4 ms·
Yeah, so? Would the ads be contaminated by being in close promitity to unrelated to them ads? This charade is used since the dawn of internet to police media a
by coldtea 3y ago
Yeah, so? Would the ads be contaminated by being in close promitity to unrelated to them ads?
This charade is used since the dawn of internet to police media and social media outlets using advertising boycotts.
- wenderen 3y agoI'm no adtech expert but I suspect that potential customers would form mental associations between two things that often show up together, like pro-Nazi content and the ads I'm sponsoring, and I wouldn't want that.
- coldtea 3y agoYeah, right, they see Apple's ads 24/7 in all kinds of mediums, and alonside 100000 tweets of all persuassions, but it's the 100 tweets most wont even ever see, unless they follow those people, that they'll make associations with the brand...
- ryandrake 3y agoCome on. No mainstream brand wants to be even remotely associated with this content. Merely appearing on the same screen as content that “touts Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party” is enough of an association to tarnish a brand. If you don’t believe this, start and invest in a wholesome brand and then advertise on Stormfront. This is Marketing 101. > During all of this Musk-induced chaos, corporate advertisements have also been appearing on pro-Hitler, Holocaust denial, white nationalist, pro-violence, and neo-Nazi accounts. Yaccarino has attempted to placate companies by claiming that “brands are now ‘protected from the risk of being next to’ potentially toxic content.” It seems the company knows that this stuff is on there and is paying lip service to protecting brands from it.
- jstarfish 3y agoI'm surprised Stormfront haven't leveraged their own notoriety to do the opposite-- conspicuously support and endorse companies like Apple. Apple's wholesome lineup of all-white products is right in line with Nazi ideology.
- throwaway290 3y agoApple with its white laptops is racist same way building white buildings in hot climates is racist. Not that it has to do with cooling and energy conservation...
- rsynnott 3y ago… Eh? I think Apple’s last white computer was the short-lived plastic MacBook, which was replaced 15 years ago.
- jstarfish 3y agoIt occurs to me I haven't actually seen an Apple product outside of protective cases in years. They've added a lot of silver to the mix. I was thinking mostly of those white monitors everybody goes for in their minimalist-aesthetic offices.
- rsynnott 3y agoThose are generally LG, not Apple.
- coldtea 3y ago>Come on. No mainstream brand wants to be even remotely associated with this content. Come on. Mainstream brands would not care less if activist idiots didn't make a fuss about them appearing together (to use the negative PR to force their censorship upon the medium blackmailing it through the advertisers). If those activists cared about the Nazi tweet, and not for controlling the medium, they'd take offense to it alone, not in relation to whomever ads happen to be shown at the time.
- smoldesu 3y ago> use the negative PR to force their censorship upon the medium blackmailing it through the advertisers It's not blackmail if these companies didn't consider the content disagreeable in the first place. Turns out a lot of companies want to save face at any cost, and they will abandon your platform the moment it deviates from their values. If you didn't expect this from Apple, IBM and Oracle, you must have been on vacation when advertisers did this on YouTube: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-38965377 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-38965377
- throwaway290 3y ago> Would the ads be contaminated by being in close promitity to unrelated to them ads? Ads on Twitter are almost indistinguishable from tweets that they require a triple take to notice that they are ads, so yes very much so? Even IRL ad and billboard placement decides how much demand you get and how much you can charge for ads. But here the ad is not even visibly separate from context. The ad literally becomes product placement. Imagine you were reading Mein Kampf and there was an ad for IBM disguised for part of the book. For Musk's new Twitter to be successful would require this radical content to be so mainstream and accepted that advertisers are genuinely not worried about such a scenario because if you're an ad company like Twitter/Google/Meta/etc then ad placement is your biz. Twitter's previous way of appealing to big advertisers was delicate public image and bland content moderation policy but Musk apparently thinks he is Trump level business genius that would free Twitter from burning money by political posturing.
- coldtea 3y ago>Ads on Twitter are almost indistinguishable from tweets that they require a triple take to notice that they are ads, so yes very much so? Really? Does the text or ideology leap out from the tweet's DIV and goes into the products or personel of the company's in nearby ads? Does Apple also become Republican or Democrat, seen next to a tweet from either supporters too?
- throwaway290 3y agoIdeology is in the eyes of the beholder, not in the product or personal. Maybe you expect the beholder is perfectly informed, can distinguish an ad from a tweet in 3 ms and can override a million years of evolution through sheer will making neurons that fire together not wire together, but advertisers probably don't. And guess what they are the ones who got the money By the way, you really just compared being Republican or Democrat to being a Nazi or antisemite?
- mindslight 3y agoIn a different universe with Musk actually being the hero some people think he is, this would be a fantastic argument to get behind. Hey advertisers, we are a content-neutral pipeline. Your ads are only showing up next to this type of content for people who deliberately set out to view that content. We believe in principled free speech, and people's right to say this despicable stuff so that it can be soundly rejected in the public sphere. We hope you'll continue to do business with us, and support the American ideals of freedom, but if not there are plenty of other websites to advertise on. However back in this universe, the most sympathetic interpretation of events is that Musk has a debilitating social media addiction causing him to regress to the adolescent edgelord phase. And so the argument that the site is a content-neutral conduit falls completely flat when the chief forum admin is spending his time personally boosting the vile content!