn't matter...