2 ms·
The real problem, in my view, is that the board's stated mission is simply impossible. The amount of potential profit precludes ever "burning it all down" regar
by JohnFen 3y ago
The real problem, in my view, is that the board's stated mission is simply impossible. The amount of potential profit precludes ever "burning it all down" regardless of how unsafe it may be or how earnest the board is. The Big Boys would never let that sort of money escape them.
Assuming AGI is possible at all, this is why something like OpenAI should never have even been started if the concern was anything like ensuring safety or even being a net benefit to the world.
Fortunately, I think AGI isn't possible (at least not within a short enough timeline to matter). But I do think there's been nothing but recklessness in terms of what has already been accomplished. In the short term, uninvolved others are inevitably going to suffer. I have a problem with any group of people deciding that others are expendable.
- bogomipz 3y ago>"But I do think there's been nothing but recklessness in terms of what has already been accomplished." Could you elaborate on this? Specifically which accomplishment(s) you consider to be reckless.
- JohnFen 3y agoThis technology threatens to put too many people out of work too quickly, and there's a large risk of widespread harm resulting. It's reckless to move forward with something like this while failing to take any steps to mitigate the risk. Worse, they seem to totally disregard this risk, justifying that disregard with some hand-wavy "it'll all be better in the long term" stuff.
- Joker_vD 3y ago> Fortunately, I think AGI isn't possible "Fortunately"? That's a strange way to phrase that. Most people in 1928 thought that the repeat of the Great War isn't possible but it happened anyhow in just 10 years. Heck, nobody thought WWI, in the way it actually happened, could be possible! A world-wide war, in a globalized (yes, it was globalized about as much as in the 1990s) economy? A war where people would just keep dying on the field from both sides without any territorial advances, and keep doing this for years, and the involved countries mostly just waiting to see who will first run out of the resources (spoiler: Germany and Austria ran out first, because the US got involved), material and human? Nah, that's just un-scientific fantasy only some silly socialists like Wells could come up with.