2 ms·
Given that Twitter/X is a private, contractual space (you see T&C even if you click through) which routinely implements the function of editor, and thus has an
by ggm 3y ago
Given that Twitter/X is a private, contractual space (you see T&C even if you click through) which routinely implements the function of editor, and thus has an editorial even if the owner is in denial.. I think it fails at the door of a free speech test because free speech in law in the US is about Government restrictions on public speech.
so 1) the body in question is not a government 2) the space in question is probably not a public space in any real sense 3) because of 1) and 2) "free speech" is the wrong basis to complain about behaviours on this channel.
He chose to go to law in the US. He views the world through a US lens. Other jurisdictions might impose other expectations and requirements.
Arguably on a duck test Twitter/X "is" some kind of public speech commons. A very odd one, and a trans-national question. But I would expect a competent US legal team to tell Musk to insert his <part> in some <orifice> and <epithet> away.
BTW IANAL and I am not trying to play one. If a real L decides to tell me how I'm wrong I'd be delighted to be schooled.