3 ms·
... because you couldn't reproduce a Rembrandt unless you happened to be, or hire, Rembrandt. In the old days, they didn't think about IP because they didn't ha
by gaius 15y ago
... because you couldn't reproduce a Rembrandt unless you happened to be, or hire, Rembrandt. In the old days, they didn't think about IP because they didn't have to: it was enforced by the laws of physical reality.
- icebraining 15y agoThat's not really true - there were a many painters who could copy a Rembrandt that would look real to anyone but an expert. The difference is that the reason people put so much value on a Rembrandt is not because they want to look at a nice painting but because of social signaling, and that can't be copied. Most painters were not Rembrandt, though, and they still made a living even if they didn't provide that signal.
- njharman 15y agoCopy not reproduce. Still can't reproduce a Rembrandt. Original is a unique, limited, and (very) valuable object. Copies or representations in other media (e.g. photographs, jpegs) are practically unlimited. If they are copyrightable their value is almost entirely due to artificial scarcity and monopoly that copyright provids.